G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: rec.games.trading-cards.magic.rules (More info?)
Playing some casual last night and I realised protection ain't all it's
cracked up to be. I cast a Knight of Dawn against a whole mess of Goblins
(who can't attack me yet because I have 3 Ghostly Prison in play. I pay 2
to give it protection from Red until end of turn but while that's on the
stack it gets burned for 2 red, so I have to pay another 2 to give it
protection from Red, another Goblin burns it for 2, etc. I run out of mana
before opponent runs out of Gobbos to fling at it so it dies.
Assuming this is how protection works on the stack it leads me to this
question:
How early in my opponent's turn can I give my creature protection in this or
any other way. Specifically I thought doing it BEFORE their untap phase
completes might work.
Example:
I have a Moonlit Strider and a Shirei, Shizo's Caretake in play. My
opponent is playing predominantly red and is tapped out. So... what if I
sacrifice Moonlit Strider during his untap phase but BEFORE he untaps any
permanents - can I do that? That way he can't burn it in response and
because the stack will resolve before he has a chance to burn it then it
will be safe for the turn?
It's a difficult question to type out so I hope I've explained it clearly.
Any help/clarification appreciated.
Thanks
Liam.
Playing some casual last night and I realised protection ain't all it's
cracked up to be. I cast a Knight of Dawn against a whole mess of Goblins
(who can't attack me yet because I have 3 Ghostly Prison in play. I pay 2
to give it protection from Red until end of turn but while that's on the
stack it gets burned for 2 red, so I have to pay another 2 to give it
protection from Red, another Goblin burns it for 2, etc. I run out of mana
before opponent runs out of Gobbos to fling at it so it dies.
Assuming this is how protection works on the stack it leads me to this
question:
How early in my opponent's turn can I give my creature protection in this or
any other way. Specifically I thought doing it BEFORE their untap phase
completes might work.
Example:
I have a Moonlit Strider and a Shirei, Shizo's Caretake in play. My
opponent is playing predominantly red and is tapped out. So... what if I
sacrifice Moonlit Strider during his untap phase but BEFORE he untaps any
permanents - can I do that? That way he can't burn it in response and
because the stack will resolve before he has a chance to burn it then it
will be safe for the turn?
It's a difficult question to type out so I hope I've explained it clearly.
Any help/clarification appreciated.
Thanks
Liam.