Which one is worth the $, 9800np 9700np, fx5600u?

Hi Everyone,

I need some opinion. My current video card spec is nvidia TI-4200, 4X AGP, 128mb. I am giving this card to my brother and will be looking for a card that will be more suited for DX9 (basically preparing for Doom 3). I am choosing between these couple of video cards here.

FX5600 ultra ($200), 9800 non-pro ($265 Saphhire OEM spec), 9700 non-pro ($220 Powercolor retail), and all these video cards have 128mb video memory.

But before I sink over $200 into a video card, I will need a couple of expert opinions. I did a little research myself and these are what I found out. The FX5600 ultra is only good with REV2 version. How do I know which company or retailer is selling the REV2 version? Besides the Core is clocked at 400mHz, what other things should I look out for? The 9700non-pro Powercolor retail sounds like a great price. Unfortunately, I had been seeing people complaining that Powercolor products are unstable, use cheap parts and their card actually clocks at a slower speed than their counterparts from ATI or Saphhire. The 9800 non-pro Saphhire is OEM spec. Am I better off paying the full $300 for the retail version? How fast is the FX5600 ultra rev 2 compare to these other 2 cards or compare to my currently Albatron Ti4200 AGP 4X 128mb card? I don't really want to pay over $200 and get something that dont really make much of a difference with my current setup.

I do not have infinite budget to sink into a video card, and obviously I want the best bang for the buck. Personally, I am leaning towards the 9800 non-pro saphhire OEM spec. A few expert opinions will be greatly appreciated.

Well I'm running an ATI 9800Pro, and I would suggest the 9800 Non Pro, in comparison to the cards you've listed any day of the week.

<b><font color=purple>Details, Details, Its all in the Details, If you need help, Don't leave out the Details.</font color=purple></b>