Tom's Hardware > All Reviews > Components > Graphics Cards > Professional Affair: OpenGL Graphics Cards Compete

Professional Affair: OpenGL Graphics Cards Compete

1:03 PM - May 15, 2000 by Uwe Scheffel

1. Introduction
2. Driver Direction For OpenGL Cards
3. 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX1
4. 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX1 - DFP- And Stereo Connectors
5. 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX1 - Display Characteristics
6. 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX1 - PowerThreads
7. 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX210
8. 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX210 - Display Characteristics
9. 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX210 - Dual-Monitor-Operation
10. Diamond Fire GL 1 Pro
11. Diamond Fire GL 1 Pro - Display Characteristics
12. Diamond Fire GL 1 Pro - 3DSM Plugin
13. Evans & Sutherland Lightning 1200
14. E & S Lightning 1200 - Display Characteristics
15. Elsa Gloria II With Nvidia's Quadro-Chip

16. Elsa Gloria II - Display Characteristics
17. Elsa And The Driver Problems
18. Elsa Drivers - The Bad News
19. Quality Problems
20. Table Of Features
21. The Test Platforms
22. Test Procedure
23. 3D Studio Max 3.1 R3 Benchmark
24. 3D Studio Max 3.1 R3 Benchmark, Continued
25. 3D Studio Max 3.1 R3 Benchmark, Continued
26. SPECapc Solidworks 99 Benchmark
27. SPECopc SPECviewperf 6.1.1
28. SPECopc SPECviewperf 6.1.1, Continued
29. Fogcity
30. Recommendations And Resume
31. Pros And Cons

Today's mainstream graphics card market is dominated by products containing Nvidia's GeForce chip, the TNT2 Ultra, the G400 series from Matrox and ATI's Rage 128 cards. In our last 3D graphics test we left out one topic: What is actually going on in the OpenGL workstation area?

Professional graphics artists or engineers use hardly any of the graphics chips mentioned above. And this situation is not really improving because of poor support, insufficient driver support for high-end applications and missing functionality. One reason for the poor support are the steadily dwindling profit margins in the last three years. High volumes are the only way to profitability for manufacturers in the mainstream segment. Long gone are the times when workstation PCs sold for 50 000 US-$. This price erosion did not stop at professional OpenGL cards. Currently the 'sweet spot' is just below 1000 Dollars. Granted, there are still very expensive OpenGL computing monsters out there, but the number of shipped products over 1000 Dollars is relatively small.

Today's 'sweet spot customers' demand decent performance, stability for many applications, and of course better support than it is usually the case for mainstream cards. In the following comparison we tested five OpenGL cards for less than 1000 Dollars. Initially we were surprised when only the Diamond Fire GL 1 Pro, Evans & Sutherland Lightning 1200, Elsa Gloria II and 3Dlabs Oxygen GVX1 fitted in this price category we selected. 3Dlabs asked us to also test the GVX210 that at almost 2000 Dollars is far above our specification. However, because of its interesting features we decided to include it in our test nevertheless.