not really, generally, liquid coolers will perform better than air coolers under load, but there are other aspects to consider. Here are a few pros and cons of each:
Air Cooler Pros:
1. Typically cost less than liquid cooler solutions although some air coolers are just as expensive
2. The only thing that makes noise is/are the fan(s)
3. Most air coolers have massive heatsinks, so even if a fan fails, you can sometimes still use your system until you can get a replacement
4. The only additional cost is if a fan fails or is too noisy or has bad performance and needs to be replaced.
5. Will NEVER leak anything into your system as liquid coolers may.
Air Cooler Cons:
1. Not all air coolers are compatible with all motherboards and cases. Some will only fit certain socket motherboards but most are universal, meaning they can be used on most builds, regardless of what motherboard socket is being used. The bigger drawback is that some air coolers will cause interference with the RAM slots or will limit how tall the RAM height can be. Air coolers can be very tall, so have the potential of not fitting in some cases, or having to remove case fans in order for them to fit, usually side fan(s) although sometimes top fan(s) as well. However, a little homework will avoid any such issues.
Liquid cooler Pros:
1. Usually provide better cooling under load than air coolers.
2. The CPU water block generally will not cause any interference with RAM slots nor will it impact the RAM height you can use.
3. Some liquid coolers are less expensive than a comparable air cooler (comparable in terms of performance).
Liquid cooler Cons:
1. Can cost more than some air coolers
2. Can have (or develop) leaks which can get on/into your motherboard and other components
3. If a radiator fan fails, same as air cooler issue. However if the pump (that circulates the liquid) dies or becomes excessively noisy, you must replace the entire liquid cooler setup if it is an All-In-One (such as the Corsair H100i). If it is a custom loop, you would only replace the pump (which costs more than replacing a fan).
4. Not all water coolers are compatible with cases. Some cases will not allow or will limit the size radiator it can support size-wise not weight-wise.
These are just a few of the things to consider when trying to choose between an air cooler or liquid cooling.