Dual Xeon Mac Pro or i7-4770

[NickZee]

Hello!

I really need feedback about a new system I am planning to build or buy. It needs to be able to handle the following:

1. (Lightroom Enfuse) - Merge anywhere from 4, 8 12, or 18 raw images (25MB each file) into one image (tif), and repeat that several times simultaneously. IE; merge 4 RAWS, merge 5 RAWS, merge 8 RAWS, Merge 12 RAWS, Merge 8 RAWS, Merge 5 RAWS.... All at the same time.

2. RAW file timelapse.

3. HD Video


The two options I'm considering are:

1. Buy a used (2008 or 2009) Mac Pro - Dual Quad Core Xeon 3.0GHz or 3.2Ghz (8-core) I know a Mac Pro 1,1 Dual Xeon 2.0 GHz (5130) can run 12 simultaneous LREnfues mergers at once. (I know from a friend that does it.)

2. Build with the following -

• 
  Intel Core i7-4770 Haswell 3.4GHz (Would consider 4770K)
  MSI Z87-G41 PC Mate
  CORSAIR Vengeance 8GB DDR3 1866 (Will up grade IF I need to)
  SSD Boot Drive
  HHD Array Storage
  650W w/ 2 120mm case fans
  Windows 8.1

Thank you for your help in advance. I'm having difficulty determining which system has the most power and speed. Dual Xeons or i7-4770.

I have seen the CPUbenchmark scores and know that the 4770 scores higher, but don't know how the rest of the system effects the workflow outcome.


Both options are about $1200. Which is the price point I'd like to stay under. If this is a DUH question for you, please remember that it's not for me.

Thank you!

 

[AMD Radeon]

there is no chance of OLD cpu to beat current generation cpu
even if it is dual xeon

 

[Don Firth]

I've found the most important thing is the Video card and hard drive. Since these can be upgraded on both systems it comes down to price. There is a good chance you will find a better deal on the non-Mac video card. Since a 6-7 year old Video Card may not do the job. I personally got rid of my I3770K for a 2009 Mac Pro 8-Core 2.26 and there is no difference except for some reason the video looks better and Of course everything just works.

Hello!

I really need feedback about a new system I am planning to build or buy. It needs to be able to handle the following:

1. (Lightroom Enfuse) - Merge anywhere from 4, 8 12, or 18 raw images (25MB each file) into one image (tif), and repeat that several times simultaneously. IE; merge 4 RAWS, merge 5 RAWS, merge 8 RAWS, Merge 12 RAWS, Merge 8 RAWS, Merge 5 RAWS.... All at the same time.

2. RAW file timelapse.

3. HD Video


The two options I'm considering are:

1. Buy a used (2008 or 2009) Mac Pro - Dual Quad Core Xeon 3.0GHz or 3.2Ghz (8-core) I know a Mac Pro 1,1 Dual Xeon 2.0 GHz (5130) can run 12 simultaneous LREnfues mergers at once. (I know from a friend that does it.)

2. Build with the following -

• 
  Intel Core i7-4770 Haswell 3.4GHz (Would consider 4770K)
  MSI Z87-G41 PC Mate
  CORSAIR Vengeance 8GB DDR3 1866 (Will up grade IF I need to)
  SSD Boot Drive
  HHD Array Storage
  650W w/ 2 120mm case fans
  Windows 8.1

Thank you for your help in advance. I'm having difficulty determining which system has the most power and speed. Dual Xeons or i7-4770.

I have seen the CPUbenchmark scores and know that the 4770 scores higher, but don't know how the rest of the system effects the workflow outcome.


Both options are about $1200. Which is the price point I'd like to stay under. If this is a DUH question for you, please remember that it's not for me.

Thank you!

 

[NickZee]

I appreciate your input gentlemen! I have opted for the Intel 4770 build.