I have played Age of Conan from the Technical tests stage all the way through to the open beta ( fileplanet ). My thoughts...
I have had my fair share of absolute frustration with loads of bugs in AoC but that comes with the territory in betas. I plowed through the bugs in order to, like all the other testers, ensure that the final product would be as bug free as possible and a smoothly oiled machine. The best part of the process is just how receptive and commited the dev team were in terms of responding to queries and suggestions.
Basically the game was "finished" last october but they decided to polish the game for a further 6 months. So in the interim loads of content adding and tweaking has been going on behind the scenes and I must say - after finally playing on the final beta patch last weekend I was truly impressed. Not only did I not encounter another bug or any lag/zonning to speak of ( with the only exception being that annoying crash after you exit AoC which is a problem with the beta client exe ) but the graphics looked even better that I imagined it could. They finally loaded in extended shading and occlusion/shadow support and textures which makes it look really, really pretty.
The dev team did stress that the beta was an UNFINISHED product - not only that, they were also trying to overload the client and so were using toned down apps and servers during the previous beta patches to make sure it would run well in the final mode. As an example; when loading into a server in the last patching stage of the beta I spawned in a cimmerian village with at least 100 other players tightly packed around me. I was playing on absolute full graphics @ 1920x1080 and there was not a shred of lag or ingame loading. Just dead smooth. It was at that point that the game justified itself to me. Combat was smooth, even with dozens of people swing combos and casting everywhere
I actually enjoyed running around at lvl 20 in full PVP. Sure, I hated the lone hidden assasins or the rogue team of mates who decimated every solitary soldier trying to get through a vital pass - but that encouraged team work
But at the end of the day it was an enjoyable experience. I havent even seen mounted, siege, or commanded mass army vs army combat - not to mention the player guild cities and building and resources and warring over areas etc.
Basically - if you didnt see the final patch ( and by final I mean the final beta patch - they are adding loads more stuff and bugfixes to the final shipped version ) then you cant really comment on this game. End of story - because I am well aware of what the closed, general and technical betas looked and ran like and they really killed the gamelplay/selling point of the game - but then again too many people confuse DEMO's with BETA's.
If thats a taste of what is to come then it is by far the best MMO i have played and Im glad I preordered.