Tom's Hardware > Forum > Overclocking > Cooler and Heatsinks > finished lapping my Q6600 (with pics and results)

finished lapping my Q6600 (with pics and results) - Page 3

Forum Overclocking : Cooler and Heatsinks - finished lapping my Q6600 (with pics and results)

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Last message on previous page:



???

Reply to dignatec
Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +


Oh rodney, you slay me! :D

------------------------------ Lian-Li PC-7B | XClio Greatpower 550W | P4 3.2 Prescott SL7E5 | Scythe Ninja
2GB DDR400 Corsair VS (4*512) | eVGA nVidia GF 7600GS AGP vmod 1.46/1.91 OCd 759/907
WD 160GB & 640GB SATA
WinXP MCE 2004
Reply to KyleSTL

dignatec wrote :

Shadow: Thanks for not flaming me, I had a feeling some people might get a bit upset about my remark.

However, I'm talking bout a modern pc, the q6600. There was one review site that showed no diff (forget which one, can google for it) and that makes sense for me. I agree the TRUE may not be 100% optimized for older chips in terms of modern chips, it should be for newer chips. Again for 2-3 C, it's not worth me spending 3+ hrs for very little gain and losing my warranty....


Even on the newer CPUs you can still expect about 7-10C drop. Seen this with a E6600. Again it depends on each CPU.

------------------------------ http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2617/3815217176_0a5be7955d_o.gif
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3553/3818083596_1a772f7162_o.gif
Reply to Shadow703793

Hmm.... well let me OC my cpu to 3.6 and see how hot it gets this weekend. I'll think about the lapping issue after that. Some before/after screen's would be helpful! :)


Message edited by dignatec on 04-04-2008 at 03:45:51 PM
Reply to dignatec

^ Agreed, unfortunately I usually lap CPU/Heatsink any way even before OCing so I don't have any sceenshots. Make note that those 10C drops were due to lapping BOTH CPU AND Heatsink

 

Here is a pic of one of my lappped CPU:
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3271/2393164766_f397dd7feb_b.jpg


Message edited by Shadow703793 on 04-06-2008 at 07:21:08 PM
------------------------------ http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2617/3815217176_0a5be7955d_o.gif
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3553/3818083596_1a772f7162_o.gif
Reply to Shadow703793
- -1 +

How do u sand the board? How did u get your hands in there?

Reply to dignatec

dignatec wrote :

How do u sand the board? How did u get your hands in there?



wow.....

Um...

Wow....

:pfff:

------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Reply to spaztic7

[quotemsg=1752127,109,134604]wow.....

Um...

Wow....

:pfff:[/quotemsg
thats hilarious

Reply to cory1234

dignatec wrote :

How do u sand the board? How did u get your hands in there?


Ok Ill try not to laugh ..... :lol: ... YOU TAKE THE CPU OUT OF THE BOARD AND SAND IT :lol: :lol:

------------------------------ http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2617/3815217176_0a5be7955d_o.gif
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3553/3818083596_1a772f7162_o.gif
Reply to Shadow703793

dignatec wrote :

How do u sand the board? How did u get your hands in there?



See class, THATS how you get a dead thread started again!




:lol:

Reply to mford66215

dignatec:
Sorry, I did not mean any harm in what I said.... I am just stunned that you asked that question.

------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Reply to spaztic7
- 0 +

Had anybody consider that temp. decrese is due to less space between heat source and spreader and so it could be important to lap as deep as possible and not only to match two surfices???

Reply to ed22222
- 0 +

can you lap vga gpu as well

Reply to ed22222

ed22222 wrote :

can you lap vga gpu as well



be difficult as gpu is not mounted in a socket so how could you take it out and do what is described.

------------------------------ Intel E6750 @ 3.20Ghz | Asus PK5-E | 2 x 1GB Corsair XMS2 PC-6400 | XFX GeForce 8800GT | 2 x WD 320GB in RAID 0 + 1 x WD 500GB | Corsair VX550W | NZXT Adamas | Acer X222W | ORTHOS Stable (8hrs 'Small FFTs' / 24hrs 'Blend')
Reply to Maximus_Delta
- 0 +

the concavity probably comes from how they are stamped out of the sheet.

does removing the protective layer cause corosion problems.

I used to alwayes hear about removing the IHS from back in the s939 days.

does anyone still do this?

Reply to Groo

This thread inspired me to do the same with my E8400:

Started with 400 finished with 1000.

[img]http://img177.imageshack.us/img177/4715/img0378cf4.th.jpg
[/img]

[img]http://img177.imageshack.us/img177/9171/img0383mk7.th.jpg
[/img]

Temps are about the same... But it's way hotter today compared to when I did the pre temps. Also I am hoping once the thermalgrease is broken in it will be a bit lower. 36c before and 36c after.

------------------------------ EVGA 780i--Intel E8400@4.05Ghz--TRUE--EVGA 8800GT SLI--2X2GB OCZ reaper @800mhz 4-4-4-15-1T--Antec 900--PCPC 750 silencer--150 raptorX!
Reply to hughyhunter
- 0 +

Hey graysky, is your Q6600 GO stepping?
Does anybody thinkhs having a Scythe Infinity with 2 fans (1300 rpm push - pull) on a Q6600 GO @ 3.3GHZ getting 70ºC to be normal?


Message edited by rojito on 05-14-2008 at 01:42:24 AM
Reply to rojito

Hi,
This is my first post to the forum, great site people, keep up the great work and advice.

I want to comment on the Lapping subject.... The comment left by jimmm is correct (my opinion), when tightening down on the HS there is alway going to be a little flex, especially in the casing of the cpu due to the thiness in the casing of the cpu. Once tightened evenly the surface will flex (although you will not see it with the naked eye, it will flex) and will be very close if not almost perfect. Even after 1 month re tighten the screws again evenly and you will not need any lapping.

Take care all...and good luck.

Peace

Reply to vette98guy
- 0 +

rojito, as I've said on the thread you started, no those are not good temperatures for your setup. Something is awry. Please try cleaning and reapplying.


Message edited by KyleSTL on 05-14-2008 at 04:37:50 PM
------------------------------ Lian-Li PC-7B | XClio Greatpower 550W | P4 3.2 Prescott SL7E5 | Scythe Ninja
2GB DDR400 Corsair VS (4*512) | eVGA nVidia GF 7600GS AGP vmod 1.46/1.91 OCd 759/907
WD 160GB & 640GB SATA
WinXP MCE 2004
Reply to KyleSTL



Cavemen didnt have zippers :pfff:

Reply to Eggrenade

nice job. i'm surprised someone doesn't offer this as a service.
when i worked at Spectra-Physics, a laser company, they had
some beautiful equipment for creating very flat surfaces with
very fine finishes.

that or a properly configured milling machine with a vacuum
chuck (vise).

------------------------------ Main Rig ~ Q9550, Aysus P5E-VM HDMI uATX board, Sapphire 3870, XQ-Pack, Seegate 640, Seesonic 650
#2 Rig ~ E6700, 1ntel 965G uATX board, eVGA 7600GT, XQ-Pack, Seegate 320 GB, Seesonic 430 Watts
http://LASIK-FLAP.com/ ~ About LASIK Eye Surgery
Reply to Raviolissimo

just to reassert what these guys are saying , it does work lapping cpu+heatsink , for comparison the ideal thing is a car engine , when manufactured they cast the engine block on mass to produce a good level of performance , it works fine and most people are happy with that , but for the odd few people you can 'gas flow the engine and skim the head increasing performance. this is exactly the same with the cpu and heatsink , there designed to a set target which pleases 90% of customers and serves its purpose , but for the odd few nutters like ourselfs , lapping them refines out the inconsistencys that manufacturing cant do cost effectively and gives you a boost.
p.s copper doesnt tend to oxidize much indoors like it does outside due to lower humidity , also AS5 if applyed properly will act as a barrier too.

Reply to samuraiblade
- 0 +

i work in a metal mfg plant. we lap about every product we make.

i am going to lap my cpu and hs on a granite table here when i get my build.

i will make sure to take pictures and post.

OT, i think i will also use our chroming facility to mod my case, i am thinking of a nice steel case that i can turn into a cylon

Reply to bohman
- 0 +

re: the flexing:
I'm sure there is some insignificant amount of flexing, but over such a small area, its probably even less than surface irregularity after lapping.

re: the Cylon case:
good luck finding a steel case without plastic on it. you might have better luck with aluminum, but, I don't know if they plate differently.

I think you'll also have a tough time finding a case with a smooth enough surface to look good, even with a thick nickel layer.

might be better off with a SS Antec p182

Reply to Groo

Need a little help...
I've been practicing lapping heat sinks off some old PC's, and found that if I go up to 400 grain, i can then use brasso (metal polish) and a cloth and get it to mirror smoothness. Only worry is that if i do that to a CPU heat sink, there may be residue left over on the base that might damage the CPU. Any thoughts?

Reply to Dutchjonsey
- 0 +

Dutchjonsey wrote :

Only worry is that if i do that to a CPU heat sink, there may be residue left over on the base that might damage the CPU. Any thoughts?


No it will not 'hurt' the CPU, but may inhibit the heatsink's ability to transfer the heat (because of inpurities in the mating surface between the IHS and HSF. Use ArctiClean 1 & 2 after you're done with everything and your setup should work optimally.

------------------------------ Lian-Li PC-7B | XClio Greatpower 550W | P4 3.2 Prescott SL7E5 | Scythe Ninja
2GB DDR400 Corsair VS (4*512) | eVGA nVidia GF 7600GS AGP vmod 1.46/1.91 OCd 759/907
WD 160GB & 640GB SATA
WinXP MCE 2004
Reply to KyleSTL

Thanks for the assist!

Reply to Dutchjonsey
- 0 +

lapping is supose to just even out surface irregulaities, so it could be done. I have a fealing that most take off to much material to do exposed heatpipes safely. If your going to try it, I'd start with the fine grit.

Reply to Groo

I gave up on my Xiggy S1283 about 2 months ago and put this AC7 on. I just got back from Lowes and all they had (horrible selection) was 220 all purpose, 400 wetordry and 600 wetordry, I bought all 3 of those. I got home and checked the Xiggy with the razor blade and its preety bad, along the copper pipes its not THAT bad.....but across the pipes its horrible, the blade dosent even touch the pipes due to the aluminum pieces, its just not even close. Im gonna mess with it here soon, and maybe do my Q6600 afterwards. Like alot of other people mine appears to be preety concave/convex w/e. Cores 0 and 1 are 4-7c higher than 2 and 3 no matter what cooler I put on here.

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/547515.png
Intel Xeon X3370 @3.6ghz Under Enzotech Extreme-X,EVGA GTX 285 SC, 4GB Mushkin Ascent eVCI @ 1066mhz, Gigabyte P45 UD3P
Reply to spathotan

Should Try someday xD

Reply to Anonymous

I've lapped my CPU/HSF combo twice and both times ive only experienced a 1-3 degree diff. waste o time IMO.

------------------------------ EVGA 780i--Intel E8400@4.05Ghz--TRUE--EVGA 8800GT SLI--2X2GB OCZ reaper @800mhz 4-4-4-15-1T--Antec 900--PCPC 750 silencer--150 raptorX!
Reply to hughyhunter

Very interesting and an enjoyable read but can I add one other variable in to the mix.

When metal, be it copper or aluminum has heat applied to it, it will expand and change shape or distort around the area that is heated. So where your IHS is concerned the edges are cooler while the area directly above the cores gets hotter and the hot area becomes larger while the cooler area stays the same. So the surface is no longer flat.

So you may have two perfectly mated surfaces when cold but once heat is added those two surfaces may not be mated so perfectly and as temps increase so does the distortion. So I would imagine that a thin IHS could bow or ripple i.e. one side goes up while the other goes down as it's heated.

No amount of lapping can compensate for this, the best you can hope for is that your IHS expands in an upward direction to mate with your HSF, cooler block or whatever you have.
Maybe this is why some HSF are convex in shape to push into the centre of the IHS to control the direction of movement and improve the contact area as it expands.

But there again I could be completely wrong. :D

http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/426925.png


Message edited by Computer Dave on 10-04-2008 at 02:52:20 PM
Reply to Computer Dave

Good points^^

Right now I'm pretty impressed!

Running 29C idle with all fans on low. Of course I have power plan on balanced so it's idling at 2.0Ghz. But I think 29C is pretty impressive for idle temps.

------------------------------ EVGA 780i--Intel E8400@4.05Ghz--TRUE--EVGA 8800GT SLI--2X2GB OCZ reaper @800mhz 4-4-4-15-1T--Antec 900--PCPC 750 silencer--150 raptorX!
Reply to hughyhunter
- 0 +

distotion only occurs with different material expanding at different rates or different temperatures within the block. the CPU block should be relativly uniform in temperature. so should the mating surface of the heatsink. heat pipes generaly run clean through the hetsink mating surface, so uneven expansion shouldn't distort the base' surface. the fins can bend and flex all they want, it shouldn't matter, but might if the heatsink was poorly designed.
Even bad distortion should be minimal over a 2" square, so none of this probably means anything..

Reply to Groo

I used to do this with all my old CPU's, P400's, etc. used a copper heatsink and arctic silver. got some really good results. Might have to try this again when i get a new cpu and watercooling soon. not sure if it's worth it at the moment tho as i have dual 2Ghz clocked to 3.4 with air-cooling anyway and low temps (very lucky)
Vinceak - older dual cores aren't really stable over 55C i believe. newer ones can go a bit higher maybe 65C. I remember someone mentioning on another forum that the Q6660 would be ok somewhere around 100C! (referring to the datasheet) Wouldn't like to try it tho, and doubt it would boot

Reply to m_silkstone

Hi this is johncena. I lapped the IHS a little more, seemed to flatten it out a little bit more, and made it a little more shiny. I added a generous amount of AS5, against my better judgment, and temps seemed to have dropped back to where they were. I may have gained a degree or two, but nothing significant.
==============================================
johncena

Link Building

Reply to johncena

just wanted to know, as im newish to overclocking (my first overclocked machine)

My processor is running at 3.2g with multiplier 9 and Bus at 256,
Core voltage is set to 1.36 so if i lapped my processor and heat sink does this mean better contact between the 2 resulting in less heat and lower voltages??

Reply to specialresident22

Yes, the heat should be dissipated better, resulting in lower observed temperatures. Will it be enough that you can lower voltages---hard to say for sure, but I would doubt it.

Reply to Athlon Mark

In my experience it doesn't mean you can lower the voltage, but you can raise them with less ill effect

Reply to m_silkstone
- 0 +

do you still use thermal paste when your cpu and hs is lapped?

Reply to soul23

Of course, but you need a lot less.

Reply to m_silkstone
- 0 +

I have noticed that everyone is using an intel cpu. Has anyone tried this with an AMD cpu. If i did this would I get roughly the same results as the rest of you guys or would i just be waisting my time?

Reply to rav3n
- 0 +

:hello: Hi, i have just finshed lapping my q6600 & heat sink, and very satisfied with the result after putting it all together again with arctic silver thermal paste, and several hours of cpu burn in, checked the temperatures with realtemp, coretemp, occt and speedfan and found that the temperatures had dropped by 10c.

My setup

CPU----------------Intel core2 quad Q6600 @2.4GHz overclock to 3.6GHz :p
Motherboard-----P5Q
Ram----------------Corsair XMS2 Dominator 2GB
Case---------------Thermaltake Armor LCS VE2000BWS
PSU-----------------Jeantech Storm 700W Sli/Cross-fire
GPU-----------------Nvidia Geforce 9400 GT


Temp Before lapping idle 37c,34c,33c,32c
Temp Before lapping, running intelburn test 82c,82c,79c,79c :fou: :fou:

intelburn test setting

Turn on error detection (y/n) Y
Stress levels 1
Enter number of time to run the test 6
PC passed this test several times

Temperature on start up this morning at 07.45 were 30c,25c,25c,25c, after leaving the pc idle for about an hour temperatures were 33c,30c.30c,30c

Idle temp after lapping are 33c,30c,30c,30c
Idle temp after runing the above test again were 72c,72c,68c,68c :pt1cable: :bounce: :bounce:

so not a bad result i think, would like some input or comments on this from other overclockers :hello: :hello:

Reply to The Taz
- 0 +

A 10°C difference at load is probably one of the best I've seen, although it's hard to eliminate potential differences in mounting that could have helped as well. Congrats on a successful lapping.

Reply to KyleSTL

rav3n wrote :

I have noticed that everyone is using an intel cpu. Has anyone tried this with an AMD cpu. If i did this would I get roughly the same results as the rest of you guys or would i just be waisting my time?


That's what I was thinking. I've got a Phenom II, but looks like our skin would be squished on the pins if we were holding them like Intel owners do. LGA775 has little bumpy things that don't get in the way of hands, lucky Intel >.> I'm gonna get an old e63 for $35 and OC the poop outa it.

Reply to computabug
- 0 +

I've lapped a couple of 478 intel chips that have a PGA like the AMD processors. As long as you're careful and clean (i.e. wash your hands) you shouldn't have any problems.

Reply to KyleSTL

Alright, I'm going to try and lap my P4 next weekend. Is there any chance somebody with girly fingers could avoid touching the pins entirely?

Reply to computabug
- 0 +

computabug wrote :

Alright, I'm going to try and lap my P4 next weekend. Is there any chance somebody with girly fingers could avoid touching the pins entirely?


If you'd like to eliminate finger prints aswell, probably.

Reply to KyleSTL

This topic has been desticky in top of the forum by Randomizer

Reply to randomizer

^Are you going to combine the two lapping guides and sticky it or not?

------------------------------ http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2617/3815217176_0a5be7955d_o.gif
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3553/3818083596_1a772f7162_o.gif
Reply to Shadow703793
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Overclocking > Cooler and Heatsinks > finished lapping my Q6600 (with pics and results)
Go to:

There are 888 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them