G
Guest
Guest
I realize that people have brought this up before but I have some new issues I'd like to mention. (I'm buying a new graphics workstation and I'm looking for advice).
First of all, I've read numerous times that dual PIIIs are slower than a single Athlon. According to the Maya Renderspeed Survey this simply isn't true... not by a longshot.
(http://www.vitolini.de/MayaRenderSurvey/Maya1.html)
In fact, dual 1000s (I would only be getting 800s, though) render the same scene 29% faster than a 1200 Athlon in Maya 3.0. I realize the Athlon is superior for this sort of operation, but not so superior that it can keep up with two PIIIs.
Second of all, one has to consider that with PIIIs you can get a SCSI system... further enhancing the dual PIII option.
One always want to look at the price/performance ratio. Price/performance is always a factor... But it's usually not the bottom line. The bottom line (in this particular case) is "What's the best system one can get for about $3,000-$4,000?" and ultimately I would conclude that it's a PIII system.
I already know my opinions, though. The reason I'm posting is to see if anybody else has a different opinion before I purchase.
If it has any bearing, the rest of the system is a Quadro2Pro chipset card, 512MB PC600 RDRAM, 18 GB SCSI 10,000 RPM. I don't think you could do better than that with AMD (Due to limited availability you can't get that card yet with an AMD system).
Any advice would help..
Thanks,
Aaron
First of all, I've read numerous times that dual PIIIs are slower than a single Athlon. According to the Maya Renderspeed Survey this simply isn't true... not by a longshot.
(http://www.vitolini.de/MayaRenderSurvey/Maya1.html)
In fact, dual 1000s (I would only be getting 800s, though) render the same scene 29% faster than a 1200 Athlon in Maya 3.0. I realize the Athlon is superior for this sort of operation, but not so superior that it can keep up with two PIIIs.
Second of all, one has to consider that with PIIIs you can get a SCSI system... further enhancing the dual PIII option.
One always want to look at the price/performance ratio. Price/performance is always a factor... But it's usually not the bottom line. The bottom line (in this particular case) is "What's the best system one can get for about $3,000-$4,000?" and ultimately I would conclude that it's a PIII system.
I already know my opinions, though. The reason I'm posting is to see if anybody else has a different opinion before I purchase.
If it has any bearing, the rest of the system is a Quadro2Pro chipset card, 512MB PC600 RDRAM, 18 GB SCSI 10,000 RPM. I don't think you could do better than that with AMD (Due to limited availability you can't get that card yet with an AMD system).
Any advice would help..
Thanks,
Aaron