Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in


Sound Proof Your Hard Drive

Although hard drive noise has not been a significant issue in recent years, thanks to noticeable improvements and optimization in the acoustics area, both products we looked at in this review manage to do a great job of reducing hard drive idle noise and especially random access noise. The 3RSystem L-1100 T.REX case and the GUP Smart Drive Neo HDD silencer reduce activity noise to levels that are close to drive idle levels. At the same time, there’s no need for concerns about cooling and drive temperature, as both products are suitable for running high-performance 10,000 RPM drives.

The Korean company 3RSystem provided the L-1100 T.REX case, which is a quality mid-tower case for the PC mainstream. It is equipped with sound-deadening mats on all interior surfaces, and a spring-assisted mounting on the hard drive cage. Both measures ensure a noticeable difference in hard drive noise. Two 120 mm fans make sure the drives don’t overheat.

However, the Smart Drive Neo HDD silencer by the Japanese company GUP did an even better job in eliminating noise, and in cooling the WD740 drive we used for this review. Frankly, we did not expect such a convincing result, as the drive is literally locked into the enclosure, preventing any air exchange. However, the spring-buffered metal bridges on which you place the hard drive not only decouple the drive from the Smart Drive enclosure, they also ensure a firm contact between the drive and the top cover, which serves as a heat sink. (Ed.: it's worth noting that we were only able to find the Smart Drive Neo on one e-tailer's page, selling for an astounding $80. Hope you really love your quiet computing!)

Regular users who simply want to make sure their system makes only as much noise as necessary should definitely look for computer cases that include spring mounts or similar mechanisms to avoid hard drive vibration being transferred to the case. Sound proofing mats like the ones we found inside the L-1100 T.REX case provide additional value.

The silencer is mostly interesting for sensitive users, or for those who insist on minimizing noise for various applications. A no-noise HTPC may not be fast enough, but using the Smart Drive Neo will get you rather close to no noise if paired with a case that is as effective in reducing noise as is the L-1100.

Ask a Category Expert

Create a new thread in the Reviews comments forum about this subject

Example: Notebook, Android, SSD hard drive

Display all 27 comments.
This thread is closed for comments
  • 3 Hide
    geevade , May 19, 2009 6:33 AM
    am I missing something?
    L = 10(lg P2/P1) dB

    ie 3dB more is double, and 10dB more is 10 times more the intensity/Power.
  • 3 Hide
    Anonymous , May 19, 2009 7:07 AM
    +3db doubles the sound intensity. +10db doubles the perceived volume.
  • 1 Hide
    Anonymous , May 19, 2009 9:24 AM
    geevade is correct. By definition, the decibel scale is such that +10dB is x10 times the quantity (sound intensity in this case), not x2 like Tom's says.

    I'm not sure where you (abc) got the idea that +10dB is twice the perceived volume. If it can be quantified at all, perceived volume is considered logarithmic in intensity, and since the intensity scale is calibrated to have the hearing threshold at 0dB, it is should be exactly proportional to the dB rating. So actually x2 the dB would be x2 the perceived volume.

    I stopped reading this article when I realized the writers don't understand noise at all and couldn't even bother to check their facts.
  • 1 Hide
    avatar_raq , May 19, 2009 10:50 AM
    Good article. Few notes:
    1. If the springs in the GUP solution made the upper surface of the HDD pess firmly against the upper (Al) plate of the cage, doesn't that mean the vibration is transmitted to that plate as well, negating the dampening effect of the springs? How could it pull such good results?! Can the author comment on that please.
    2. I think the comparison would be more realistic if -instead of throwing it on a styrofoam on a workbench- the raptor's noise was measured in a cheap B-brand case , with the GUP cage inside that cheap case, and then with the HDD in the Trex case. The results would be simimlar to the real experience of the user. The chassis could have amplified the vibration, on the other hand the closed case could dampen the noise, who knows what the end result would be?
    3. It would have been nice to compare both products to some popular cases that sport a plastic or rubber tool-less mounting for the HDDs claimed to reduce the niose e.g CM Storm Sniper or HAF 932..The latter case sells for appriximately the same price of the GUP cage (case = HDD cage!), so comparing them would have given true impression about their value.
    4. Have the author considered recording the noise with a sensitive mic to let us hear the noise and decide for ourselves how niosy 40 dBl is..This is just a suggestion..
  • -2 Hide
    Anonymous , May 19, 2009 11:52 AM
    For sound pressure, the formula is L=20(log P2/P1) dB... in other words, +6 dB doubles it and +20 dB is 10 x intensity.
  • 1 Hide
    chjade84 , May 19, 2009 1:03 PM
    Alright Holy-Fire you are wrong, kinda. +10dB is 10x the intensity. However, You are wrong about the perceived volume. Tom's (and ABC) has it right, at least for the purposes of hard drive silencing.

    "Another consideration which prompts the use of powers of 10 for sound measurement is the rule of thumb for loudness: it takes about 10 times the intensity to sound twice as loud." ()

    That is what this article is about. Perceived loudness. Who cares what the intensity actually is. Quit nit-picking and read the article for what it is worth. A +10dB increase means a particular sound will seem twice as loud.

    Don't let 'em get ya down Tom's!

  • 1 Hide
    chjade84 , May 19, 2009 1:04 PM
    Ok, they took out my link to that quote...
  • 0 Hide
    dan in saint louis , May 19, 2009 1:36 PM
    chjade is correct. While +10dB represents 10 times the sound power, it is perceived by humans as being twice as loud. +3dB of noise is barely detectable by humans.
  • 0 Hide
    geevade , May 19, 2009 2:14 PM
    how about using sone, if talking about perceived loudness. dB is about the magnitude relative to a reference level. Perceived loudness also depends on the frequency of the noise (and age ;)  e.g. we're the most sensitive at about 2kHz.
  • 0 Hide
    chjade84 , May 19, 2009 2:25 PM
    Because, the sone is not an SI unit, not widely used, many people don't understand it or know what it is, but most importantly... doesn't matter.

    This is not a technical white paper addressing the worldwide consortium of hard drive manufacturing acoustical engineers (WCHDMAE, LOL). This all is irrelevant. All people need to know is that this particular method makes your hard drive seem about half or about a third as loud.

    Stop thinking so much!
  • 0 Hide
    pschmid , May 19, 2009 2:36 PM
    Thanks for the feedback!


    1) The aluminum plate comes with a heat conducting surface coating, which prevents vibration to transmit to the cover.

    2) Our approach of running the old Raptor on styro pads reflects the lowest possible noise. I agree, using a case would probably be more realistic.

    3) I am not sure when we'll do something similar again, but we'll look around some more once that is the case.

    4) Not considered, sorry. Since we can't spend unlimited time on this type of product reviews it will be hard to do it all.
  • 0 Hide
    pschmid , May 19, 2009 2:47 PM
    Correction: There is no head conductive coating, but a few pads that you install in between the drive and the aluminum cover.
  • 0 Hide
    TidalWaveOne , May 19, 2009 3:00 PM
    Get an SSD drive if you want quiet/silence or speed. Old Raptors were noisy, VelociRaptors are fairly quiet by comparison.
  • 1 Hide
    Anonymous , May 19, 2009 4:02 PM
    "meaning that 40 dB is double the sound pressure of 30 dB, 50 dB is twice as much as 40 dB, and so on".
    To those who talking about loudness, read the quotation above once more. Do you find any trace of loudness being mensioned? I don't. Thus the author doesn't know what he is talking about. And it doesn't matter if the article is for general audience or for engineers. Such mistakes shall not appear at all. Obviously author either does not know what dB is or the difference between the sound pressure and loudness.
  • 0 Hide
    avatar_raq , May 19, 2009 5:15 PM
    Thanks Pschmid. Appreciated.
  • 0 Hide
    cjl , May 19, 2009 10:13 PM
    TidalWaveOneGet an SSD drive if you want quiet/silence or speed. Old Raptors were noisy, VelociRaptors are fairly quiet by comparison.

    This is definitely the case - I have a pair of velociraptors, and I can't hear them unless I put my ear right next to the case.
  • 0 Hide
    man-inj-74 , May 20, 2009 2:11 AM
    I have two GUP Smart Drive 2002C's in use (a better model but same concept). They are brilliant! Hard drive noise is not an issue if your other components are loud... but if you're a silence loving man and your other components are silenced then Hard drive sound proofing is the next step. I have both GPU and CPU on water cooling, use an Enermax quiet PSU and an SSD as my boot OS. The GUP'S are used for a 1.5TB Seagate and 300GB Velociraptor. The only drawback I see is using the 5.25 Inch Drive bay for a 3.5Inch drive.... but they run cooler quieter so its worth it. PC weighs a lot more though... these things are heavy.
  • 0 Hide
    NoCalDrummer , May 20, 2009 5:14 AM
    The dB scale is a measurement of relative POWER, based on the exponent of ten. One sound that delivers twice [2 times] the power of another would be 10 x log(2) = 3.0dB louder. A sound that is quintuple [5 times] the power of another is 10 x log(5) = 7.0dB louder.
    The "37dB" figures shown in the article are relative to the amount of acoustic power required for a human to hear ANYTHING, which is "0dB". That's assuming an environment free of any extraneous noise such as refrigerators, street noise, air systems in homes, wind noise, etc. In other words, you'd probably have to find a dry cave in the middle of nowhere to get near that sort of audio level. Otherwise, you're lucky if it's in the low 30's.
    The maximum power that the ear can handle without real pain is 120dB, or ten to the 12th power higher (1,000,000,000,000). As once was explained to me, it's the difference between two fleas making love and two elephants in the same act.
    But there's a real difference between "acoustic power" and perceived "loudness". It's related to the frequencies involved as well as the actual power, with the highest and lowest frequencies seeming to fall faster as actual acoustic power is reduced. Not surprisingly, we're more sensitive to the frequencies in the middle of the audio spectrum, so a squeal at about 1,000Hz is going to be more annoying than an equally powerful noise at 20 Hz or one at 15kHz. The latter was often produced rather strongly from old CRT televisions, but seldom noticed by the general public.
    Most acoustic measuring devices come with filters to simulate the sensitivity of the human ear to various frequencies, and I'm sure that these were used for the measurements in Tom's article.

    On a related note (no pun intended) a little insulation foam strips strategically located in a computer case can do wonders to reduce the internal noise from becoming external noise. The large-area case sides can radiate noise like a large loudspeaker, so a thin layer of silicone on these slabs of steel, aluminum, or plastic can deaden the acoustic properties of the cases without adversely affecting the cooling of the system. And a lower-power CPU can also mean a slower, quieter fan to keep it cool. Just a thought.
  • 0 Hide
    geevade , May 20, 2009 6:14 AM
    chjade84Because, the sone is not an SI unit, not widely used, many people don't understand it or know what it is, but most doesn't matter. .... !

    I agree, it's not that important, but I guess expect TH-articles to get the facts right, especially since the article explains dB.

    The decibel isn't SI either btw.
  • 0 Hide
    drealar , May 20, 2009 10:11 AM
    Hey Patrick,
    I'm wondering what kind of sound deadening material they use in the 3RSystem? More like how does the texture feels like. Lol might sound like a stupid question.

    It's just that most of the sound proof materials that I've worked with (for other projects, not building PC) easily absorb heat, but dissipate it slower. So is there any sign of hotter or faster heat build up during your test with the 3RSystem case? My average room temp. is 27c, up to 30c when my PC is on, on to 35c during hot days
Display more comments