Archived from groups: alt.cellular.nextel,alt.cellular,alt.cellular.gsm (
More info?)
On 14 Jul 2004 07:26:29 -0700, gopiballava@gmail.com (gopi) wrote:
>"John Eckart" <JEckart@mail.com> wrote in message news:<nE1Jc.2529$Qu5.1988@newsread2.news.pas.earthlink.net>...
>> "Joseph" <JoeOfSeattle@yahoo.com> wrote in message
>> news:a2i5f0114jphk7ork87o9fg6bir6jsa5jh@4ax.com...
>> > On Sun, 11 Jul 2004 10:21:36 -0600, "Scott Stephenson"
>> > <scott.stephensonson@adelphia.net> wrote:
>> > >> iDen is a TDMA technology just as is GSM and IS-136 so called
>> "TDMA."
><snip>
>> Even though iDEN and GSM is based on TDMA technology, it doesn't make it
>> TDMA. You can't use a "TDMA" phone on an iDEN and/or GSM network. The
>> newer 3GSM is based on CDMA technology.
>
>It's been explained in this thread before, but is apparently still
>being ignored.
>
>TDMA, Time Division Multiple Access, is a modulation technique.
Wrong. TDMA say nothing, NADA, ZILCH about modulation, what is says is
the spectrum is time shared amoung the users. Makes no difference what
modulation scheme they use, as long as they time share it. In the case
of D-AMPS, there are time slots for 3 calls in the channell, in GSM
there are 8 x 217 time slots in a channel, and that is usually 8
calls, but with HFR can be 16.
GSM and D-AMPS both operate by time sharing the channel, i.e. only one
phone is broadcasting at any given moment on a specific channel for a
specific BTS. Phone company used to time division mulitplexing and
used PCM modulation, which bears no similarity to GSM or IS-136.
CDMA is a digital analog of synchrous detection, and relies on the
fact that when recovered using the speading code, all calls except the
one you are interested in appears to be random noise. Multiple phone
are in fact transmitting in the same channel simultaneous, something
that neither GSM or D-AMPS/IS-136 can do.
As for actual modulation, CDMA, IS-136 and GSM all use variations on
PSK (phase shift keying)..
FM and
>AM are also modulation techniques.
>
>Many people _incorrectly_ use "TDMA" when they mean "The IS-136
>standard, which uses TDMA modulation."
>
>The term TDMA does _not_ refer to any single, specific standard. It is
>a generic term. I can call my phone a "GSM phone" or a "TDMA phone" or
>a "cellular phone." All of those are accurate.