Old thread but posting In case someone has the same issue. I didn't use Honestech, but MAGIXs Rescue Your Videotapes! (www.magix.com/gb/video-to-dvd/) and had the same issue. Turned out that the Disk drives were different between my computers, and on the older computer it wasn't able to read newer Disks. No idea why. Anyway, given up with Disks - a hard drive man myself now.