You can't say you're satisfied with a HD 238i in relation to a HD 589, it's on completely different levels.
I have a HD 598 Audiophile Headphones, also the 600 and 650.
They are mainly for music lovers and less more of the gaming "bass" pumped headphones. If you're looking for headphones for music, the HD 598 is the ***.
As in terms of Surround, no. I don't recommend it for games, i tried and got shot random places in Battlefield 3 that i couldn't hear them from. Can be changed to surround if you have a good sound card but it just gets all weird ...
In my opinion
HD 598 = For Music (Best Music Headphones IMO for the $150-$200 Price Range)
Beats by Dre = Hip Hop Music
Creative & Sennheiser PC series are good gaming headsets/phones
*Don't buy Steelseries Siberia V2 if you wear glasses, it hurts the hell out of your head after 20 minutes, and the speakers sound muffed as though someone put a pillow over it.*
Thought that'd help