Headphones to replace Sony MDR-CD180s

I had a pair of Sony MDR-CD180 headphones that covered my whole ear. They were comfortable and sounded fine for me.

They recently got a short in the right cord (after many years). I need some replacements. I would find another pair of the same, but I'm wondering if there are better out there for the $$ these days.

I've tried Sennheiser HD555 and they weren't snug enough for me and they were also very overpriced for my not so sensitive ears. I just got some Sennheiser HD202s today, but they don't completely go over my ears, they are too uncomfortable and the bass is too strong with them. I also don't think I care a lot for Sound cancelling phones.

So, should I just dig up another pair of the 180s? Is there a newer model that will fit the comfort and quality of the 180s for me?

I don't want to spend more than $40 for a pair. These will also be used 90% for gaming.