G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: comp.os.linux.advocacy,microsoft.public.windowsxp.general (More info?)
I was looking at my XP desktop ( this applies to my KDE desktop as well)
and thinking:
1) People understand desktops. Seeing both programs and documents laid
out on a surface, is very clear. Seeing an Open Office document, as a
little icon is very clear.
2) People don't understand folders, directories and they certainly don't
understand "file extensions".
3) Taskbars and "start" buttons are very redundant. Yes, they are ways
to organzie programs that are not on the desktop -- but they are way too
confusing.
4) When I click on a desktop with the main mouse button, nothing happens
unless I click on an icon. That is really wasteful. Using the
secondary mouse button brings up settings for changing wall paper and
screen savers and resolution - that is also wasteful as these are not
everyday things for 95% of users (yes, some people like to change them
everyday, but not very many).
5) The tray is appealing, but also cumbersome. I don't need to look at
these icons all the time -- I like popup alerts, but it doesn't require
an icon to be sitting there, taking up real estate 24x7.
So, an ideal desktop would be one without anything BUT the desktop. It
would use the main mouse button click to bring up a list of programs in
a popup menu. It would use the right mouse button to set the desktop
config, but also to show items that are now in the "tray". Any alerts
that popup from TSR programs would just show as a baloon right on the
desktop.
I was looking at my XP desktop ( this applies to my KDE desktop as well)
and thinking:
1) People understand desktops. Seeing both programs and documents laid
out on a surface, is very clear. Seeing an Open Office document, as a
little icon is very clear.
2) People don't understand folders, directories and they certainly don't
understand "file extensions".
3) Taskbars and "start" buttons are very redundant. Yes, they are ways
to organzie programs that are not on the desktop -- but they are way too
confusing.
4) When I click on a desktop with the main mouse button, nothing happens
unless I click on an icon. That is really wasteful. Using the
secondary mouse button brings up settings for changing wall paper and
screen savers and resolution - that is also wasteful as these are not
everyday things for 95% of users (yes, some people like to change them
everyday, but not very many).
5) The tray is appealing, but also cumbersome. I don't need to look at
these icons all the time -- I like popup alerts, but it doesn't require
an icon to be sitting there, taking up real estate 24x7.
So, an ideal desktop would be one without anything BUT the desktop. It
would use the main mouse button click to bring up a list of programs in
a popup menu. It would use the right mouse button to set the desktop
config, but also to show items that are now in the "tray". Any alerts
that popup from TSR programs would just show as a baloon right on the
desktop.