Valve threatens legal action against Dbrand over its unsanctioned Portal 2-inspired Companion Cube — edgy accessories manufacturer kills product after asking for licensing deal, admits it didn't have 'the right to make it'

Dbrand Steam Machine Companion Cube
(Image credit: Dbrand)

When the Steam Machine was first unveiled, aesthetic customization was one of its biggest talking points beyond the hardware itself. At the time, Dbrand showed off a case modeled after the iconic Weighted Companion Cube from Portal 2 and later sold it for $99 — all without ever asking Valve permission for the use of its IP. Therefore, as expected, the case is now gone, and every order will be subsequently refunded.

RIP Companion Cube from r/dbrand

This is pretty characteristic of Dbrand, a company that prides itself on its edgy corporate branding where it often doesn't care about playing by the rules. That's fine as long as the rule-breaking is limited to cursing out your customers on social media, but it doesn't work when you violate copyright law. If anything, Valve was generous with allowing Dbrand to get away with selling the case for this long without repercussions.

That's precisely the takeaway from the company's official statement (embedded above) where it calls Valve "direct, fair, and respectful throughout." Valve's legal team reached out to Dbrand and asked it to shut down the entire operation; halt sales immediately and take down the sales page and all promotional content. Dbrand complied and even extended a hand for an official collaboration, but Valve turned down the offer.

Latest Videos From

The popular skin manufacturer has previously found itself in similar hot waters with Sony and Nintendo. You may remember the famous "Darkplates" saga where the company similarly took advantage of an open customization feature and started selling faceplates for the newly-launched PS5. On the other hand, it also sold unofficial Zelda skins for the Switch OLED, literally called "Clone of the Kingdom."

It's one thing to produce accessories with original designs, but it's a completely different thing to use said company's IP as the design, regardless of the engineering efforts behind it. That's why the Darkplates eventually came back, but the Zelda skin can't. And it's also why a Portal 2-themed case can't realistically exist without asking the company who owns Portal. Valve had to draw a line somewhere to protect its IP and avoid creating precedence for future litigation.

Anyhow, this machoistic corporate strategy has worked wonders for Dbrand's online following, but even the fans called out this move as comically stupid. Beyond the copyright violation, the chance of an official partnership is now gone, too. Dbrand said the Companion Cube case became its second-fastest selling product ever, implying things would've certainly worked out had Dbrand approached Valve ahead of time.

Google Preferred Source

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.

TOPICS
Hassam Nasir
Contributing Writer

Hassam Nasir is a die-hard hardware enthusiast with years of experience as a tech editor and writer, focusing on detailed CPU comparisons and general hardware news. When he’s not working, you’ll find him bending tubes for his ever-evolving custom water-loop gaming rig or benchmarking the latest CPUs and GPUs just for fun.

  • russell_john
    Just another reason not to buy this Billionaire's overpriced underpowered hunk of junk. My computer from 2019 had more power ......
    Reply
  • thrus
    To be fair why would you team up with a company when they just used your property illegally? That doesn't seem like a business partner that is going to behave in a way that you can trust ton honor any agreement you come to, especially when they know what they did and don't care seeing as they have done it multiple times in the past.
    Reply
  • derekullo
    thrus said:
    To be fair why would you team up with a company when they just used your property illegally? That doesn't seem like a business partner that is going to behave in a way that you can trust ton honor any agreement you come to, especially when they know what they did and don't care seeing as they have done it multiple times in the past.
    They did it to make a news story.
    Did you know of Dbrand yesterday? ... me neither.
    And now we are talking about them.
    Reply
  • usertests
    russell_john said:
    Just another reason not to buy this Billionaire's overpriced underpowered hunk of junk. My computer from 2019 had more power ......
    Dbrand admitted they used Valve's IP without permission/license.
    derekullo said:
    They did it to make a news story.
    Did you know of Dbrand yesterday? ... me neither.
    And now we are talking about them.
    I vaguely recalled the Darkplates situation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dbrand#PlayStation_5_faceplates
    Reply
  • JamesJones44
    russell_john said:
    Just another reason not to buy this Billionaire's overpriced underpowered hunk of junk. My computer from 2019 had more power ......
    I've been critical of the Steam Machine, but it has long been established that you need permission to use someone else's IP...
    Reply
  • jerkofme
    russell_john said:
    Just another reason not to buy this Billionaire's overpriced underpowered hunk of junk. My computer from 2019 had more power ......
    It may have. Care to share the specs of your 2019 PC? I wonder if we rebuilt it with today's market prices. If it would be cheaper than the steam machine. I'm very highly doubt it. The steam machine is overpriced for its capabilities based on 2015-2020 prices.

    The ram alone in the steam machine costs three hundred dollars. The video card is another five. There's eight hundred dollars, and we haven't even touched the motherboard Power supply cpu, data storage, or case.

    I was very surprised the base model didnt start at 1500.

    But overall, i'm really not surprised when anyone buys something overpriced. Macbooks are still selling...
    Reply
  • TheOtherOne
    jerkofme said:
    But overall, i'm really not surprised when anyone buys something overpriced. Macbooks are still selling...
    And so are iPhones!
    But that's iCult for you, they will buy anything from Apple, regardless of the Specs and producing cost. ❤
    Reply
  • krisavi
    derekullo said:
    They did it to make a news story.
    Did you know of Dbrand yesterday? ... me neither.
    And now we are talking about them.
    I have known about them for years, just because they are unknown to you doesn't mean no one knows them.

    They made the skin without IP and Valve has the right to shut them down. I think if they would want to recuperate some cost, they could offer valve to buy the molds and hope that valve will release the skin that people want. There was demand and I am sure Valve also understands that people might end up being upset at them for not making a deal to make it legal. Valve does cooperation with other companies like iFixIt to provide support for parts.
    Reply