Ads
Ads
All about Power Supplies
 Latest Power Supplies articles
Small Business Battery Backup: Eaton's 3,000VA PW5130

Small Business Battery Backup: Eaton's 3,000VA PW5130
Uninterruptible power supplies (what most people call battery backup) are essential for protecting servers and bridging power outages. We looked at a high-end solution from Eaton, which offers impressive flexibility in a small business environment. Read More

  • Power Supply Roundup: Part II
    In Part I of our power supply roundup, we went through five mainstream PSUs rated at up to 700 W. Round two sees us tackle another seven mid-range units in an effort to determine which power supply deserves your attention. Read More
All Power Supplies articles

Newsletters


  • Ask your question about IT issues
  • Post

Partners

The Games selection

crazy : Interactive Boogy Pick one of the 3 songs, hit on the correct keys matching this boy's dance moves.
crazy : Xiao Xiao 7 A great fight scene from the animation movies Xiao Xiao.
Ads

Sponsored links

Apple Sued Over MagSafe MacBook Adapters

Next news
1:00 PM - May 6, 2009 by Jane McEntegart

Apple is at the center of another class action lawsuit regarding the MagSafe connectors on its laptop adapters.

The MagSafe, long hailed for its design which helps prevent accidents when users trip over or catch the cable on something, is being targeted by users who complain Apple has been negligent when it comes to adapter design.

Ars Technica today reports that a complaint filed last Friday in California Northern District Court's San Jose office alleges that the MagSafe power adapter is prone to frayed wires and overheating, and as a result represents a fire hazard.

The complaint apparently accuses Apple of being negligent in the design of the power adapter, claims violations of various consumer warranty laws and alleges that Apple "has not taken action to remedy the defects." That said, it also notes in brackets that they’re not quite sure if that last part is true. Seems like a pretty important fact you’d want to check out, but who are we to tell them what boxes to tick before filing a legal complaint?

Ars points out that Apple acknowledged a problem with strain relief near the MagSafe connector last year and said that users "may be eligible for a replacement adapter free of charge provided there are no signs of accidental damage" even if the adapter is out of warranty.

Source : Tom's Hardware US

Talkback
Add your comment
tenor77 05/06/2009 7:26 PM
Hide
-20+

In related news several posts mysteriously disappear from Apples forums.

MustWarnOthers 05/06/2009 7:45 PM
Show
nekatreven 05/06/2009 8:03 PM
Hide
-13+

Apple: "But our power adapters are so pretty and, they have magnets! Who cares if they catch you on fire?! ...Steve wouldn't care!"

IzzyCraft 05/06/2009 8:07 PM
Hide
-0+

Aww and that's one of the few things i liked on mac laptops figures apple...

hellwig 05/06/2009 8:11 PM
Hide
-9+

MustWarnOthers :
Hi,I'm a sleazebag/sleazebag company looking for a chunk of wealth for no other reason than that I know the average dumbass jury will hand it over.Though this raises insurance rates and limits growth, I believe I should be entitled to that which I have not earned.


While I agree frivalous lawsuits are the new gold rush for the lazy and morally reprehensible, I also know Apple is horrible with its product quality.

How many screens have they thrown at customers with serious display issues? How many batteries have they sealed in their products that barely make it past the 1-year warranty (and thus require expensive work to replace)? Apple may be known for its software quality and hardware style, but as far as hardware quality goes, they are pretty sub-par. No doubt there may be some legitamacy to this lawsuit afterall. Sadly though, any money that is collected will go straight into the greedy lawfirms pockets.

maigo 05/06/2009 8:30 PM
Hide
-3+

Oh wow, and here I was expecting a new patent infringement suit

dtemple 05/06/2009 9:03 PM
Show
B-Unit 05/06/2009 9:27 PM
Hide
-0+

But it just works, right?

CChick 05/06/2009 9:35 PM
Hide
-8+

Software Quality ? WHAT Software quality ?

garbage OS? Cant even code its own kernel ? Piece of $hit security and lie to everybody ?

dman3k 05/06/2009 9:41 PM
Hide
-0+

Apple says that they want their customer to buy brand new laptops or handhelds before any of the problems ever happen.

Hey, look, I'm a Mac, and I'm slick and cool! You must upgrade and buy me now!

cruiseoveride 05/06/2009 10:07 PM
Hide
--1+

In real life Mac would be a quadriplegic, unable to do anything "normal" PCs can do.

neiroatopelcc 05/06/2009 10:18 PM
Hide
-1+

This is actually a bit amusing! The ONLY thing I like about apple is that connector. And now it turns out that the only thing they did right is wrong .... lol

doomhammr 05/06/2009 10:20 PM
Hide
-5+

tenor77 :
In related news several posts mysteriously disappear from Apples forums.



Apple loves sweeping their mistakes under the rug.

the_one111 05/06/2009 10:51 PM
Hide
-1+

doomhammr :
Apple loves sweeping their mistakes under the rug.


What else can you do when your the worst corporation in your market?

hellwig 05/06/2009 11:17 PM
Show
deltatux 05/06/2009 11:19 PM
Hide
--1+

this issue was resolved last year, so why the lawsuit, makes no sense to me. My MagSafe is fine here.

scryer_360 05/07/2009 12:17 PM
Hide
-0+

So they are suing the best adapter in the industry for something they aren't quite sure about?

Only in America.

geoffs 05/07/2009 12:50 PM
Hide
-1+

I've seen power cord fraying problems on laptop AC adapters from Dell, HP/CPQ, Apple, IBM/Lenovo, Toshiba, and Sony, and those are the ones I can think of off the top of my head. I've also seen it on AC adapters for Wi-Fi routers, modems (phone, DSL, and cable), ink-jet printers, routers/firewalls, cell-phones, etc. from dozens of manufacturers. This is an industry-wide issue, not anything specific to Apple, and I can't say it's significantly more likely on any one brand.

In 15 years of owing Mac laptops none of my Apple AC adapters have ever frayed or failed. One was recalled and replaced due to a potential fire hazard (not fraying related). MagSafe is the best laptop power connection yet put on the market, but like virtually every other adapter for portable devices, the thin DC cord is subject to fraying if you routinely stress it.

tipoo 05/07/2009 1:31 AM
Hide
-0+

I wish there was some magsafe-like adapter for windows laptops, minus the fire thing.

systemshock869 05/07/2009 5:39 AM
Hide
-1+

You people really think this is a viable lawsuit? I'm no Mac guy by the way, but this sounds like some money grubbing scumbags trying to get a few bucks from Apple. First, they don't even know if what they are accusing Apple of is true, and secondly, Apple has offered to give out free replacements! Come on people..

croc 05/07/2009 7:59 AM
Hide
-2+

"In 15 years of owing Mac"...

Truer words were never spoken....

tayb 05/07/2009 8:10 AM
Hide
-1+

I can attest to this not only on the Magsafe power adapter but the iPhone power charged/sync cable. Right where it plugs into the computer/USB the gray lining starts to pull back and there are exposed protective wiring over the cabling. That can eventually fray and I guess potentially cause a fire.

The minute I saw this happening, however, I took the power adapter to an Apple Store and had them give me another one. I'm not waiting for my house to burn down or my pants to catch fire so that I can make a few bucks suing a good company.

Shadow703793 05/07/2009 2:31 PM
Hide
-0+

Oh the irony! Wasn't Apple hailed as "better quality" than PCs by Consumer Reports (see: http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=15062 ) and Mac users?

Shadow703793 05/07/2009 2:34 PM
Hide
--1+

CChick :
Software Quality ? WHAT Software quality ?garbage OS? Cant even code its own kernel ? Piece of $hit security and lie to everybody ?


If Liunx kernel grunts (the guys who dwell there) could sue Apple they should.(Alas open source/GPL lets Apple do this legally. I find it funny most people don't know OSX IS based on BSD/Linux.

Anonymous 05/07/2009 3:51 PM
Hide
-1+

my magsafe burned my computer twice. I visited the apple store and the "genius" not really... said it was due to lint getting between the charger and computer.. BS. I called apple care told them what happened, and that my computer is indeed a fire hazard and they replaced the parts necessary..

Fadamor 05/07/2009 4:08 PM
Hide
-1+

As a former Geek Squad employee, I've seen my share of frayed power cords for laptops. While I'm no fan of Apple I can say the majority of frays were due to negligence on the part of the owner (dropping the laptop, yanking the cord out by the cable, or running it over with the vaccuum), which is exactly what the MagSafe connector was designed to address. Seems like they didn't provide enough strain relief, however. They were so concerned with making everything lightweight that they went with power cabling that was TOO light and too easy to break when the MagSafe feature was actually needed. Poor lifecycle testing.

geoffs 05/07/2009 8:18 PM
Hide
-1+

Shadow703793 :
If Liunx kernel grunts (the guys who dwell there) could sue Apple they should.(Alas open source/GPL lets Apple do this legally. I find it funny most people don't know OSX IS based on BSD/Linux.

I find it funny that people don't know that it's actually based on a Mach microkernel, with BSD compatibility, not upon Linux.

kamkal 05/07/2009 8:56 PM
Hide
-0+

dtemple :
Thanks for the interesting article Jane! Personally I find all power adapters have wiring prone to fraying. I've seen dozens of power adapters with the wiring right after the plug being worn... just from normal use. Seems people are just sue-happy to get the money Apple has... hehe.



I have a Toshiba laptop that came with a LITEON adapter. Adapter is in fine condition. Laptop is 4 years old.

Good try though!

kamkal 05/07/2009 8:59 PM
Hide
-1+

Shadow703793 :
If Liunx kernel grunts (the guys who dwell there) could sue Apple they should.(Alas open source/GPL lets Apple do this legally. I find it funny most people don't know OSX IS based on BSD/Linux.



It is based on UNIX, not Linux.
Linux is a clone of UNIX as well, with BSD being UNIX.

kamkal 05/07/2009 9:17 PM
Hide
-0+

kevkole :
my magsafe burned my computer twice. I visited the apple store and the "genius" not really... said it was due to lint getting between the charger and computer.. BS. I called apple care told them what happened, and that my computer is indeed a fire hazard and they replaced the parts necessary..



HAHA mac "geniuses" are so funny. I worked apple tech support phone lines, maybe I spoke to you lol.

You could always count on the "geniuses" to create a problem that you had to mop up over the phone.

Here's a good one:
Women takes her macbook to the store, the fans are on constantly after startup.
Mac moron tells her it is the BATTERY, gives her a new battery. (???)
Women leaves store, gets home, turns on laptop, after 2 mins, fan are at full.
She calls in, I speak to her.
Bring up Activity Monitor, a process is stuck at 100% CPU usage.
Force quit the process, fans slow down and then turn on and off normally.
I advise her never to go back to an apple store.

Here's another one:
Mac moron selling a copy of Leopard (10.5) to a lady whose mac is like a G3 with 256MB ram. They sold her this cuz her mac had 10.3 (Panther i believe) and 10.3 wouldnt run the newest iTunes and she had just bought an ipod touch that needed the newest version of iTunes to work..

So the g3 laptop would not even BOOT UP the installer cuz it cant handle 10.5. No error message, nothing, just sits there on a blank screen accessing the dvd lol..gotta love the so called 'software quality' from apple...

Had to send the lady 10.4 (Tiger, which would run the newest itunes) to rectify the issue (and I had to speak to several different dummies in 'tier 2 tech support' before they would 'authorize' sending out the disks even though apple is the one that screwed up)..

And it isnt just one store, happens at a lot of them from across the US.

maybe all you mactards should think about that before talking about quality...

Comments are closed on this page.

Sponsored links

Related articles

  • Apple MacBook Review: Part 2

    Yesterday, Alan Dang gave us his impressions and experiences with the hardware in Apple's MacBook. Today it's all about the software, plus performance numbers comparing a real Mac to a "Hacked Mac on a Mac."

  • Apple MacBook Review: Part 1

    Long-time PC power user turned Apple convert Alan Dang shares his thoughts on Apple's MacBook in this, the first of a two-part review of the hardware and operating environment.

  • Lenovo's X300 vs. Apple's MacBook Air

    When Apple launched its MacBook Air, it was rumored that Lenovo would follow up with a 13" ultra-portable laptop. Lenovo did just that in February when it launched its X300. We focus on the X300, but include comparisons with the MacBook Air.