Shop for All
My Passport Essential Portable 320GB Hard Drive - Black My Passport Essential Portable...

Compare the top 5 lowest prices by hovering your mouse over the product names on the left

$119.99
My Book Essential Edition 2.0 External 500GB Hard Drive My Book Essential Edition 2.0... $97.99
Spinpoint F1 1TB Hard Drive Spinpoint F1 1TB Hard Drive $145.00
Barracuda 7200.11 1.5TB Hard Drive Barracuda 7200.11 1.5TB Hard Drive $189.99
Caviar GP 1TB Hard Drive Caviar GP 1TB Hard Drive $134.99

See More Products...

Hitachi's DeskStar 7K500 Mammoth

We reviewed Hitachi's top model in August already. In contrast to the Barracuda 7200.8, it comes with five rather than four platters due to a lower storage density. However, the DeskStar still comes out on top compared to Seagate's device.

Speed Or Capacity: Can't We Have Our Cake And Eat It Too?

We already mentioned the performance shortcomings of the Barracuda 7200.9. While the Barracuda 7200.8 scored 13.8 ms and offered a read transfer rate of up to 68 MB/s, the dot nine reaches 14.1 ms and a mere 61 MB/s - which approaches a 10% decrease in transfer rate. The average read transfer rates even went down by 12%.

PCMark05's hard drive benchmark confirms this with a Windows XP startup transfer rates of 7.8 versus 8.2 MB/s. The file writing benchmark even went down to 57.2 MB/s, while the 'Cuda' 7200.8 scored 66.5 MB/s.

With these results, the Barracuda 7200.9 cannot beat Hitachi's latest DeskStar 7K500 top model, which is built by combining as many as five storage platters. While we would generally tend to purchase drives with as little moving components as possible, the 7K500 definitely is the faster choice, beating the 7200.8 in almost every benchmark.


Talkback
Be the first to comment on this review!

Note You are going to post a comment as anonymous.