Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.dell (
More info?)
SCraig wrote:
> My daughter wants a laptop for college. She says she's asked around and
> students she knows have had problems with their Dell laptops. I was
> figuring on getting that brand for her but now am wondering what the
> reliability of the Dell laptops is? Any input is appreciated.
>
> Craig
>
>
I'm a 4th year engineering major (meaning I use my computer more than
the average student) at UCSD; I too purchased a laptop (IBM Thinkpad
T21) just before college (which died last month and am now on my second,
a Dell D610). I know you're only asking about Dell reliability, but
since I just went through researching and buying a new laptop, I figure
I may have some info that may help:
First off, regardless of the brand you go with, get AT LEAST a 3 year
warranty! I recommend an OEM warranty as opposed to one from Best Buy,
Fry's, or CompUSA. I had to send my IBM in two times in 3 years, and
their service is amazingly good (they're known as the best in the
industry). As I've only had my Dell for 5 days I can't say anything
about them yet, but so far it seems very sturdy.
The next big thing I'd recommend is check the college bookstore for
student discounts. For example my school has IBM Thinkpad's listed for
close to a $1000 off MSRP. Dell are also discounted for students but
generally not as much as IBM -- but IBM costs a lot more in the first
place (I found a better deal buying my Latitude from the Small Business
section of Dell.com than on campus, but in general student prices are
better).
On a side note, does she plan to use the laptop as a laptop or just keep
it in her room 90% of the time? If she actually plans to take it
around, I wouldn't go heavier than 5.5lbs. My roommate went with an
Ispiron 9200, and it's a monster; I doubt it's left the condo twice in
the last 6 months which makes me wonder why he bothered with a LAPtop.
Some brands/models I'd highly recommend looking into are: IBM Thinkpad T
series (T43 will be available at student prices in April), Panasonic
Toughbooks, Fujitsu LifeBooks S series, & Sony S series. Brands I'd
avoid are eMachines, the consumer Compaq/HP's, any brand you've never
heard of (not worth the risk for laptops). If you'd like more
suggestions, etc. feel free to email me (just remove nospam from my
reply-to). It should also be noted I would have gone IBM again if the
T43 was available, but I needed the notebook sooner than April.