G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: alt.games.adnd (More info?)
I posted this question in rec.games.frp.dnd because I didn't know
about this group. My apologies to those who read it twice.
In the first and second editions of AD&D, charm spells harm the ability
of a spellcaster to cast spells. I forget the exact wording. But I
suspect the main idea was that you couldn't charm a spellcaster into
casting spells for you for free. Something like 25% of the time,
due to the mental confusion of being under a charm and due to the
mental demands of casting spells, the charmed caster would
unwittingly choose a spell that would have nearly the opposite of the
desired effect.
Let's say a warrior character, using a philter of love or other
charm-like magic, convinces a higher level fighter to train him
or her for free. No problem in the rules as written.
But if a mage/wizard/magic-user casts a charm person (or uses
a philter of love) to help persuade a higher level wizard to train him
or her... how should it go?
Training up a level doesn't explicitly require the casting of spells,
but you might expect the teacher to cast a few as examples.
So should it fail outright, or have risks, or (eek) cause the
trainee to learn bad spellcasting habits such that 25% of the time
he or she imitates the WRONG way to cast a spell of that level?
NarniaFan
I posted this question in rec.games.frp.dnd because I didn't know
about this group. My apologies to those who read it twice.
In the first and second editions of AD&D, charm spells harm the ability
of a spellcaster to cast spells. I forget the exact wording. But I
suspect the main idea was that you couldn't charm a spellcaster into
casting spells for you for free. Something like 25% of the time,
due to the mental confusion of being under a charm and due to the
mental demands of casting spells, the charmed caster would
unwittingly choose a spell that would have nearly the opposite of the
desired effect.
Let's say a warrior character, using a philter of love or other
charm-like magic, convinces a higher level fighter to train him
or her for free. No problem in the rules as written.
But if a mage/wizard/magic-user casts a charm person (or uses
a philter of love) to help persuade a higher level wizard to train him
or her... how should it go?
Training up a level doesn't explicitly require the casting of spells,
but you might expect the teacher to cast a few as examples.
So should it fail outright, or have risks, or (eek) cause the
trainee to learn bad spellcasting habits such that 25% of the time
he or she imitates the WRONG way to cast a spell of that level?
NarniaFan