Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Old laptop or new netbook/laptop?

Last response: in Laptops & Notebooks
Share
May 23, 2010 5:15:46 AM

Hi all,
I've had this question for a while.
I have a HP Pavillion dv6000 series notebook that's almost 3 years old. Now I need to use it for university, but the battery life is just close to zero (~15minutes). So I was considering to buy a new 12cell battery for it which is about $100 and will probably give it around 3 hours battery life.

But then I began to think about netbooks and laptops <=13.3". Like this:
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E1683...
$400 and free shipping. Athlon Neo MV-40 1.60 Ghz, 12.1", 2GB RAM,HD3200 and 250GB HDD. Battery life is 6 hrs. Everything except the CPU (and screensize ofc) looks equal or better than my dv6000.

So here is the question: which is the better solution?
A)-Buy a high capacity batt. for the old laptop or
B)-Sell the old laptop and buy a new netbook

I'm pretty sure I can sell the dv6000 for $300+. So either way the cost is identical.

In fact, my only concern is the CPU. How is this Athlon Neo MV-40 1.60Ghz compare to the Athlon 64 X2 TL-58 1.90Ghz of my dv6000?
and is the Atom N450 1.60Ghz similar to the MV-40?

So if the netbook can actually outperform my dv6000, I will sell this old piece of junk and go for it 4 sure.
===========================updated=============================
my bottom line is that the netbook should be able to play high-def videos smoothly, like h.264 mpg4, or 720P/1080P YouTube videos.
Also it should run office softwares nicely, like running 3 MS Word files and 2 pdf files at the same time or something like that.
If a netbook can fulfill these tasks, I do not care to spend $400-500 on it.

Please leave your comments. Thanks. :bounce: 

More about : laptop netbook laptop

May 23, 2010 5:32:08 AM

MV-40 with singal core can hardly be compared to dual-core TL-58. But it is better than N450. Meanwhile, dv6000 has a better graphic performance than Eee PC 1201T.

In sum they are not products at the same level. But if you don need to use big applicaitons, Eee is OK.

BTW, a 12cell battery can only give a 3 hours life for dv6000?
m
0
l
May 23, 2010 6:05:59 AM

ssshjp said:
MV-40 with singal core can hardly be compared to dual-core TL-58. But it is better than N450. Meanwhile, dv6000 has a better graphic performance than Eee PC 1201T.

In sum they are not products at the same level. But if you don need to use big applicaitons, Eee is OK.

BTW, a 12cell battery can only give a 3 hours life for dv6000?


I thought the MV-40 and N450 are dual core...are they not? So what models are dual core CPU for netbooks?
I though the HD3200 on the netbook is better than the Geforce Go 7200 on dv6000. I've played the same game on a newer HP laptop with HD3200 and the graphics looks better than the dv6000.
The original 6 cell battery gives the dv6000 about 1.5, less than 2 hrs initially. So I would assume a 3 hr life for a 12-cell, maybe 3.5 at most.
m
0
l
May 24, 2010 3:22:54 AM

Has anyone else got an idea? I really want to know if it is a good idea to buy a new netbook.
m
0
l
!