Tom's Hardware > Forum > Computer Peripherals > Flat Panels/ LCDs > 17" better image quality than 19"?

17" better image quality than 19"?

Forum Computer Peripherals : Flat Panels/ LCDs - 17" better image quality than 19"?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

In a 19" monitor, aren't the pixels farther apart than in a 17", resulting in lost image quality? I edit video, and image quality is important, so I'm wondering whether to get a 17" or 19". I've seen both in stores, and the size is hardly noticeable. Are there any 19" with a slightly higher resolution?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +

Quote :

In a 19" monitor, aren't the pixels farther apart than in a 17", resulting in lost image quality? I edit video, and image quality is important, so I'm wondering whether to get a 17" or 19". I've seen both in stores, and the size is hardly noticeable. Are there any 19" with a slightly higher resolution?



Both 17" and 19" have the same resolution, 1280x1024. The pixel size of 17" is .264mm, and on 19", .292mm. Therefore, the images on a 17" should be sharper, though smaller.

The maximum/native resolution is fixed by the standard of display type and size. So, all of the same size and type should have the same maximum potential. (The chip which drives the display is better in some than others which accounts for differences between brands.)

The sharpest resolution theoretically should be the one with the smallest pixel sixe. In widely availabale models, that is the 20.1" UXGA, 1600x1200, @ .255mm.

Reply to Hose

Some added thoughts for video editing:
* compare the 6-bit and 8-bit models to see if you can tell the difference
* compare the matte finish LCDs with the glossy finish ones. The matte finish will give solid colors a blotchy look, which can be annoying for precise image editing.
* consider an IPS based panel, since viewing angle issues on the other panel types will cause colors to shift a little from one end to the other; you have to decide whether you can notice this; it may not be as big of an issue for video editing as it is for accurate image editing
* watch some videos on the monitor and see if the screen door effect bothers you. Even on the high dot pictch of a 20" LCD, I notice the screen door effect on areas of similar color in video; I would think that this would be very annoying for video as you sometimes can't tell if your video has odd dithering in it or if it's just your monitor. This is probably a problem with all LCDs, and likely only a CRT would solve the problem. In fact, for video editing, you might want to seriously consider a flat screen CRT (perhaps a cheap used one from craigslist.com)

Reply to KevinAr18
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Computer Peripherals > Flat Panels/ LCDs > 17" better image quality than 19"?
Go to:

There are 568 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them