Tom's Hardware > Forum > Windows XP > Windows XP General Discussion > NTFS Partition Compatible with Win 98 fat 32 on a

NTFS Partition Compatible with Win 98 fat 32 on a

Forum Windows XP : Windows XP General Discussion - NTFS Partition Compatible with Win 98 fat 32 on a

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Hello, I heard that In win XP, if you partition the hd in NTFS format, you can't share files with other computers that are running win 98 with in your network. I was told to partition in fat 32 so they would be compatible. Is this true?
I have three computers two of them have win 98 and, I just finished building the newest one. I am installing win xp home ed. on this new computer.
I was not given the option to partition in fat32. Please help.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +

Correct. When installing XP chose not to upgrade the drive to NTFS and you won't have any file system conflict issues!

"Opinions are like assholes, everyone has one"

Reply to nja469
- 0 +

When I try to setup XP it only gives me the option of
NFS Partition and NFS (Quick) Partition. I don't understand why fat 32 isn't a option that I can select. Do you know why this is happening? I am booting the computer up to the xp cd and it goes through the setup but I stop because I only have the two NFS options.
Thank you

Reply to Seekie
- 0 +

thats strange that it doesn't give the FAT32 option. Worse comes to worse, you can boot off a win98 boot diskette (you can grab one from <A HREF="http://www.bootdisk.com" target="_new"><font color=red>bootdisk.com</font color=red></A> if you don't have one), fdisk and format, then boot off the CD and tell it to use the current partition as is.

<i>It's always the one thing you never suspected.</i>

Reply to jlanka
- 0 +

Yes, I am in agreement with jlanka.
Use Windows 98 CD (if you have otherwise download a boot disk from the link jlanka provided). Format the hard drive using Win98 CD/Boot disk. It will format the partition under FAT32.
Finally run the Windows XP setup.

<font color=blue>Mubashar</font color=blue>
_________________________________________________________

<b><font color=red><i>"All delays are dangerous in war."</b></font color=red></i>

Reply to xyz
- 0 +

Yes, I am in agreement with jlanka.
Use Windows 98 CD (if you have otherwise download a boot disk from the link jlanka provided). Format the hard drive using Win98 CD/Boot disk. It will format the partition under FAT32.
Finally run the Windows XP setup.

<font color=blue>Mubashar</font color=blue>
_________________________________________________________

<b><font color=red><i>"All delays are dangerous in war."</b></font color=red></i>

Reply to xyz
- 0 +

Thank You everyone for your help. I used the win 98 boot cd and fdisk/formatted to fat 32. It worked great.
Now I have to figure out why the system wont shut down, I pick the shut down option and it restarts.
Thanks again.

Reply to Seekie
- 0 +

you should be able to format to fat32 from the winxp boot cd. i dont know why it isnt showing up for you, but, you should be able to do it like the other guys have said above.

as for your actual question, here's my educated guess...

i say educated cuz i have just switched over to xp within the last month and haven't actually used winxp on a network yet to encounter the problems. but, despite this, i have been learning how to use this new os and i think winxp does allow win98 machines to access shares created on it.

from my understanding, ntfs is like fat32, except that it reserves a cluster in each sector for special system flags that allows u to control the security of your file system by setting permissions on files and folders. These permissions control which users have access to those files and what types of access they have, such as "read, read & execute, write, modify, etc."

WinXp is very much a "user" system, in that, you can create multiple "user accounts" and "user groups" and assign rights and priviledges to them. It is possible to create user accounts for people to remotely log on to your computer. By setting the permissions on folders and files for these users accounts, you should be able to control which files and folders they have access to under that user name. I believe it is possible to therefore allow a win98 machine to access the winxp machine by setting the permissions on a folder or file to include "read, write ..." permissions for the "computer name" of the win98 machine. These settings can be made from an administrator account on the winxp machine by right-clicking the folder or file, selecting the "sharing" tab, "share this folder" button, and then the "permissions" button. In the window that comes up, there should be an "add" button that allows you to add a user or group so that their permissions can be defined. I believe the easiest way to set it up for more than one computer is to just "add" the "network" group, and then configure the permissions. This should give any network computers the ability to access those drives, folders, and files that you have configured as above.

However, for many people, this may be too much trouble if tight security isnt a concern, and in that case, fat32 would be a better option

Reply to Neobyte
- 0 +

It might not shut down due to a mis-configuration in BIOS and the ACPI controls. Simply go into BIOS and make sure ACPI (power management) is enabled and it allows the OS to customize the settings, helped me.

"Opinions are like assholes, everyone has one"

Reply to nja469
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Windows XP > Windows XP General Discussion > NTFS Partition Compatible with Win 98 fat 32 on a
Go to:

There are 841 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them