Security Firm: Windows 7 Less Secure Than Vista

Status
Not open for further replies.

philologos

Distinguished
Feb 4, 2009
105
0
18,690
Vista UAC was one of the major complaints about the OS. Microsoft really had no choice but to change the default. Anandtech, for one, recommends turning UAC back to maximum. But Microsoft was practically forced to loosen the UAC settings.
 
"I was disappointed when I first used a Windows 7 machine that there was no warning that I had no anti-virus, unlike Vista," Genes said. "There are no file extension hidden warnings either. Even when you do install anti-virus, warnings that it has not been updated are almost invisible."

First off, if you don't install your own Anti-Virus without a warning you shouldn't be using a computer.

Second, I'm fairly certain Windows reminded me to do so when I first installed the retail Windows 7 Home Premium.
 

justiceguy216

Distinguished
Aug 13, 2009
48
0
18,530
"I was disappointed when I first used a Windows 7 machine that there was no warning that I had no anti-virus, unlike Vista," Genes said./quote]

"...because now users aren't scared into buying our product."
 

Foxholecharlie

Distinguished
Sep 20, 2008
2
0
18,510
Did someone mention to this guy that he had to dress, feed and water himself every time ?

I find it very hard to believe it did not tell him he had no Anti-Virus.
Let me see, OH by golly, what is that "flag" in the task bar ? Do I dare place my mouse over it ? Do I dare!!!

Imagine this guy who works for a "security company" and cannot even check what or if any anti-virus is loaded onto a machine. How could he possible even find a virus ?

See its easier than pie to fill a blank page with rhetoric. No special job title or occupation needed.
 

mental issues

Distinguished
Dec 11, 2009
2
0
18,510
What an odd position for a company that sells anti-virus products to be taking.

On another note, my old subcompact car is safer than any new vehicle because I placed a sticker on the dash that says "DRIVING INTO THINGS AT HIGH SPEEDS CAN CAUSE SERIOUSLY INJURY OR DEATH". Without this warning, I would have no way to realize that I should be taking precautions to avoid a crash. Of course, the only standard of safety by which I measure cars is their ability to make me aware of the danger of colliding with large objects.
 

amabhy

Distinguished
Sep 11, 2009
97
0
18,630
Oh great Yam. Another article slamming Windows 7, and you fail to note that the company stating the claims makes money fixing up problems and viruses in Windows.
 

ravewulf

Distinguished
Oct 20, 2008
972
33
19,010
Out of the box, Vista can be more annoying (for those who aren't paranoid).

I love Vista, but UAC was/is the first thing to go on any new installation for me.
 

DarkMantle

Distinguished
Aug 6, 2008
131
0
18,690
[citation][nom]mental issues[/nom]What an odd position for a company that sells anti-virus products to be taking.On another note, my old subcompact car is safer than any new vehicle because I placed a sticker on the dash that says "DRIVING INTO THINGS AT HIGH SPEEDS CAN CAUSE SERIOUSLY INJURY OR DEATH". Without this warning, I would have no way to realize that I should be taking precautions to avoid a crash. Of course, the only standard of safety by which I measure cars is their ability to make me aware of the danger of colliding with large objects.[/citation]

+1 to you, that was great.
 

belardo

Splendid
Nov 23, 2008
3,540
2
22,795
UH... when you install Windows7, it does FLAG a warning about the lack of an Antivirus program and WILL/CAN open a Window to download an Antivirus program, besides Microsoft's.

So I call the "Security expert" as fud.

Yeah, UAC is dialed back a bit... but the USER can make it as bad as Vista... and oh yeah, vista's UAC was such retarded crap that most people TURNED IT OFF when they can or find out that they could!

UAC (in vista) is such garbage that it POPs up with when doing such simple things like Device manager, Display settings, rename a desktop icon, etc... it gets old very very fast.

With Win7, it can be left on with minimal bother. Still stupid thjavascript: void(0);at there isn't a CHECK BOX to remember what the program is like firewalls do or SpyBot's tools.

 

doc70

Distinguished
Jul 3, 2009
325
0
18,780
Bull$hit from a company that tries to sell it's product. I disabled the UAC on Vista first thing and never had a virus because I use an anti-virus (free) and a firewall (free). Also, did the same thing on Win7 and guess what? My AV auto-updates, so I don't need to monitor it.
A PC can only be as smart as it's user, and there is no software in hell that will ever change that, regardless of the OS of choice.
If you know anything about protection you will know what and when to use it.
 

Maxor127

Distinguished
Jul 16, 2007
804
0
18,980
People complain way too much about UAC. It works fine in Vista. I rarely get alerts. People either overexaggerate about it or are using their system incorrectly.

When I do get an alert, I know it's coming and it's second nature to just click through it. If you like having a less secure computer, then good luck with that.
 

joe nate

Distinguished
Oct 17, 2009
92
0
18,630
"Even when you do install anti-virus, warnings that it has not been updated are almost invisible."

For some reason, yesterday my Kaspersky Internet Security turned itself off yesterday. Normally the little flag in the lower right is gone unless it says something. Seeing the little flag (Windows Action Center) there told me something was amiss. Mousing over it it told me what was wrong.

Definitely more user friendly now, instead of bombarding you with annoying pop-ups every 5 seconds, acting like built in ad-ware! Windows 7 action center ftw.
 

wira020

Distinguished
Apr 9, 2009
63
0
18,630
He couldnt find anything wrong with win7... and this is the best thing he can say about win7... sure means to me that win7 is good or better than i thought... look at this positively...
 

False_Dmitry_II

Distinguished
When I ran vista, within two minutes I turned off UAC because it asking me about 5 different facets about the SAME THING THAT I TOLD IT TO DO was completely insane. I couldn't leave it like that at all.

Now in windows 7 I have it on the default because it only pops up basically when things are installed, which is much easier to deal with. I'll probably still turn it off eventually because I don't suck at surfing the web, but it is still much better.
 

omnimodis78

Distinguished
Oct 7, 2008
886
0
19,010
Got up to "...Trend Micro" and stopped reading. Before TM makes any subjective claims on an OS they should first figure out how to write a viable and reliable security program. Not to mention, of course they will claim that an OS is flawed, but if you install their crappy program, all will be peaches and cream. BTW - microsoft security essentials is great! It's not pretty, but it's solid for the average PC user. Cheers!
 

DominionSeraph

Distinguished
Oct 22, 2007
12
0
18,510
The CTO of a security firm just failed on security philosophy.

UAC is not a security measure. It's designed to make the admin account act like a limited access acount so that software developers would start programming for limited access accounts instead of assuming Root access. It is not there to protect an administrator from himself, nor to protect an idiot running as an administrator.

UAC is about social engineering, and the Microsoft engineers made no secret of that.

 

prathameshdotinfo

Distinguished
Nov 27, 2009
11
0
18,510
I got a Laptop (C2D, 4GB Ram, 512Mb Ati Graphics) with Vista Installed & the processing sign would always show up.It was real SLOW on such a High End Laptop. Next I got a 7 upgrade from Dell & its real fast. U can feel d difference.

When I saw this article on my RSS I thought I would get to read about security flaws, but saying that Antivirus warnings don't pop (In my case it does pop up if my AV is not updated) & UAC can be customized as less secure OS seems Funny. But its true that because of the Design of Windows system, it will always be a playing ground for Viruses, Malwares, Malacious code & Hacking.

Due to security concerns I only use Windows for Professional Softwares, For everything else I use Ubuntu.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.