Last message on previous page:
| Quote : I cannot believe that this thread is still going..... o well. |
"Believe it, hot rod."
--At Toon, "Volunteers"
I have to say, I feel somewhat vindicated here. The longer this thread has gone, the more people seem to agree with the basic premise of the original article -- that WoW can be addictive for some people -- while I'm getting flamed less and less for writing the darn thing.
Rob, you're a horrible editor, you have no life, and your mom hates you. [/flame, flame, flame]
I think people are just finally becoming aware (again!) that new things still lead to old problems. Honestly, it's those with the biggest problem that flamed the hardest, and they've since moved on. I'm grateful to see public awareness improve, because now, as BigMac states, we have more help available.
Thanks Twisted_Sister for your words. I'm sure brooklynitegirl was serious in her question, though she probably wasn't a regular and only found this thread via googling. I hope she found her answer.
| Quote : What would happen if you started playing WoW with him*? Would he enjoy having you take an interest in his interest (obsession?), or would he get angry because WoW is "his domain".
|
yea, it's a nice compromise... BUT that will only make it MUCH worse. It's sending the wrong signal to his problem (affirming that his excessive playing is ok)... she'd be essentially a crutch. Plus, it's not the quality time together that relationship needs.
I equate it to a spouse becoming a drinking partner w/ an aloholic. A very bad idea.
I know a bunch of fathers who have a gaming problem. Since their time is finite, they teach and encourage their kids to play video games. They see it as killing 2 birds with one stone... but the reality is that they are not providing the proper type & amount of nurturing to their kids. It's very sad.
Plus, they often let their young kids play games that are much too mature for them and/or online games (everyone knows how uncensored it is online).
She needs some tough love on this...
I knew I would get a reply like this.
I was thinking she could use "I spent time doing what you want, now be fair and do something I would like"; which would get him off the game and outdoors. But yeah, I can see why that isn't the best option.
As for the fathers with gaming problems? Give the kids some CIV or R:TW for History, Sim City for economics and Windows ME for advanced IT troubleshooting
But seriously though, I've actually learnt a lot about history from video games through RTS. I've also learnt that no matter how strong your character is, they will always be killed instantly any time they go near water.
But yeah, I agree with the tough love. This may sound like a totally stupid question but since I don't play WoW I don't know so:
Are WoW characters saved on the server or on the users PC? If they are saved on the PC... (Oops, sorry hon, I accidently hit the "format" button).
It'll be server-sid eI'd have thought (terminal-side would make it too easy for people to cheat).
Having said that, it shouldn't be beyond the wit of a better half to deduce/find out his login and password...
| Quote : It'll be server-sid eI'd have thought (terminal-side would make it too easy for people to cheat).
|
yeah, there are programs to log keystrokes... very common use when a spouse suspects unusual computer activity (e.g. cheating, going to bad websites, etc.).
| Quote : It'll be server-sid eI'd have thought (terminal-side would make it too easy for people to cheat).
|
yeah, there are programs to log keystrokes... very common use when a spouse suspects unusual computer activity (e.g. cheating, going to bad websites, etc.).
How is she going to get him off the computer long enough to install the keystroke logger?
| Quote : It'll be server-sid eI'd have thought (terminal-side would make it too easy for people to cheat).
|
yeah, there are programs to log keystrokes... very common use when a spouse suspects unusual computer activity (e.g. cheating, going to bad websites, etc.).
How is she going to get him off the computer long enough to install the keystroke logger?
She's his girlfriend - use your imagination.
| Quote :
|
Clearly you underestimate the power of a true addiction...
I'm SURE all you gamers are way smarter than a doctor of psychology! Come on people, it says 40%. So some of you are not addicted; CONGRADULATIONS! However the results of a study done by a doctor is somehow more convincing than gamers in denile! IF YOU ASK ME I'D SAY PAYING THAT MUCH MONEY TO PLAY THE STUPID GAME AND MONTHLY AT THAT, PLUS BUYING EXPANSIONS AND WHAT NOT! HMMM I'D SAY THAT SHOULD DECLARE AN ADDICT RIGHT THERE! 8O
You're addicted to BBCode.
Welcome to the forumz.
| Quote : I'm SURE all you gamers are way smarter than a doctor of psychology! Come on people, it says 40%. So some of you are not addicted; CONGRADULATIONS! However the results of a study done by a doctor is somehow more convincing than gamers in denile! IF YOU ASK ME I'D SAY PAYING THAT MUCH MONEY TO PLAY THE STUPID GAME AND MONTHLY AT THAT, PLUS BUYING EXPANSIONS AND WHAT NOT! HMMM I'D SAY THAT SHOULD DECLARE AN ADDICT RIGHT THERE! 8O |
The ugly side of denial... the yelling friends.
Do you have some personal stake in game addiction? Just seems like it struck a nerve. 8)
| Quote : I'm SURE all you gamers are way smarter than a doctor of psychology! Come on people, it says 40%. So some of you are not addicted; CONGRADULATIONS! However the results of a study done by a doctor is somehow more convincing than gamers in denile! IF YOU ASK ME I'D SAY PAYING THAT MUCH MONEY TO PLAY THE STUPID GAME AND MONTHLY AT THAT, PLUS BUYING EXPANSIONS AND WHAT NOT! HMMM I'D SAY THAT SHOULD DECLARE AN ADDICT RIGHT THERE! 8O |
By using your logic people who put petrol in their cars twice a week are addicted to cars and everyone is addicted to food because they eat everyday.
I've rather there be WoW addicts who stay at their PC all the time than heroin addicts who rob old ladies for their pension.
P.S. Welcome to the forums.
Well. Ofcourse people get addicted. Everyone want the epixx and have to grind there ass off all the time!
Take a short cut. Got se http://www.mmoverload.com and let them help you out. Helped me get my epic flying mout as lvl 70 and the fastes way througe Karazan, Grulls lair etc.
Ive played wow for about two years now, i really dont do much else, lost my friends, dropped out of school all i ever do is play wow and yes i feel like its an addiction i really cant stop
I can't stand the game, been playing 2 months, have a 46 mage and 32 druid, I just can't stand it, but I do play other games that I have commitments to, such as battlefield 2 ladder. I guess, if I would've started playing when it came out - I would be a zombie by now, I wouldn't of known there's other types of quests other than escort this or kill this xxxxxx many times by playing better games.
I have Crysis and GW Eye of the north preordered, just waiting for ut3, sc2, and quake wars release dates (I don't preorder unless I know the release date and it's a game I want).
people like this lady and others like her make me sick
u should see some of the videos on the web where u have grown women crying because there son wont stop playing wow
its ridiculous how gullible people can be when someone slaps a label on something as a disease
I think that anything, weather it be, drugs, video games, gambling, sex, alcohol, whatever the object is, it can be addicting.
People who want to put down others who feel this way are just as 'confused' as they think the ones doing the research are. If you have never experienced addiction on the forefront, never had to expose yourself to the losses that it can cause, then I think you have no right to place negativity on those who have.
I believe video games, especially ones like w.o.w. are extremely addictive, and dangerous. The ones who play, aren't always aware of the addictions they have, but without a doubt, the families, friends, workplace, and whatever else is involved in thier life, knows about the addiction, and suffer from it.
Before you jump on the case of someone who says that games are dangerous, take a look at what exactly they are saying, look at the symptoms, do you suffer from this disease? If so, maybe you should take this seriously, if you don't, then these articles are not specifically meant for you.
The main purpose is to help those who need it, and their lives that suffer.
Just wanna add my own experiences.
I played WoW since release until last Feb'07 (cant remember when it was released) and had been playing diablo2 for years before that.
I was hooked for the whole time, averaging well over 40-75+ hrs/week. I know it sucks and i knew it.
To everyone who angry to the doctor, u need to help yourself as in most cases, no one can help you.
Anyway, my best excuse for paying monthly fee to play WoW is it is the cheapest entertainment around (less than $20 for a MONTH)
My early gaming was just like others...hobby, pastimes etc... but life sucks sometimes... slowly it became a place to hide from real life. I started to avoid friends, late to work, felt happy when i was off from work not counting how many failed in uni etc. However these sad reality was "not that bad" when you are so good at the game...i was famous, well respected by the bad guys and good guys, i was rich (i had many legit godly items in the game) or having rare epics that not many people have access to etc. Its like a good substitute of sucking in real life.
There were times where i "woke up" trying to get back in real life, but it just never worked out. There were times where i broke down in tears for being a game addict and feeling trap, unable to get out.
Then i met this girl, who end up being my gf... we went through times like "brooklinenitegirl" mentioned (i met her before WoW release). Basicly everytime we have a fight, its due to me playing WoW.
To cut the story short, somehow (i had been trying to get back in real life for years and with a wonderful gf's support) i graduated...and finally found a full time job and since then i have been working more than 70hr/week. It just automatically stopped me from playing wow and kind of cured my WoW addiction.
Months have passed, now we just bought an apartment and I'm the happiest man in the world. It sucks to work 70+ hr/week but atleast now i'm grinding in real life and getting real life rewards (my gf, family are happy and proud of me).
Nothing to brag about here, if you note sign of addiction... or worst (real life sucks) WoW or any addictive games is NOT for you!!! help yourself out before it's too late.
Goodluck guys.
Regards,
former WoW addict
Well here's my experience.
I don't blame Blizzard, people make their own choices. I would say this game is addictive more in the way gambling can be than drugs.
I don't think that shows up well until people get into a raiding guild. I would say most raiding guilds have a LOT of addicted players. Players that would stew all night if they suddenly quit. This occurs for a lot of reasons.
First of all, every time you kill a boss is like a pull on the handle of a slot machine, "will it drop that purple I need?". You feel you need it so you can progress, but you also feel you need it for the bizarre fashion show that the forums and armory have become.
You become willing to try the same boss over and over again week after week until you a) succeed in killing it, and then b) the item you want drops. Now someone else may want that item too and have more DKP than you so now you have to keep going.
Downing a large raid boss for the first time has a certain elation to it. People will honestly cheer if it was a particularly tough fight. My guild got stuck at Morogrim for instance and when we finally got the mechanics down and won, I almost lost my eardrums for the screaming in ventrillo.
Well while you are doing this you build relationships with real people in an imaginary land. You start to feel like you are letting them down if you don't show up, they need you. This becomes part of your reasoning to play more and more. I HAVE to show up Thursday, my friends need me! Because of the nature of pulling 25 like minded people together, you end up with a schedule. So on raid nights, everything at home stops so you can go try to get that next purple and not let your 'friends' down.
OK, well raiding is expensive. Figure you'll spend 100g per raid night in a SSC/TK or higher progression guild. This includes repair (my gear cost 45 g to repair from 10%), 2 flasks at 25g a piece, and food for 5 g. You can farm this but making money is usually faster than farming at this level of the game. So now you dedicate your off raid nights to making money. You have to do about 8 dailies to keep this pace going. Dailies take between 10 and 20 minutes plus flight time between zones. So you have now dedicated 2 hours of your off nights to make enough gold to play for 4 hours on your raid nights. This puts you at a minimum of 18-20 hours a week every week.
You get a piece of t5 gear and then you start thinking, "we're only 2 bosses off the 2nd piece now" then the next thing you know you're spending an additional hour or 2 reading strategies in your off time...
I really don't know that addicted is the right word. I still knew when it was important to skip nights to go to parent teacher conferences, etc. However it's insidious and as you get better gear in more complex content you just keep wanting more, like your next big gambling score. I am not trying to make anyone quit, I'm just letting you know- this isn't the same as CS or SimCity
Well...here's the thing:
There is this book that all accredited therapists use to diagnose mental illness called the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders, or the "DSM" for short:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSM-IV
The current revision, the DSM-IV, has "Pathological Gambling" listed as a mental disorder. The problem with this is that it walks a fine line:
On one extreme there are some addictions that are also in the DSM that many do consider serious rather than just "excuses":
All the 292.xx code numbers deal with different drug addictions/intoxications/etc.
All the 291.xx code numbers deal with alcohol-related stuff.
On the other hand, the definition of "addiction" is pretty flaky as is. If somebody likes something enough, they'll want to do it above all other things.
All the 312.xx numbers are considered "impulse control disorders". These range from:
312.33 Pyromania (compulsive fire setting)
312.32 Kleptomania (compulsive stealing)
312.39 Trichotillomania (compulsive hair pulling)
312.34 Intermittent Explosive Disorder (get pissed off with little to no provocation)
312.81 Conduct Disorder (often the prelude to someone becoming a psychopath or sociopath when they get older)
312.31 Pathological Gambling (mentioned above)
312.30 Impulse-Control Disorder NOS (NOS stands for "Not Otherwise Specified" )
Out of those six specific impulse control disorders above (312.30 not included), how many of you actually believe that these are serious disorders and how many of you see them as excuses? It's a pretty damn fine line.
Unfortunately, psychiatry is not an exact science. Chemistry and Physics have units of measure like meters, grams, newtons, joules, etc. There are no "addictometers," "personalitometers," "fearometers," "realitometers," or "moodometers." Hell, we don't even have a clear-cut, objective meaning of what's considered "normal"!
In any case, if "Internet Addiction Disorder" or "Gaming Addiction Disorder" ends up in the DSM, they'll probably be under 312.xx alongside the existing entries that walk that fine line between "normal" and "pathological," or between "serious mental illness" and "lack of control and accountability for one's own actions."
Thoughts?
ok so like, here's the truth... they other day when i logged into wow (been playing since beta), I noticed my time played was 57 days... blah blah... now this is just on my 70 level mage... it like hit me hard... 57 days (57*24 hours = 1368 hours) that i had wasted on this char alone... not to mention all my others (have about 15, but only 6 above level 35)... HOLY FRIGGIN HELL! how many hours of my life have i wasted playing a stupid game? I need to go see this Dr. lol. Seriously this is friggin sad, disgusting, pathetic... I mean, why the hell do i still play? I have pretty much done it all, seen what i wanted to see, and killed all the alliance i wanted to... damn what a waste... time for this troll to retire... lol. I swear I am NOT loggin in tonight... i have to break the chain. This is just sickening.... I need to add up all the hours on all my chars to really make myself sick
When people play MMOs until they die, and their social life suffers because of a game then I think that qualifies as an addiction. It wouldn't surprise me if 40% of players are addicted.
I know what its like I was addicted to a MMORPG before, played it like 4h a day for 4months.
To be fair I did almost make £1k by selling stuff tho lol. See my computer specs for proof
As for me, eight years ago I was starting to get addicted to MMORPGs because it felt like they allow you to get into imaginary worlds in more submersive ways than TV, video films and single player games allowed you to do. It felt like by playing MMORPGs you got to actually live in imaginary worlds rather than experience some single adventure in them. However, after 10 years of experience with various massive and less massive online MMORPGs for PC I have come to conclusion that most of the current MMORPGs are just too simple and limited to be addictive. One game which was unique for me in many ways is Neverwinter Nights 1, but it doesn't count as a really massive MMORPG because there are less than 100 people on each server. One reason why NWN 1 was unique is that people developed more high quality features and unique content for their servers than you could find in any commercial MMORPG. The other reason is that some people could be Dungeon Masters and they could control monsters and NPCs, arrange quests and do many other things that make the game very interesting for the players. Alas, commercial massive MMORPGs lack such features.
i have been a mom for the past 8 months and my fiance has been addicted to w.o.w for the past year...he gets right into his game...hes a completely different person when hes playing..he pays no attention to whats going on around him at all...he has lost 2 jobs because of it and he is about to loose me and his new daughter he pays absolutly no attention to us what so ever when he is playing and when hes not playing im happy but hes miserable he has admitted in the past he is addicted to it and he just recently admitted again he was addicted to it....he is depressed(it runs in the family) and he takes zoloft but it doesnt help he sees a shrink and has told her about his addiction and she only said ill see if i can find a program for ppl who are addicted to this game because she has a dozen more clients whom are addicted to w.o.w it effects his whole life and it is effecting me and his daughter terribly...i need help i dont know how much more i can take...i love him but i dont want to live liek this anymore....he doesnt spend anytime with his daughter and i am and have been raising our daughter alone...after i gave birth he left to go home and play w.o.w....how low can u possibly get.....aghhh im so frustrated will someone out there please help me....any advice will be taken to my heart just please help me.....i dont know how to cope.....thank you
Perhaps the most effective "treatment" is first to get the person somehow addicted to a few other games, maybe one game at a time. If the person shares his time between many different games, he starts to loose addiction to the game's community. He would be visiting gaming communities of different games and wouldn't get so attached to them anymore because he would feel more like a visitor among all of them. In the long run, this could help to loose addiction to all of the games involved.
Secondly, the person's interest in the so-called "grinding" process (acquiring experience points, levels, and gold, raising character's skills etc.) would become less serious. If you share your time between three or more different games, eventually you start to realise that you cannot have the best player character in either of the games because you cannot compete with the hardcore addicts who only concentrate on one game. Then you start taking each game less seriously. However, the person should probably start to realise this in a positive way. Basically, he should become convinced that he is experiencing much more of the modern computer gaming than before because he plays many different games.
All in all, this is probably one of the most realistic first-step solutions there are for really hardcore WoW addicts. It might be a good idea to turn them first from WoW addicts just to "computer game addicts" or "MMOG addicts" (MMOG = massive multiplayer online games). That should be a progress because being addicted to computer games or MMOGs in general might not be as bad as being addicted to only one specific game. Then it is just the matter of cutting down the time spent with games. It's possible that for many people the only realistic goal is to reduce the time spent on gaming to half or less of the previous amount instead of trying to completely stop playing games.
It might be one of the few possible solutions to which the most hopeless WoW addicts could commit themselves permanently. First you cure yourself from WoW by getting addicted to another MMORPG in order to diminish the value of WoW to yourself, then you find some other games and try to distribute your time among them. The more different games you play, the less you care about each of them. Hopefully, eventually you will start to get bored with all of the games and start to use more time on Internet surfing and using forums. A good solution at that point is to start using computer increasingly more for searching for information on the Internet which can help you to start coping with all of the little daily things associated with the real life.
I checked out this thread wondering why somebody would pick up another old thread on this topic, but after reading desperatenewmom's post I felt like it was something important discuss. I think Morton's suggestion is way off base. She's not dealing with somebody who just likes a game too much. I'm not going to re-hash the whole "Gaming addiction - Reality or Myth?" discussion because I've already made my opinion there clear, but I see a much more serious issue then being addicted to WoW and I hope desperatenewmom that you are reaching out for help elsewhere too. Generally in a place like this you're going to get advice like Morton's, which while well meaning is not any good to you.
It's good that your fiance admits to being addicted, recongnizes his depression and is seeking help. But if he's doing all this and still isn't getting better then maybe he's using it all as an excuse. If like you said he's taking meds but they're not working, he probably shouldn't be taking them, I'm not a doctor but the Zoloft could be contributing to worsening the problem if it's not helping. It could be that he's using all this as a crutch and really just needs a swift kick in the ass. As far as WoW goes you need to make it clear that he won't be playing it anymore. WoW has the advantage that it requires a paid subscription and isn't exactly easy to install if it's not already on your PC. If you can take over all finances to guarantee that he isn't paying for WoW at least by credit card or out of your bank account. Also force him to give you his pass word and delete all his characters. I would even go as far as telling an in game GM that you are intentionally deleting these characters and why as it may make it harder for him to get them to restore them if he tries. Then uninstall WoW and delete every WoW or Blizzard file on any computer you own and destroy the install CDs. All this won't guarantee that he won't try to play again but I've seen many a dedicated WoW players quit the game because of lack of payment, loss of characters, or having to reinstall the game and every update from the past 3+ years - doing all three to him may actually work. If you have any questions on how to go about any of these things please feel free to PM me.
Getting away from the WoW aspect of his issues here's a few things to consider. How old is he, what's his education/job status, has he been diagnosed with anything other then depression my his shrink? Also was your pregnancy/engagement unexpected? These are obviously pretty personal questions but I ask because on a very personal note I went through something somewhat similair to your situation when my girl friend got unexpectedly pregnant right after high school. It didn't involve video games (actually I think my being depressed for me made gaming so un-fun that I actually spent far less time gaming then I did before or after that period in my life) and was probably not as serious; I didn't need profesional help or meds to get over it. But maybe thats what your fiance needs to do, just get over it. I don't want to get into too many personal details in an open forum but if you want more specifac advice please feel free to ask. I just get a sense that your guys issues may be very similair to what I've been through and may be able to offer some advice.
One of the most crucial things when creating a void in someone's routine is to fill it constructively immediately. Get them involved in something where they feel needed and wanted. Ideally something that gets them away from the computer.
Purplerat made some good suggestions but I would stress the importance of involving the addict in the process. He should not only know that his characters are going to be deleted, but he should be the one to delete them. His account should not only be canceled, but he should be the one to cancel it. If you do all these things behind his back he could feel betrayed and just shut off.
Once all that is done, start a family project that requires his expertise. Something he has an interest in and is time consuming but also involves you. The big draw here is that he must feel needed, and that he will be missed and will be letting people he cares about down if he does not contribute.
Morton's suggestions are good for a minor addict. Someone who isn't losing jobs and loved ones because of their addiction but just get nothing productive done during their down time because of it. For those people transitioning to other games works wonders for the reasons he listed. For a heavy addict though, the temptation of being at the computer already is very strong. You don't need to force them to give up gaming completely, but keep them off of endless games like WOW and other MMOs.
hehe, no wonder if these wow gamers are addicted, if i had to pay so much money for a game per month, and it even counts down when you don't game , so every day is a waist of money
but what with the kids who play this game on a free rpog server? still so high?
With my suggestions I definetly intended that she do so with his knowing, if not have him do it himself. Since he admits he has a problem she should be able to get him in a moment of clarity and force him to do those things. By no means is taking the game away the answer to his problems. But it might just give him enough space to deal with whats really wrong.
| vochtige wrote : hehe, no wonder if these wow gamers are addicted, if i had to pay so much money for a game per month, and it even counts down when you don't game , so every day is a waist of money
|
Thats sounds really stupid but I agree that part of the reason people play so much is to get their value. I dont think it causes addiction but I know when I played WoW I sure wanted to get my $15 a month worth. But then again I do the same thing with my Gym membership. I have a treadmill and full weight set at home, but they're bought and paid for so I don't use them. However paying $50/month for a Gym membership makes me want to go as much as possible. While Blizzard has no real reason to do so I know that a lot of WoW players would like the option for a lifetime membership. At this point it may not be worth it (how long will WoW last beyond the next expansion before a whole new game is needed to compete with new MMORPGs) but when LOTR Online came out they offered $200 for a lifetime membership. I know a group of people who bought that and they will just once a week or so get together and play because there's no sense of needing to acheive something before your subscription runs out.
Just remember they've never found ANY expert who could clinically diagnose patients and get a success rate over 50%. In otherwords, clinical psychiatry has been debunked, and survives only on the backs of drug companies.
Thats not to say they can't help people, but their inability to diagnose a problem is proven.
The problem is the media keeps calling them "experts".
Desperatenewmom - if he acknowledges the problems and won't quit, you have to make him decide what is more important to him: family or game. If his answer is "game," do yourself a favor and leave - no good will come of staying for you or your child, or your husband for that matter. He needs a good healthy kick in the pants, and needs a reason to quit, and while you are around he won't realize what he has to lose. If he willingly lets you go to play WoW, he's probably a lost cause; sad to say, but likely true...
make him watch the south park world of warcraft episode. I dont even play wow but it made me play battlefield and sup.com. a bit less.
If hes addicted that bad then some time on his own, or knowing that theres no-one around him, will shake him out of his stupor. That or go and snap the disc. Honestly video-game addicts need a damn good shake and someone to give them a long lecture into their face from a distance of no more than 10cm.
| robwright wrote : Is video game addiction an actual medical condition? Dr. Maressa Orzack, founder of the Computer Addiction Services program at McLean Hospital in Massachusetts, says the answer is \"yes\". And she believes that up to 40 percent of the 6 million plus players of the mega-popular MMORPG World of Warcraft are clinically addicted to the game. TwitchGuru talks with one of the foremost experts in the controversial field of video game addiction. |
It's a mistake to call someone an expert just because they make something a profession. Psychology can successfully diagnose a problem with around the same rate of success as a random dice roll. They can't even agree on what addiction is, and hence they have no way to diagnose it.
Clinical psychology has been completly debunked, or at least thats what I'm learning in my psyc degree. I wonder how come their theories are still given so much weight.
| Quote : And she believes that up to 40 percent of the 6 million plus players of the mega-popular MMORPG World of Warcraft |
Corrected information above.
lol about time someone pointed that out. wow actually stand for With Out Willy
I have a degree in psychology and here is my take.
50% accuracy may sound terrible but when you consider the subject matter, that is far better than a die roll or a coin flip because it isn't a choice between two options, you have more like 10 options for some cases and it is often difficult to tell if there are multiple problems at once.
Also Psychology is a very very young science. A lot of mistakes are still being made. And a lot of psychiatrists take short cuts or string patients along.
All in all, I would advise taking anything a psychiatrist/psychologist says with a bucket of salt, but I wouldn't immediately throw it out. Also they are about the closest things we have to experts in this subject matter.
| infornography42 wrote :
|
Don't psychiatrists / existential sociologists /etc. Count people toward their statistics even if what the person has is an extremely mild form of something? That's their policy right?
I'm not sure what statistics you are referring to. If you mean clinical studies, sometimes. Depends on the researcher. Well done studies will show information like that in a graph or other chart and it will be fairly clear what they are talking about.
Less well done studies, which sadly is the majority of them, do tend to lump subjects together.
If you are looking at psychological studies it is good to keep a cynical eye open for potential confounding variables or poor methodologies.
Paranoid personality v.s. Paranoid schizophrenic
40% of WoW players show some traits that resemble addiction v.s. 40% of WoW players convulse and act violent when confronted, foam at the mouth. It's still considered 'addicted' regardless of how severe.
The DSMIV description of gambling addiction is something along these lines.
Pathological gambling is now defined as persistent and recurrent maladaptive gambling behavior meeting at least five of the following criteria, as long as these behaviors are not better explained by a manic episode:
1. Preoccupation. The subject has frequent thoughts about gambling experiences, whether past, future, or fantasy.
2. Tolerance. As with drug tolerance, the subject requires larger or more frequent wagers to experience the same "rush".
3. Withdrawal. Restlessness or irritability associated with attempts to cease or reduce gambling.
4. Escape. The subject gambles to improve mood or escape problems.
5. Chasing. The subject tries to win back gambling losses with more gambling.
6. Lying. The subject tries to hide the extent of his or her gambling by lying to family, friends, or therapists.
7. Stealing. in order to seed their gambling addiction
8. Loss of control. The person has unsuccessfully attempted to reduce gambling.
9. Illegal acts. The person has broken the law in order to obtain gambling money or recover gambling losses. This may include acts of theft, embezzlement, fraud, forgery, or bad checks.
10. Risked significant relationship. The person gambles despite risking or losing a relationship, job, or other significant opportunity.
11. Bailout. The person turns to family, friends, or another third party for financial assistance as a result of gambling.
As with many disorders, the DSM-IV definition of pathological gambling is widely accepted and used as a basis for research and clinical practice internationally.
Of those 5, 7, and 9 don't carry over perfectly to MMO addictions since the financial investment is minimal, but the rest do. I would probably replace them with things like the following.
X. Replacement. Attempts to replace lost friends and family with online friends.
Y. Obsession. No longer has any other apparent hobbies or interests outside the game.
Z. Prioritization. Forgoes basic necessities of life such as work, eating, and sleeping for prolonged periods of time in favor of the game.
Of those, I could not claim to have had any more than 3 at any given point. I know at least one person who had 4. That does not qualify as an addiction. I had one friend ever who had 5 and he was in bad BAD shape at the time. His girlfriend had to force feed him in order to get him to eat. Fortunately he quit on his own after about 6 months.
I think I can say with confidence that if anyone exhibits 5 of those symptoms, intervention is warranted.
To answer your question. Yes all addicts are lumped together, but it does take an extraordinary level of dependence to be considered an addict so such lumping is fair.
Addendum... I would probably remove number 4 as a criteria as well. Escape is after all the point of playing an MMO.
Thanks for being so thorough.
I am chronicling 30 days and 30 nights without video games and dissecting the motivational elements that make MMORPG's so addictive in a day-by-day blog.
I invite all of you who are interested in the subject to check it out, [url=http://www.rlding.com][/url].
I hope to help other men and women like myself transfer the motivation of MMO's into their real lives.
Brian.
Heya,
I hit level 60 with my paladin. I started with the battlechest that has the original WoW + Burning Crusade. I played for about two months. I prepaid for 3 (4 if you count my free month for buying the box). I found myself having to give up other activities just to keep up with the people I was playing with, and playing alone in that game is one of the most stupid things ever (go play minesweeper, it's about as exciting).
So I canceled my account.
Uninstalled it.
Addicted? I felt the pull. But fortunately, the game is actually really bad, so I didn't get harmed by becoming a WoW junkie.
Very best,
Holy necrothread Batman!
It almost went a year before being resurrected this time.
my mother and aunt are completely addicted to wow. my aunt is the most addicted of the two. she dosnt eat properly and is skinny as a skeleton. all she does is play wow and only stops to work her part time job at walmart that provides just enough money she can play to no end, she neglects her child (who is thankfully old enough to support her self now) i try to call her and she cant even talk a phone call because she always has to fight something in the game. the only person she takes calls from is my mother when they are raiding something together.
my mother plays every second of free time she gets but at least she works a full time job and makes descent money. my brother came to visit (who we haven't seen in years) with his kids and she couldn't even turn off the game, she just sat playing wow. she doesn't go any where and do anything else with her time but play. she takes 4 and 5 day weekends sometimes and plays 18 hours a day, every day, of every weekend, non stop. and if she stays up too late playing wow and doesn't get enough sleep, she calls in sick, and guess what... she spends that day playing too. i know its not just the games fault other than not having an ending, there are plenty of people who play in moderation. i just wish i knew how to pull them away from it before either of them end up in the hospital or alienating them selves from the family.
There are 1233 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.
