For more details on the issue; I can listen to music at a low volume and people will not hear my audio I hear over Skype. Although when I turn up the volume they can hear it clearly. There isn't any feedback to the mic and the headset cancels noise both in and out very well. It is also not an issue with Skype as I can turn up the music and see the volume bar on the Mic in Sound > Recording fluctuate with the audio in my speakers.
Every search for this problem had answers to analog issues but not for a USB headset. Any help would be appreciated.