I just want to ask, since at least one of those keyboards needs special drivers - have you tested the driver under all the operating system mentioned on the box ?
Sounds silly, but I got a G5 gaming laser mouse from Logitech, which mentions Windows 2000 on the box, but works only as a 3$ mouse under Windows 2000 since the special drivers do not work under Windows 2000. So nothing can be taken for granted nowadays.

I've gotta say my G15 actually has enhanced my "gaming experience" I'm not doing backflips for it or any other device but the goodies like the LCD screen and Macros are well packaged and FUN! Mostly it's that LCD Screen keeping a tally on kills without switching screens, see what's playing in my music while I'm playing, use it for xfire, yada yada. That LCD Screen is cool. Except for that big ciggarette hole I put in mine DOH'!

If your going to spend that much money on a gaming keyboard you should consider this, in combination with a regular keyboard.

http://www.twitchguru.com/2005/03/08/the_dx1/
http://www.ergodex.com/mainpage.htm

I used this for wow and wouldnt go back, I had about 20 keys mapped onto it in the natural shape of my hand by the time I was done.

It does loads of other stuff I never even used like timed macros and things, mostly because they were against the wow T&Cs.

I've also tried this on FPS games with equally satisfying results, I cant say it made me any better at them, but it was a lot more comfortable for prolonged play, no more hand cramp.

upsides
* you can map all of the keys to anything you want
* you can position them where ever you like on the device

consequently it doesnt make any assumptions about the size of your hands so it you have long short or fat fingers it doesnt matter.

downsides
* its a bit hard to get outside the states, I found one shop in the uk which would import it.
* vista support isnt there yet, although its announced as being worked on, new drivers dont seem to be their No1 priority.

Awesome, lets do a gaming keyboard review, and not look at any of the Zboards or Logitechs.

Isn't that like saying lets look at the top 5 operating systems, but i couldn't get hold of a copy of windows in time, so we just wont talk about it.

And apart from that gripe this was one of the most uninformative articles i have ever read, Tom's usually has higher standard.

P.S. I find programmable keys and macro's very useful in RTS games, but somehow FPS and WOW are the only games mentioned in the review. Back lighting is nice in a low light room, and i like a low light gaming environment, it makes the screen look better. There were just so many aspects of what makes a good gaming keyboard that were left out of this article, how good button response feels and key positioning are not the only two things that make a good gaming keyboard.

P.P.S. I don't care that you don't see the point of gaming keyboards, how about asking people who do see the point of gaming keyboards why they like them before you publish an article on gaming keyboards?

I took a Saitek eclipse and another Saitek nova or something like that, one had a programmable keypad attached and the other had backlit letters and numbers. I wanted the backlit numbers and letters and the keypad so I took all the parts I wanted from both and made my own. (almost forgot, it had red backlight, I wanted blue, so I ordered blue surface mount leds from Ebay and replaced all the reds with blues, not easy but it worked)

Here is one I was looking at originally, the russian Optimus Maximus LED keyboard which was supposed to originally be like the price of a good cell phone. I figured thats hot. Now the price is like as much as a used car, so forget it. Its still cool, but not that cool.

Interesting article in its total lack of decent information, but at least it covered the basics. I've used probably 5 keyboards in the last 5 years for gaming and i have to say they are all pretty much the same. I loved my MX3200, the MX5000, microsoft wireless, G15 and a host of others i cant even remember now.

G15 does it for me now becasue i like the LCD for keeping track of things in BF2142. The backlit keys are fantastic for night gaming and the fact that it has USB ports in the board is great cause it gets my MX Revolution Mouse receiver close to reduce the lag. i was skeptical about the MX rev mouse at first till i moved the receiver and its no perfect and very fast.

G15 has a nice weighting to the keys and i really enjoy this keyboard for typing even thought its severely lacking in function keys (calculator, open, zoom, sleep, etc etc).. I've never missed a keystroke with this baby and of all my keyboards i'm definately in love with the weight and feel of the keys.. (and they haven't rubbed off yet)

I'm glad no-one has mentioned the stupidly overpriced Optimus yet as they are a pretty decent idea and an pretty undecent price... They will get there though..

For now, i'm keen to use my G15 with a little lable on the macro keys for now till a better idea comes out.

i think thg needs to do a better review of more options. At this stage though there are really 3 options.. standard keyboard, keyboard with a WASD pad built in, or a separate keyboard and a separate WASD pad... so i guess this article kinda covers the basics..

I have a G15 keyboard, and although it doesn't help me in playing CS or anything, occasionally the macros are handy when playing warcraft. Generally, i believe that spending that much money on a keyboard is a waste if you purely want improved gaming performance. However, i LOVE the lcd screen! It works great for media control while im playing computer games, and i can even see messages from msn!

My G15 was definitely a worthwhile investment in my opinion, though im sure the larger population will disagree. Its one of those things that you never knew you needed so much, until you got one.

My only complaint with it is the usb ports are pretty useless. They are usb 1.1, not 2.0, but thats not the major issue. Since the keyboard uses the full power supplied through the usb 2.0 standard, there is not enough current left over to power any other devices. I have tried several flash drives without success and the only thing that has worked is my mp3 player that i set on usb hub mode (so it drains its own battery).

Travis Meacham completely fails. What were you thinking man? this is the worst piece of crap writing I think I've ever seen on Tom's.
You listed 2 keyboards, one of which, the Razor, is complete marketing flash garbage, no true gamer would touch that thing. You didn't give any information to the community that they didn't already have.

As a gamer, here's what I look for in a gaming keyboard:
1. An easy to read backlighting for all the keys, that you can read day or night.
Best I've seen so far is the G15, my old saitech was very hard to read during the day.
2. Programmable keys with macro ability and timing tweaks.
The G15 does this extremely well.
3. A useable LCD screen to show vital stats gamers care about.
Again, the G15 does this right.
4. This is my BIGGEST problem with all keyboards. DEL,END,Page DN keys MUST be in a line right above the arrow keys.
You see on the razer how they squish that row of keys up and make the DEL key all big? Crap for gamers that actually use those for keybinds close to the arrow keys, and not the WASD keys.

The conclusion is: Yes, gaming keyboards can and do enhance the gaming experience.

why buy gaming anything? I got wireless mouse and keyboard from logitech. hell... when in the middle of bf2 i randomly look at the ground and spin at 6000rpm for no reason. when i have scope to someone's face and keyboard moves me left randomly doesn't bother me if i lose few kills

That would piss the hell out of me, but it's more due to low quality mice (old tech) than the surface. Have not had that problem since I got rid of my bog standard microsoft optical mouse and got a MX1000 like wise I never had that problem till I upgraded to optical mice from track ball mice.

i want that new logitech gaming keyboard because it lights up and basically thats it lol.. just like the new lcd im getting, im fine really with my 21" crt dell trinitron but its bragging rights really

You can't already brag with a 21" CRT?