I realize that this is not the perfect section for this, but since it covers a lot of areas, I think this is a good place to start. Fredi, don't move this just yet.
I just recieved <font color=red>Office XP 2002 Proffessional</font color=red> from Microsoft tonight. Let me just say that it is a major dissapointment, and a very large step for Microsoft in a horrible direction. They are challenging people with the way the XP series will be marketed. Although I won't speak on behalf of WinXP until I get it in the fall, here goes on Office:
<font color=red>SUBSCRIPTION SOFTWARE</font color=red>
The version that I have is a one year subscription. I have to activate my subscription to use the software by contacting MS with my serial number and hardware I believe. Apparently MS still hasn't decided on going this route during the official release, but as of now you have to pay for a subscription as well as the software.
<font color=red>HARDWARE REGISTRATION</font color=red>
You have 19 times (they told me 50, but the software told me 19) to boot the software before you have to register your hardware. Each time you make a "significant" change, you need to once again call or e-mail MS. The microsoft representative wasn't even sure what that meant, so I will assume that everytime you change your hardware you have to make the phonecall. This doesn't work for me at all since I take my NIC card out all the time.
This is an attempt to stop home users from installing on all home machines. The software is still very expensive. I have the proffessional edition and it will cost an arm and a leg. There is a standard edition without Access, and there is going to be a SE version for the first 90 days that will include a MS optical mouse. The prices are not good at all.
<font color=red>JUST ANOTHER PATCH</font color=red>
The features in XP are basically all the same with a few new ones. They are claiming it to be a new brand new version, but basically you aren't getting anything new except the above two pains. I watched a demo of all the new and "exciting" features, and there aren't any.
I still haven't even installed the software, and quite frankly I don't plan too. I got the software for free, and will recieve subscription updates for free if they choose to go that route, but unless there is a nice and handy "patch" to be downloaded, I just don't see any benefits. Microsoft claims that they are taking the route that many other software developers have taken. Nonetheless, there are cracks for all of them so I think we can sleep tight for Office XP if you really wanted to, but with the upcoming release of WinXP I just don't see any choice but to avoid it. Cracking an OS is not an option in my opinion.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso<P ID="edit"><FONT SIZE=-1><EM>Edited by dhlucke on 05/01/01 10:50 AM.</EM></FONT></P>
I like to reimd you as a few of us beta tested fer office 2000 and win 2000. Both in their beta stages really really sucked.Just let final release come before you pass judgement.Its good to be evil.
SPUDMUFFIN
<font color=blue>Just some advice from your friendly neighborhood blue man </font color=blue>
The reason I brought this up in the manner I did is becuase I'm not talking about a Beta version. I have the final release. That's why I can't speak on behalf of WinXP.
I wouldn't say the product sucks, but there isn't much new to it beyond the two killers above. Hardware registration and a possible but currently active subscription process ruins the office suite of programs imop.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
This is only slightly off topic, but I think is worthy in this thread.
I remember hearing somewhere that the large majority of offices where MS products are deployed are still using Office '97, and are reluctant to upgrade to Office 2000.
I wonder how well this new package will be received by the public. Obviously the manufactured PC that ship with Word will have the new XP software when it comes out, but I think most people won't feel justified in dropping $300+ for more of the same that will most likely require them to upgrade their hardware as well.
Just my 2¢
--------
I have not yet begun to procrastinate.
Um what are you talking about they havnt finished the final build. Beta 1 and 2 soon to be 3 in the next month or so. Geeze if you dont like it dont use it as a evil guy that i am even im tired of hearing about how everyone hates what Microsoft does, give me a break go use linux then.
SPUDMUFFIN
<font color=blue>Just some advice from your friendly neighborhood blue man </font color=blue>
Geez...I guess I'm a friggin retard. Sorry. I must have completely missunderstood the Microsoft representative's entire 2 hour seminar and the other 6 that I have gone to before. I'm so sorry....
Look, I'm sure Microsoft will have a zillion patches, for this version in my hand (critial update is activated once again), but that's not the point. The only real thing that might change is the subscription process. I have to actually subscribe every year to use this software. Do you think that is right? Regardless of whether I get it for free, what about the average Joe Smoe? How will you feel when you have to pay $300-$600 for the software only to pay a yearly fee as well?
I did read an article on some site today that claimed that MS didn't care whether or not you change your hardware a hundred times. They apparently claimed that it won't be a problem unless you have your serial number online, in which case they'll deactivate your # (since it will obviously have too many hardware configuration numbers), so that NO hardware config will work. But why even have it then? If I can get 100 hardware identification codes for myself and my closest friends, then aren't we right back where we started? I just don't understand this whole concept of hardware locking software.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
If you made the product you would get very very upset when people pirated it wouldnt you??? Its yer time and money man if you are moral you would say yes and if you are AMD orientated well you would say no since by how it all seem to play out yer all cheapo's.
SPUDMUFFIN
<font color=blue>Just some advice from your friendly neighborhood blue man </font color=blue>
You're completely right. Microsoft is being really stupid lately. I think it all started when they decided to go ahead with the .NET initiative.
Microsoft seems to believe that everyone in the world now uses the internet 24/7. And that people NEVER do things like build a new computer, taking as many components from their old computer as possible, and install their old OS on this new computer. (Which is perfectly legal because the old computer is no longer in use.)
Frankly, from a network administrator's standpoint, XP scares the living drek out of me. I mean companies tend to just buy one copy of the software, and then buy a large number of site licences. Then they just use the one CD, and the one CD key/serial number/whatever and install it on every machine. And it sounds like XP makes this simple business approach completely impossible.
Besides the simple fact that there are a LARGE number of questionable routes that Microsoft is forcing all of their customers along.
I can see that either Microsoft is suddenly going to loose a LOT of sales, or that Microsoft is going to rapidly change their whole software direction. Suddenly Linux doesn't look all that bad.
<pre>1 <font color=blue>Print</font color=blue> "You too can be annoying, if you try."
2 <font color=blue>Goto</font color=blue> 1</pre><p>
This is copied from another websight.......
Hi Kyle,
I want to clear some things up about Windows Product Activation. First, we need to know that EVERY piece of hardware you have in your system has UNIQUE identifiers. (MAC Address for NIC’s, Processor ID’s, RealTime Clocks, etc.) When you enter a PID in Windows XP, it is hashed against several pieces of hardware in your machine. (I’m not at liberty to tell you what pieces of hardware, or how many.) The resultant value is then passed to a clearinghouse (on the internet, or by phone if you prefer) and a verification code is sent to activate windows. In effect, it ties the PID to that specific computer, in its current configuration. Microsoft is aware that customers will change the configuration of their computer. Changes in hardware are expected, and allowed. It is only when a PID is trying to be cleared on several hundred/thousand configurations that Microsoft would even care. Microsoft isn’t in the business of screwing customers, but they would definitely like to give the shaft to thieves.
Windows Product Activation DOES NOT require you to get a new product key every time you want to reinstall/format windows. Not the first time you reinstall, not the 8 billionth time you reinstall. (You have to go through the Activation process, but you are passing the same AUTH string to the clearinghouse, it NEVER counts against you. There is no timeout for reinstalling Windows against the same hardware, or several future hardware upgrades.) Activation takes less than 10 seconds on a 56k modem, or 5 minutes on the phone with a telephone representative. It also takes place before ANY personal information is even entered.
Your product key is bound to the hardware in your system. If you change your hardware SIGNIFICANTLY, you can still reactivate. (In fact, only on HIGH volume keys with different hardware will MS stop accepting the pirate key.) ie. Customer has a product key, he can go through a FEW COMPLETE computer overhauls, use the same product key, and be just fine. NOW, if a product key is used in 1000 different hardware configurations, we don’t let THAT product get activated. The PID has then become worthless. Nobody can activate Windows with it. This makes PID sharing (the most common form of Windows piracy) a little more costly. If YOU ever want to reinstall the Windows YOU bought, YOU better keep your key, and not give it away, or post it on the internet.
In a test environment, which I’m sure you will be using Windows for in a lot of scenarios, you probably won’t have a Windows that’s more than 30 days old before you wipe it. (no need to activate…)
We’ve determined that a crack will be out for this method of activation within one week after RTM, but this is not to stop those guys. This is to stop the casual piracy of Windows, and I think it will be a viable solution. Bottom line is you should pay for the software you use.
Hope that helps clear that up. It’s not going to hurt anyone but the people it’s targeted to hurt: the software pirates.
Here is a little additional information he shared with us in a following email.
A point I want to clear up:
Microsoft has no way of knowing what KIND of hardware is in your machine. The identification value is a HASH. A PRODUCT OF OPERATIONS PERFORMED ON SEVERAL PIECES OF HARDWARE. It's a totally unique number BASED from your hardware. It doesn't scan hardware and send it WITHOUT permission. That would take too long, and, consequently, is PROTECTED under law already. We know that hardware is unique, so by HASHING the unique hardware ID's against a unique PID, we have a totally unique identification number to track how many times a specific PID has been used on different configurations.
If you take a truth and follow it blindly, it will become a Falsehood and you a Fanatic.
Thanks! I was wondering how the hashing routine worked.
Also, did you all know that you don't have to enter ANY personal info when you send the PID online? I read the small print at the bottom of the screen and it said that you only have to enter info on the lines that have a "*" by them. I then looked and noticed that the only line with a "*" by it was the line that shows what country I'm in (I was installing Office 2000 sr1).
It's still sneaky of Microsoft though. Because most people won't notice that the lines with the "*" are the only required ones. So therefore most people will still give M$ a load of "Marketing Info".
Also, if you choose to register by mail and then enter wrong info you are screwed, and have to re-install your OS. So don't do that OK! Make one wrong move and it could be all over (at least for several hours as you re-install your whole OS). I still don't like the system and think it's really arrogant and invasive. But the info you just gave me makes the registration-activation process not seem quite as bad as I thought.
Thanks.
<b><font color=green> Have a day </font color=green></b>
I'm still not sure how some of the ID stuff happens though.
A friend of mine tried to install Office 2000 sr1 on her's PC and a friend's PC, and it didn't work she said. So it sounds like if you buy a whole new system, then your copy Office 2000 (that cost you $600!) will no longer work on the new PC. I haven't tried it, but I can't imagine this being true.
<b><font color=green> Have a day </font color=green></b>
Thanks for posting that. This is the article I was refering to. What is the point of the hardware registration at all? Seriously it sounds more like microsoft is trying to gather information more than anything else according to this letter which states that microsoft will be very lenient.
But when it comes down to it, will microsoft be that lenient? I don't know since microsoft themselves told me that one of the main reasons for this process was to eliminate home users from only buying one copy and then installing on their friends and family's PC's.
If this letter is correct, then I could call microsoft now, activate my computer, then call again when I build a new computer and get another number, thus leaving my old one in place. Or will MS cancel the old number? Could I just call 10 times and hook up my closest buddies?
Either way, I DO NOT approve of microsoft gathering my hardware information. What will be next? Will I constantly have to reenter numbers and call microsoft everytime I have a lan party and stick my NIC card in?
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
I'll install the Office XP Proffessional later tonight, and let you know exactly what they ask and do.
Even if the hardware thing is no big deal, or if it can be cracked, it still leaves the issue of the software being a subscription as of right now.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso<P ID="edit"><FONT SIZE=-1><EM>Edited by dhlucke on 04/26/01 04:13 PM.</EM></FONT></P>
| Quote : "When you enter a PID in Windows XP, it is hashed against several pieces of hardware in your machine. (I’m not at liberty to tell you what pieces of hardware, or how many)." |
I also really ticks me off that Microsoft says that they are "not at liberty to tell" me what <i>exactly</i> they are doing inside <b><i>my</i></b> machine and what is the <i>exact</i> info they are gathering!
Again, it just shows that they think they can own anything. And that they are trying to rule the world (very subtley) through ruling ALL PC opertating systems on ALL computers and requiring that ALL of them <i>require</i> a connection to Microsoft in order to run. This is like requiring every business to ask permission from Microsoft before they can get any work done. It's pretty close to absolute power! Most companies are totally dependant on M$ and have invested hundreds of thousands or millions in M$ software. Microsoft knows that they have most of the world by the balls. I know this sounds like a conspiracy theory, and I'm not that kind of person, but when you really think about it, M$ will have more power with XP in some ways than many of the worlds governments (if they ever try to abuse it). And we all completely trust and know that they will <i>never</i> do <i>that</i>. Big brother Bill will make sure nothing bad ever happens to us... NOT!. M$ will always do what they think is best for us (whether we agree with M$ on what they think is best or not) No one deserves that much trust.
<b><font color=green> Have a day </font color=green></b>
| Quote : I'll install the Office XP Proffessional later tonight, and let you know exactly what they ask and do. |
Thanks! I'll be very interested to hear what you find out.
<b><font color=green> Have a day </font color=green></b>
Ok, I'm debating on how much information to pour down everyone's throats.
First off, in order to even begin the installation I had to update Windows.
I am going to paste in here a bunch of stuff that I either typed by hand from the dialog boxes, or I got from the help file and privacy policy text files:
First of all, here is what the help file for the initial setup said:
The only real interesting part here is that it crashed my computer and I had to start in safe mode to get running again. A large part of this setup was something called "Microsoft Internet Software"
| Quote : Microsoft Office Setup: Install Windows and Office Component Updates
|
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
Ya thats the way it installs for a AMD system, With and Intel its done in two seconds.=)
SPUDMUFFIN
<font color=red>Being Evil Is Good. Cause I Can Be A Prick And Get Away With It.</font color=red>
Ok, next is the EULA. Keep in mind that right now it is a subscription based software. There is a checkbox to enter a non-subscription cd key, so it is apparent that they have not decided whether or not to go this route and have left me with at least a way to convert my software to non-subscription.
| Quote : END USER LICENSE AGREEMENT FOR MICROSOFT SOFTWARE.
|
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
Ok, next I activate the subscription: This was very easy, and little did I realize that this 2 second process had already sent my hardware configuration. This is text from the dialog boxes.
| Quote : SUBSCRIPTION ACTIVATION
|
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
Have i told you yet you are a moron??? Cause if some how i forgot to well ill say it now YER A [-peep-] MORON!!! geeze post the EULA else where [-peep-] head.
SPUDMUFFIN
<font color=red>Being Evil Is Good. Cause I Can Be A Prick And Get Away With It.</font color=red>
Well, now the software is running, so the first thing I wondered was "when do I register my hardware". I found my answer in the help file.
| Quote : Office Activation Wizard Privacy Policy
|
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
Ok, now I realize that I just posted alot, but it's everything you would want to know about the subscription process and the hardware registration.
I will be reminded 60 days before my subscription runs out to renew. If I don't renew, my software goes into reduced functionality mode as described above.
The only thing I don't really know is what exactly was sent to microsoft regarding my hardware configuration? The only personal information that I sent was my country that I know of.
If there is anything else someone needs just let me know. I'm sure the EULA was enough to read as it is....
For the record, I am running a P2 400, with Win98se. Everything is upto date, so I'm not sure what Office required in the begining just to begin the installation.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
I'm still a bit confused on the subscription deal. Is this of office products only or for all future XP products.
Are you required to renew your subscription. If so that is absolute Crap!
If you take a truth and follow it blindly, it will become a Falsehood and you a Fanatic.
Right now Office XP <b>IS</b> a subscription based software. From what I understand so is WinXP. However, they might change this before the official release of their products. According to them, it is still at their discretion. Like I said, there is a box to input a key for a non-subscription based version. I did try my key in that box, but it didn't work. Nonetheless, if they don't go subscription I'll have to get a new cd key to continue using the software. Each subscription has to be renewed yearly.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
By the way. Thanks for your incredibly thorough posts! You really did some work documenting and putting all this here for our good.
Thanks for going to the trouble! You are a true community member in my book.
<b><font color=green> Have a day </font color=green></b>
Are people expected to pay for that subscription renewal at the end of the year? If so then I wont be buying a single piece of that software.
If you take a truth and follow it blindly, it will become a Falsehood and you a Fanatic.
I'm sure that they have a think tank of extremely intelligent people, combined with a think tank of average people on the street, and combined they are trying to figure out exactly how much they can get away with.
Right now, my guess is that they are set to release it as subscription software unless some public outcry tells them not too. I'm sure that once the reviews come out a month before it's release, they'll decide whether or not to ship it with a subscription based cd-key, or a normal cd-key. Alternatively they might just try this for a year and see if the public has got to the point where we will tolerate anything.
Personally I think MS is treading on thin ice. Sure, people that buy new computers won't object to recieving the software in their bundle, but I doubt that many others will enjoy going out and spending $300-$500+ for the software only to pay a yearly fee as well. Families nowadays have several computers, and there is no chance in hell that they are going to buy copy for each hardware config as well as pay a subscription. Pretty soon MS products will be like a normal monthly bill...insurance, gas and electricity, credit card, rent, and the microsoft montly bill. BTW, they didn't have a figure on the subscription fee yet.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
No problem. There have been a number of "rumor" threads based on stuff on the internet, but I thought I'd give a first hand report. I'll do the same for WinXP when I get it in the fall.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
I pulled out my second video card yesterday (pci) and office still runs. I can't remember if I had my NIC card in there when I installed XP, but it's not in there either and it's running. I doubt they're checking pci cards.
<font color=red>Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.</font color=red>
Pablo Picasso
You can take your hard drive and boot from another computer from that drive (make a copy of the hardware config first). I'm very curios if xp still works..
Misu
__'_
Just thought I'd give my last two cents about Office XP. It sucks. There is something wrong with Outlook and the address book. Maybe it was with the upgrade, but I don't know. Either way half the time I send e-mail it just gets denied right away. I get a message 2 seconds later with the bad news.
I'm not sure why some emails get sent and some don't, so I'm going to have to uninstall and go back to the old version. It's not worth my time or money to play around with it.
Stupid MS.
<font color=red>Did you ever wonder WHY aliens only abduct idiots?</font color=red>
I have had similar problems with the address book. Especially when trying to print out address on labels in Word from the Outlook address book. It seems that you now have to have two different address books, one for outlook and one for windows and word. It seems that MS has made this set of software even less productive.
Why is this, do you think?
Back off man, I'm a scientist
I have no idea what they were thinking. I'm going to go back and use netscape I think. I'm a bit fed up with the whole thing. If I send e-mails to multiple recipients, some go through and some don't. I'm not sure what the problem really is.
I think that I have to type in every email address from hand instead of using the address book, but I'm not in the mood for this. I'm trying to figure out if I can transfer all my addresses and e-mail to netscape right now.
<font color=red>Did you ever wonder WHY aliens only abduct idiots?</font color=red>
There are 1031 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

