Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads

Apple is 'Lawyering Up' as Most Sued Company

by - source: Tom's Hardware US

Lots of companies are gunning for Apple.

Apple gets a lot of attention in today's world. While the company is churning out products that the mainstream public enjoy devouring, Apple is also getting the attention of lawyers.

According to BusinessWeek, since 2008, a year after the launch of the first iPhone that arguably kick-started Apple's climb, the Cupertino company has faced more lawsuits than any other tech company in the industry.

Because of that, Apple management is now 'lawyering up' by adding those who have fought and won against companies such as Microsoft, Intel and Broadcom.

Apple this year added an in-house attorney, Noreen Krall, for the purpose of tending to intellectual property litigation. She had previously worked with Sun Microsystems and IBM.

In addition to the in-house help, Apple has also called the help of outside counsel, which even include a lawyer that negotiated a settlement where Apple had to pay $100 million to Creative Technology.

Apple is currently involved in patent battles against HTC, Nokia and Motorola, which center around the mobile technology space.

Share:
28
Comments
X
Submit

Comments
Add your comment
webbwbb 12/01/2010 4:57 PM
Hide
-20+

Well of course they are the most sued company in the industry. When you have utter disregard for the intellectual property of others and make billions for it you tend to get sued.

rantoc 12/01/2010 5:00 PM
Hide
-20+

What is the surprise here ? If they start patent "wars" they have to endure it the other way around - Especially with their tendency to brag about "their" inventions that other really creative companies have already invented years ago...

bustapr 12/01/2010 5:00 PM
Hide
-4+

I can investigate patents better than the team at Apple, if theres any...

WR2 12/01/2010 5:02 PM
Hide
--1+

A bit of a surprise to me given Apple's perceived image and self promotion efforts.
Not exactly the kind of press coverage Apple would hope to see.

Parrdacc 12/01/2010 5:03 PM
Hide
--1+

I do not know if this is news or comes as a shock to anyone. I mean whoever is at the top is always going to be a target for lawsuits whether they are legit or not. In turn those at the top will sue as well. Just a typical cycle that goes on.

COLGeek 12/01/2010 5:04 PM
Hide
-13+

I am "so" shocked that anyone would want to do mean things (like sue) to Apple. I mean, heck, they are the bastions of virtue in the computing world....

I really need to figure out how to type sarcastically........

Albyint 12/01/2010 5:34 PM
Hide
-3+

Apple is gearing up for a renewed front on the destructive patent wars. Yay more law-suites, less open source and more lunacy from mad man Jobs.

If i remember correctly, and im sure someone will tell me if i dont, didnt they start this "patent war" and now it seems they are having trouble.

fullcircle_bflo 12/01/2010 5:47 PM
Show
hemelskonijn 12/01/2010 6:16 PM
Hide
--1+

Without any digits to support these claims its utter useless. In example i would like to know how many cases get settled outside of court for Apple and for instance Microsoft and some other big names. Chances are that Apple just doesn't settle and thus indeed ends up in court way more often. Whatever the supporting data suggest i don't really care but its amazing that claims like these are suggested to be relevant to anything.

Anomalyx 12/01/2010 6:30 PM
Hide
--2+

fullcircle_bflo :
Search the internet for "sarcasm mark" or sarcmarc.


I'm pretty sure it's copyrighted - you have to actually buy rights to use it.
(I'm actually serious about that one)

deletemach_kernel 12/01/2010 6:30 PM
Hide
-0+

Id sue them....after i pass my law exams ;)

deletemach_kernel 12/01/2010 6:35 PM
Hide
--1+

bustapr wrote :

I can investigate patents better than the team at Apple, if theres any...





Please dont investigate the Darth Vader way :D

orionantares 12/01/2010 7:34 PM
Hide
-2+

I believe the iPod kick started them.

The iPhone just road the wave.

SoiledBottom 12/01/2010 8:00 PM
Hide
-1+

Sounds like a bunch lies to me...if I were Steve Jobs I'd sue someone over this article

HavoCnMe 12/01/2010 8:51 PM
Hide
-2+

Is Steve implying that he has balls of that magnitude?

xythrax4420 12/01/2010 9:34 PM
Hide
-5+

apple invented the lawsuit

WarraWarra 12/01/2010 9:57 PM
Hide
--2+

Well if Apple actually gives a damn about their products like tehy PowerBook G4 / bondi Blue / Cube used too they would ahve less issues.

If they payed royalty as in reasonable % per product they would still be able to make their 1300% profits on each items sold and rip-off it's customers then there would be less or almost no issues.

Also if Apple actually did the math they would see it is easier to replace or even give away a replacement items for a defective on as much cheaper and so would have better customer relations instead of the "non existing customer relations currently" + they would not have to fake their stock prices or cook the tax books as much.

FOR:
So why does Apple and all other enemy's of Steve jobs not just agree to disagree and develop opensource standards that is then accepted by all as legally imune while still ripping of customers and making money with the end products.

This would stop a whole lot of USA attorneys stealing from it's clients to keep a law suite running against the best interests of their clients and stop all or most of the corporate JUDGE bribing that we are so used to in the USA.

Half of these clowns posing as lawyers have never even completed high school or was able to read a book so how can they defend anyone if they could stumble onto the legal system that does NOT exists in the USA.

Just look at Obama and his circus doing anything to be in the news or to aggravate his employers the USA citizens, after all he is just another gov employee same as a street sweeper or the rubbish man.

bill gates is your daddy 12/01/2010 10:05 PM
Hide
-2+

HavoCnMe :
Is Steve implying that he has balls of that magnitude?



IT'S A TRAP!!!

Yoder54 12/01/2010 10:24 PM
Hide
-2+

WarraWarra :
Well if Apple actually gives a damn about their products like tehy PowerBook G4 / bondi Blue / Cube used too they would ahve less issues....Also if Apple actually did the math they would see it is easier to replace or even give away a replacement items for a defective on as much cheaper and so would have better customer relations instead of the "non existing customer relations currently" + they would not have to fake their stock prices or cook the tax books as much....Half of these clowns posing as lawyers have never even completed high school or was able to read a book so how can they defend anyone if they could stumble onto the legal system that does NOT exists in the USA....Just look at Obama and his circus doing anything to be in the news or to aggravate his employers the USA citizens, after all he is just another gov employee same as a street sweeper or the rubbish man.



Are you a moron or something? You would be well served to do some fact finding.

Regarding all of the litigation going on with the tech companies now...it is insane. In fact, Microsoft is involved in a very important case that is being followed by all of the tech companies. The problem is that it is too easy to sue over patents...and that is what most of Apple's cases are about...and MS is fighting to bring about much needed change. The laws must change with the technology.

Like I said, most of the suits against Apple are patent related and so your replacement argument is without merit. And, like it or not, Apple rated the highest in customer satisfaction this year. The article is in PCWorld.

Sure, you can practice law without a HS diploma. See it in every court room. Yikes. The lawyers are merely the puppets of their corporate semployers. Hell, it is easy to try and get a few million off of vaguely interpreted patent laws.

Judges are bribed by corporations? Some pretty serious accusations there. Can you prove what you say or are you just hot-headed?

It is not Obama who is running the circus. It is the Republican party who is fixated on giving millionaires tax cuts, cutting unemployment benefits, and not signing the SMART treaty. You seem confused. You really should catch up on your current events. Also, by definition, the President of the US is our elected leader, and a trash collector is a hired public servant...big difference...let me guess, you never took US Government in HS.

eddieroolz 12/01/2010 11:26 PM
Hide
-0+

Hey, they brought the HTC lawsuit upon themselves and I have good reason to believe that Nokia has a plausible argument in the suit as well.

So in the end, Apple brought this unto themselves by being overly arrogant.

Von Death 12/02/2010 12:12 PM
Hide
-0+

Yoder54 :
Apple rated the highest in customer satisfaction this year.



We can't repel ratings of that magnitude!

The 8.25 million people who are stupid enough to buy ipads would also be stupid enough to give Apple good ratings.

To break down the ratings system: Would you rather be complimented by 10,000 school children or once by Steven Hawking?

xerroz 12/02/2010 1:12 AM
Hide
--1+

von death :
We can't repel ratings of that magnitude!The 8.25 million people who are stupid enough to buy ipads would also be stupid enough to give Apple good ratings. To break down the ratings system: Would you rather be complimented by 10,000 school children or once by Steven Hawking?


One Steven Hawking of course

hemelskonijn 12/02/2010 1:19 AM
Hide
-1+

von death :
We can't repel ratings of that magnitude!The 8.25 million people who are stupid enough to buy ipads would also be stupid enough to give Apple good ratings. To break down the ratings system: Would you rather be complimented by 10,000 school children or once by Steven Hawking?



Interesting point you make there but i hope you realize that it goes both ways?

dEAne 12/02/2010 3:05 AM
Hide
-0+

It's quiet real that if you disregard the intellectual property of others their lawyers will sued you, lots of money for them, misery for you.

Yoder54 12/02/2010 3:36 AM
Hide
--1+

von death :
We can't repel ratings of that magnitude!The 8.25 million people who are stupid enough to buy ipads would also be stupid enough to give Apple good ratings.



The problem with your statement is that it is directed towards iPad purchases, while the researched was directed towards all Apple products. Consumer Reports also puts Apple on top when it comes to customer satisfaction, quality, and expectations.

So who is the Stephen Hawking of computers? Your premise is without validation.

There is one thing that anyone who purchases an Apple product can be assured of is leading edge design, and high-quality. Apple represents the best of American ingenuity and design, and why American's would be so opposed to see an American firm kicking the ass of various foreign firms is beyond me. This rabid hate of Windows or Apple is merely a sign of immaturity. Both companies have their flaws, but what American firm doesn't. Compare MS or Apple to the health insurance industry and they will come out looking like angles. The beauty of our marketplace is that it is the consumer who gets to decide what to buy. To choose the Mac OS over Windows does not mean that one is stupid. There are many PhD's in academia who use Mac's and have been for years and they are anything but stupid.

Hell, toast the success of Apple and be happy that they employ a lot of American engineers and do not out source their designers to India or China.

cdirtydevil 12/02/2010 4:34 AM
Hide
-0+

So he's showing us in the pic instead of going under the competition he goes over or is he playing the new apple icharades

Ads

Best offers

Newsletters


OK
Ads