Tom's Hardware Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » Phenom 9850 v Q6600 For Fun System
 

Phenom 9850 v Q6600 For Fun System

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
 Page :   1  2
Next 
Author
 Thread : Phenom 9850 v Q6600 For Fun System
 
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Last message on previous page:

customisbetter wrote :

What is "flame baiting"?



Flame baiting, at least as I understand it is posting intentionally inflamatory comments with the intent of starting an argument.

Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

And yes, it can run Crysis.
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

ahhh gotcha. thanks.


---------------
e4400 (SLA5F???)2.66Ghz
ECS 945 GCT-M
2x1GB Kingston 667
EVGA 8800 GS SC 712/1728/1031
Profile: journeyman
More Information

dragunover wrote :

I would definitely stick with the Q6600.No offense,but AMD has been really disappointing me.Plus,you would be saving money.




How does AMD disappoint you? The Phenom is native quad core. The Q6600 is a Multi Chip Module.
Native quad core has TREMENDOUS advantages over a Multi-Chip Module.

You're not being honest.

Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

Just_An_Engineer wrote :

I'm still not sure I believe the quoted $284 price for the 2.66 GHz Nehalem. Certainly would be great if it does turn out that way. I'm a little concerned about what the new motherboards might cost. Given that this will be the enthusiast targeted Nehalem I wouldn't be surprised to see the motherboard prices be quite high indeed.



This is true. Most of the time the companies release the uber extreme mobos so I would expect one thats just out of this world in features witht the X58 chipset to be first and then a few more mild solutions.

I was just woundering but wont there be a P55 chipset as well for the enthusiast class people? And since Nehalem will no longer be dependant on the Northbridge for memory I would expect it to be on either the 1366 or other socket sine its the CPU that determines how many DDR3 channels i.e. Bloomfield will have 3 and Lynnfield will have 2.

Well either way good luck with your build. Just make sure you are happy with what you buy cuz thats what matters most.


---------------
http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/381014.png
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

enigma067 wrote :

How does AMD disappoint you? The Phenom is native quad core. The Q6600 is a Multi Chip Module.
Native quad core has TREMENDOUS advantages over a Multi-Chip Module.

You're not being honest.



Truth be told those advantages are only seen in the server market due the the naitive quad cores ability to communicate with eachother without having to go trough the FSB and instead have the HTT links to use. Other than that in the desktop market the MCM has been able to outpace the naitive quad without any problems in most normal apps and games.

As for him I would only guess he was pulled into the Phenom hype of it being much better than Core 2 or maybe something else.


Message edited by jimmysmitt y on 07-25-2008 at 12:50:53 AM

---------------
http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/381014.png
And yes, it can run Crysis.
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Thanks Jimmy
Im already feeling pretty smug right now. My sis decided she neeeeeeeeeded a 500 dollar smartphone. I said its not worth it, she won't use half the features and the touch screen will break. Guess who's phone needs a new screen?
from batman "i bloody did tell you"!


---------------
e4400 (SLA5F???)2.66Ghz
ECS 945 GCT-M
2x1GB Kingston 667
EVGA 8800 GS SC 712/1728/1031
And yes, it can run Crysis.
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

And i wasn't pulled into the hype by anything. I am just bored of everyone using intel. I kind of want to give AMD a chance. Thats all.


---------------
e4400 (SLA5F???)2.66Ghz
ECS 945 GCT-M
2x1GB Kingston 667
EVGA 8800 GS SC 712/1728/1031
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

^LMAO

Yea they are not that great unless you can use the features.

I read that the touch technology Apple bought for the iPhone wears out after a while.

And $500 bucks on a phone? Mand thats near 2 HD4870s for CF that will rip most games up.....


---------------
http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/381014.png
And yes, it can run Crysis.
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

yeah, apperently ATT is giving her another 600 dollar phone for 130 plus two months of insurance free. I guess they only hate iphone users. BTW they gave me my phone free as well. Dads got an iphone but the service is decent.


uh... amd FTW? there, no spam.


---------------
e4400 (SLA5F???)2.66Ghz
ECS 945 GCT-M
2x1GB Kingston 667
EVGA 8800 GS SC 712/1728/1031
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

^I will agree that AMDs ATI divison is doing quite good and makes me happy they are as I have always been able to trust ATI cards. Whenever I used nVidia it always bit me in the ass. Either the driver caused BSoD (in 2K and XP) or it just didn't perform like it should have.


---------------
http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/381014.png
And yes, it can run Crysis.
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

I found this at
http://www.tweaktown.com/news/9814 [...] index.html

 

It is not hurting my decision.

 

Unfortunately my e4400 at 2.66 does it in 22 seconds. not much of a boost there, maybe not multi-threaded?

 

http://images.tweaktown.com/imagebank/news_AMDPhenomX4DenebSPI1Mitocp-4_full.jpg

 

Ok ive edited this about ten times, the picture worked the first time but now won't.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by customisbe tter on 07-25-2008 at 05:37:39 AM

---------------
e4400 (SLA5F???)2.66Ghz
ECS 945 GCT-M
2x1GB Kingston 667
EVGA 8800 GS SC 712/1728/1031
Profile: addict
More Information

i prefer 9950

Yup, you got it buddy
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

customisbetter wrote :

I found this at
http://www.tweaktown.com/news/9814 [...] index.html

It is not hurting my decision.

Unfortunately my e4400 at 2.66 does it in 22 seconds. not much of a boost there, maybe not multi-threaded?

http://images.tweaktown.com/imageb [...] 4_full.jpg

Ok ive edited this about ten times, the picture worked the first time but now won't.



SuperPi is single threaded and highly intel optimized, well, depends a lot on the integer performance of the processor. Which Intel does better at. Granted I can show you benchmarks in Everest where the phenom completely wipes the floor with Intel without breaking a sweat. My system for example scores 50092 on the PhotoWorxx bench, compared to the 28809 that the QX9650 gets.

If you're doing compression of a lot of large files, Phenom will have the advantage there, especially if you OC the IMC/L3. WinRar bench can show that easily. 1,928KB/s on my old 9600be at 2.6core, 2.4 IMC/L3, and that was on my k9a2 plat with an early beta bios, only running DDR2 800 memory. If you can, go with 1066 DDR2, it's worth it. Ram speed does effect system performance on the k10, more so than the q6600.
This is what my current build does in WinRAR with no OCing, Main difference being 1066 memory. Come to think of it, think the 9600be was getting over 2000 at the stated settings.
http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/Mathos/WinRARCurrent.jpg
And that wasn't even hitting 100% cpu usage.
Music is more of a mixed bag, depends on what you're doing or whether it's multi threaded.

The_Blood_Raven wrote :

Ok here is what I want you to do OP. Get some blue paint and some green paint. Now get a slice of Rye bread, NO SEEDS!!! Paint one side of the slice blue and paint the other green. Now I want you to go find the NEWEST car in the neighborhood and toss the painted slice of bread up in the air so it falls on the car. Now when you remove the slice of bread if the paint on the car is blue, then go get the Q6600. If it is green get the 9850 and the SB750 later down the road.

Or you could go with a Via system just to shake things up a bit!



:D hmmm think I might use this idea for choosing my next major system build. There are a few neighbors cars I wouldn't mind doing that test on :).


---------------
AMD Phenom X4 9850 Black Edition, ZeroTherm Nirvana 120 Premium CPU Cooler, MSI K9a2 Platinum bios 1.1b3 or P.0J, 4GB (2x2) Mushkin DDR2 1066 (pc8500) 5-5-5-15 2.05v RAM, Sapphire Toxic HD3870, Raidmax RX-700SS PSU, Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 320gb SATA2 X
And yes, it can run Crysis.
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

for only 35 bucks more, i might get the 9950 instead. iv read that it clocks to 3.3 with the sb600.

Message quoted 3 times
Message edited by customisbe tter on 07-25-2008 at 09:28:59 AM

---------------
e4400 (SLA5F???)2.66Ghz
ECS 945 GCT-M
2x1GB Kingston 667
EVGA 8800 GS SC 712/1728/1031
Profile: member
More Information

Right now I have a 9850 BE system.It runs great (especially very smooth with the IMC).I would go with the 9950 BE CPU right now if you get a good motherboard that supports it.I use the
ASUS M3A32-MVP Deluxe AM2+/AM2 AMD 790FX ATX AMD Motherboard for my system which uses the SB600.This motherboard works with the 9950 with a simple BIOS update.However you might want to wait for the 790FX,750 SB motherboards to come out.
I've ducted my Window air conditioning system so that it supercools the components in my PC.

Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

^Be careful with the 9950. It has a 140w TDP and if you OC you will want to get a good HSF.


---------------
http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/381014.png
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

Get... BOTH!! put em together, run em... and... send back the one you don't like? :oops:

Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

^Always the easy way out huh Girmmy? lol


---------------
http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/381014.png
Profile: addict
More Information

customisbetter wrote :

for only 35 bucks more, i might get the 9950 instead. iv read that it clocks to 3.3 with the sb600.



You can get $15 off the Phenom 9950BE at The Egg with promo code EMCAHCCBJ.

jimmysmitty wrote :

^Be careful with the 9950. It has a 140w TDP and if you OC you will want to get a good HSF.



Odd