OpenAI bans China-linked ChatGPT accounts that amplified US data center electricity price backlash — used AI-generated cartoons to stoke fears over U.S. data center energy costs

OpenAi Dev Day, Nov 7
(Image credit: OpenAI)

OpenAI says it has banned two clusters of ChatGPT accounts it believes are operating from China, which used its models for covert influence campaigns targeting U.S. tech and policy debates, including one called “Data Center Bandwagon,” that produced social media comments and comic strips blaming AI data centers for rising household electricity bills. Whoever was operating the accounts prompted ChatGPT in Simplified Chinese via VPNs, and posed on X as Americans from a range of backgrounds. Yet OpenAI’s full threat report found that the activity generated virtually no authentic engagement.

A second cluster, "Tech and Tariffs," generated anti-tariff cartoons under instructions to depict President Trump but never Chinese leader Xi Jinping, and was linked to a network of fake X accounts spreading false claims that ChatGPT user data had been stolen.

OpenAI assessed that the Data Center Bandwagon operators were likely a social media team at a private Chinese tech company working for provincial-level government clients. Among other requests, they asked ChatGPT for comic strips about a grid operator's capacity auction prices, drawing on a regional newspaper's reporting, then posted the output on X under hashtags such as #capacityauction, alongside links to legitimate news coverage.

Latest Videos From

While no grid operator was named, capacity auction pricing links back to a real, well-documented dispute: PJM Interconnection's independent market monitor has blamed data centers for an "irreversible" 75.5% increase in power costs across the largest U.S. grid region, with wholesale prices near some data center clusters having climbed as much as 267% in five years. Three U.S. senators have demanded answers from Amazon, Google, and Meta over costs passed to residential customers.

"This was not a case of an influence operation creating a debate," Ben Nimmo, principal investigator at OpenAI, said. OpenAI rated the activity Category One on the Breakout Scale, meaning it stayed on one platform, with no evidence that it reached genuine audiences.

The Tech and Tariffs cluster poked fun at U.S.-China competition around tariffs, rare earths, AI, 5G, and industrial resilience, and generated bulk comment batches in English, Italian, Japanese, and Traditional Chinese, the latter aimed at audiences in Taiwan. One operator described the accounts as a "water army," a Chinese term for coordinated troll networks, and asked ChatGPT to design a system for scraping and analyzing social media posts from individuals flagged as risks. OpenAI said its model returned generic data storage advice and declined to help with collection. Fake accounts in the same X network repeatedly posted fabricated claims that ChatGPT user data had been compromised, which OpenAI reckons is an attempt to damage its own reputation.

In its full threat report, OpenAI compared the campaigns to the 2022 Spamouflage operation, which researchers at ASPI and Mandiant found targeting Lynas Rare Earths, Appia, and USA Rare Earth after Beijing's 14th Five-Year Plan prioritized rare earths. The new activity followed the adoption of the 15th Five-Year Plan recommendations, elevating AI as a strategic industry for China.

Google Preferred Source

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.

TOPICS
Luke James
Contributor

Luke James is a freelance writer and journalist.  Although his background is in legal, he has a personal interest in all things tech, especially hardware and microelectronics, and anything regulatory. 

  • Notton
    Okay, so are they going to go after the Russian propaganda bots, impression farming bots, etc?
    Because, from the sounds of it, OpenAI will only take action if they deem they are losing money off of the transaction.

    I also find it funny the Chinese bots mainly targeted Twitter.
    That place is now so full of bots, you'll maybe see like 1/1000 comments made by an actual human.
    It's so bad it makes Youtube comments section look good in comparison. (they're both bad and filled with bots)
    Reply
  • PEnns
    Hide it and the problems will go away!!

    Damn those cartons, they're keeping the tech Bros awake at night.
    Reply
  • Zaranthos
    I suspect these types of things are far more widespread and common than we think. The AI and data center backlash often doesn't look organic at all, nor does it even make sense sometimes. One way or another this stuff is going to happen and most of the time trying to stop it will be like pissing into the wind. The appetite for it comes from industry and consumer alike carried by hundreds of trillions of dollars of investments.
    Reply
  • Blacksad999
    Notton said:
    Okay, so are they going to go after the Russian propaganda bots, impression farming bots, etc?
    Because, from the sounds of it, OpenAI will only take action if they deem they are losing money off of the transaction.

    I also find it funny the Chinese bots mainly targeted Twitter.
    That place is now so full of bots, you'll maybe see like 1/1000 comments made by an actual human.
    It's so bad it makes Youtube comments section look good in comparison. (they're both bad and filled with bots)
    Exactly.
    Russian propaganda bots who spam conservative "alternative facts"? No problem.
    Chinese bots who say something negative about AI datacenters? Gotta go.
    Reply
  • phead128
    NIMBYism ("Not In My Back Yard") is a classic American tradition dating back to 1980's, over 46 years ago.

    OpenAI is filing for IPO worth almost $1 Trillion and is financially invested in steamrolling any opposition to it's AI and data center plans - democracy be damned.

    If you oppose higher electricity and water depletion in your neighborhood, you are obviously a Chinese agent and must arrested for sabotage for speaking the truth against Big AI.
    Reply
  • bit_user
    phead128 said:
    NIMBYism ("Not In My Back Yard") is a classic American tradition dating back to 1980's, over 46 years ago.
    And it's not just affecting the people whose back yards it's in! It's having a real impact on electricity prices and memory prices. So, the natural expectation should be for widespread outcry!

    phead128 said:
    If you oppose higher electricity and water depletion in your neighborhood, you are obviously a Chinese agent and must arrested for sabotage for speaking the truth against Big AI.
    Well, we have yet to hear complaints about legit users getting banned on these grounds. Maybe those will come.

    In the meantime, the subtext of the announcement seems to be "these concerns are overblown, as they were stoked by foreign agents". Not that I agree with it, but that seems to be their message.
    Reply
  • phead128
    Even toms reported on this a day ago:

    AI is set to consume up to 600 billion gallons of water by 2030 — rising energy consumption primarily to blame as data center power demands riseo-blame-as-data-center-power-demands-rise
    Propagandist outlet confirmed!! /s
    Reply
  • nookoool
    A random Chinese nationalist trolling or just spewing uncomfortable facts is always written as state covert operation by western media lol.

    I guess the interesting thing is that they fingerprint ai generated graphics c and actively run surveillance on it or actively monitor content being generated (??). Ask uncomfortable questions about the country and you get autoflagged?
    Reply
  • gdmaclew
    phead128 said:
    Even toms reported on this a day ago:

    AI is set to consume up to 600 billion gallons of water by 2030 — rising energy consumption primarily to blame as data center power demands riseo-blame-as-data-center-power-demands-rise
    Propagandist outlet confirmed!! /s
    Where does it go?
    Does it just evaporate?
    Reply
  • bit_user
    gdmaclew said:
    Where does it go?
    Does it just evaporate?
    Yes, the point is that it evaporates from where the datacenter (and more importantly: power generation) is located, which is a problem if it's in a water-scarce region. That's when it's a problem.
    Reply