Nvidia Sued by Laptop Owners Over Faulty Chips

Next news
2:01 PM - May 13, 2009 by Marcus Yam

Apple, Dell, and HP laptop owners are tag-teaming Nvidia with a combined lawsuit stemming from issues with faulty GPUs

While Nvidia’s technology may have moved on from the GeForce G84 and G86 fiasco, owners of that chip certainly haven’t.

In fact, five laptop owners who have the older, faulty GeForce hardware are now banding together to sue Nvidia, reported ComputerWorld.

According to court documents, the plaintiffs are seeking from Nvidia full replacement of the faulty chips and to pay unspecified damages.

Rather than recall faulty notebooks, manufacturers of laptops affected have gone through certain steps to help cover the problem. Apple promised owners of the GeForce 8600M GT-equipped that it would repair for free any faulty GPUs within two years of purchase date, regardless of extended Apple Care coverage.

Other notebook makers such as HP and Dell also extended warranties and released new BIOS software that increased the fan speed to better cool the GPU – hopefully warding off any defects from showing up.

Such measures were unsatisfactory for many, especially the five who are now suing Nvidia.

"This is a grossly inadequate 'remedy,' as it results in additional manifest defects, including, without limitation, further degraded battery life, system performance and increased noise in the Class Computers," the legal complaint read.

"Worse, this 'remedy' fails to solve the actual problem. Instead, this measure only ensures that the Class Computers will fail after the OEM's express warranty period expires, potentially leaving consumers with a defective computer and no immediate recourse," the lawsuit continued. "Finally, even after this purported 'update,' video and system performance is still degraded due to unacceptably high heat and part failures.

The plaintiffs are spread out in Louisiana, California, Illinois, New Jersey and New Mexico. Although among them are only laptops made by Apple, Dell and HP, if such a suit were to hold any water and move to class action status, it could be spread owners of other notebook makes. Stay tuned.

Source : Tom's Hardware US

Talkback
Add your comment
Tindytim 05/13/2009 8:17 PM
Hide
--1+

And the Apple tax just gets higher and higher.

chripuck 05/13/2009 8:17 PM
Hide
-5+

I had the most problems on my Sony Vaio with the 8400m GT chipset.

dman3k 05/13/2009 8:29 PM
Hide
-0+

Apple has problems?? OMG OMG! Has hell frozen over??

Let me call Master Steve Jobs to make sure.

Tedders 05/13/2009 8:31 PM
Hide
-4+

Uh, Guys, Dell and HP have the same issues. Not Apple's fault.

megamanx00 05/13/2009 8:38 PM
Hide
-5+

Hah, funny

Oh well that's what happens. The problem is so bad there are people on ebay just specializing in replacing and repairing the affected HP laptop motherboards. You see some of the boards repaired and resold, which isn't bad since you can pick up a system that just needs one of those new boards pretty cheap. Of course then there is the pain of taking it appart ^_^, but that's what I did to build my cheap DV6000 latop.

Anonymous 05/13/2009 8:45 PM
Hide
-3+

My Asus G1S laptop died two weeks ago. I did some video editing, put it to sleep, and when i came back, nothing. My 8600gt is dead and to replace it out of warranty would be "A couple hundred dollars" as quoted from tech support. I just want them to replace a faulty and recalled card that they knew would burn out. We need a class action lawsuit, this looks to be just 5 people.

Tindytim 05/13/2009 8:48 PM
Show
kyeana 05/13/2009 9:05 PM
Hide
-0+

Here we go again!

ill b ben 05/13/2009 10:12 PM
Hide
-4+

ahh.... my good old 8600m gs... wich stoped working after 1.5 year or so.. good thing i write a lot of e-mails wich made me get a brand new!!.. crappy motherboard with the same 8600m gs again so again its a matter of time.. Ans yeah it is nvidia fault since they decide what the materials are for the gpu it self. not to forget my 8600 gts wich also stoped working after the same period of time.. i learnd my lessons back to ati

war2k9 05/13/2009 10:13 PM
Show
ill b ben 05/13/2009 10:31 PM
Hide
-1+

no not rly actually, far from it i would still recommend nvidia over ati if it has the more bang for buck. But the trouble wich came along with getting a 'fix' for my laptop was a pain alone but when my pc went down along i.. well lets say i was rather pissd since i used em both for CAD work and some 3d work (student) and since i had no spair gpu i was screwed for a month or so. All in all it worked out eventually.. but yeh i my self wouldnt buy a nvidia chipset based on those cores anymore.

norbs 05/13/2009 11:10 PM
Hide
-2+

So is the first thing you guys do is look for anything in reference to apple and then post?

tbq 05/14/2009 12:32 PM
Hide
-2+

How does this become a class action suit? And how do we sign on if that happens?

Tindytim 05/14/2009 12:48 PM
Hide
-2+

norbs :
So is the first thing you guys do is look for anything in reference to apple and then post?


Actually I look for any reference of Monkey Island 5 then post.

kyeana 05/14/2009 12:57 PM
Hide
--1+

^:D

matt87_50 05/14/2009 1:51 AM
Hide
-1+

give em one for me and my dell m1330! i can't believe they weren't forced to recall or even FIX THE PROBLEM for subsequent releases of the chips.
just because it doesn't break in the short term, they thought they could get away with it. temperature sensitive chips just wont cut it, ESPECIALLY in a laptop! FU nvidia. enough to convert me to ati just to spite you (though i've always liked ati)

apache_lives 05/14/2009 3:06 AM
Hide
-1+

heh 8400's and 8600's arnt the only bad chip series we have seen at our shop fronts

i say f**k nvidia - im not buying there products for a while yet cause i aint trust them, ATi for me next time me thinks

lire210 05/14/2009 3:39 AM
Hide
-1+

chripuck :
I had the most problems on my Sony Vaio with the 8400m GT chipset.


i wouldn't touch vaio with a 10000000000 foot pole unless it was free because they cost alot for ok hardware just a step bellow a mac ick.

kato128 05/14/2009 5:06 AM
Hide
-2+

This is one reason why I never buy a laptop for performance video. Its much easier to replace a pcie card than a faulty mainboard chipset.

Zoonie 05/14/2009 2:09 PM
Hide
-2+

One word - finally!

Miribus 05/14/2009 4:17 PM
Hide
-2+

First, my one Apple dig out of the way, because I can:

If Apple didn't use nVidia, which would thus make this only happen in "PC's" Apple would probably quickly run ads as to how this is a "PC" problem, and somehow by extension, Windows.

Second, I'm glad this is being taken to court as a stupid BIOS update to spin the fan faster doesn't really fix an overheating issue with poor silicon. Many XBOX360 owners can tell you that.
As the article states, it really just delays it.
Most importantly, apparently nVidia knew about it for quite some time, and (like the MS with the 360), prayed it just wouldn't be an issue.
They have to be taken to court for that.

To Apple's credit: they are at least apparently attempting to actually repair and replace the boards (I presume with better silicon?)

ShqTth 05/14/2009 8:34 PM
Hide
-0+

HP Did a good job, to most models, HP extended the warrenty perriod 6 months. Or if the laptop was out of warrenty, then it has a one time free replacement under that policy.

A customers notebook was covered under it, he was happy, as he bought that laptop from his x wife for $550.
And now hes glad he doesn't have a defunt laptop. No one likes giving free money to a x-wife for nothing haha.

Anonymous 05/14/2009 10:50 PM
Hide
-0+

My graphics card doesn't like iplayer. 8400M GT GPU on a Vaio (also thought i was getting 512 dedicated memory and got 64, but maybe i was being stupid).

On certain points on the new iPlayer is when it crashes e.g. during heros "I am Sylar" there is a point, also a point on the Jonathan Ross.

First time: A restart fixed it, played iplayer again and oh dear crash at the same point. Restart fixed it.

Second time: Different iplayer program. Crashed and took all day to try and fix. Now have updated the driver so hopefully the problem is solved.

apache_lives 05/15/2009 3:58 AM
Hide
--1+

z2009 :
My graphics card doesn't like iplayer. 8400M GT GPU on a Vaio (also thought i was getting 512 dedicated memory and got 64, but maybe i was being stupid). On certain points on the new iPlayer is when it crashes e.g. during heros "I am Sylar" there is a point, also a point on the Jonathan Ross.First time: A restart fixed it, played iplayer again and oh dear crash at the same point. Restart fixed it. Second time: Different iplayer program. Crashed and took all day to try and fix. Now have updated the driver so hopefully the problem is solved.



lol doesnt sound like anything to do with this article

Anonymous 05/18/2009 5:36 PM
Hide
-1+

Yeah i was wrong. It just occurred reading this post ironically. What happens is the screen goes weird, everything outlined in pink- hard to describe. Computer crashes then when it starts up i have lines all over the screen as if it is failing to initialise the previous graphics. It also starts up in low graphics mode.

It corrects itself randomly- this time after 30 minutes it just went back to normal after a restart, last time after a day while i was trying to get more information about it. So you don't think it's related to this? What can be the problem, just updated the driver and checked for newer updates but is the latest.

Comments are closed on this page.

Sponsored links

Related articles

  • Two's Company, Four's a WOW! Sneak Preview of NVIDIA Quad GPU Graphics

    Dual graphics solutions using SLI are yesterday's news - quad rendering is in! Asus' muscle-card combines two GeForce 7800 GT chips on one board. Pair two of these cards up in SLI mode, and you get a "Quad GPU" system. Of course, not everyone has $1,600 to spend just on their graphics subsystem.

  • NVIDIA GeForce 6600 GT: AGP Has Not Been Forgotten

    Less than 2 months after it unveiled the GeForce 6600 GT on PCI Express, NVIDIA now presents an AGP version. The same graphics chip is used, and the AGP connection works using an HSI bridge chip. How well does the combination work?

  • Nvidia GeForce 9800 GTX Review

    The 9800 GTX is not a revolutionarily new card. We look at the card's design and test it against a strong set of competitors. How well does its performance match up with its name?

Ads
Ads
All about Notebooks
 Latest Notebooks articles
Intel’s Mobile Core i5 And Core i3: Arrandale Is For The Rest Of Us

Intel’s Mobile Core i5 And Core i3: Arrandale Is For The Rest Of Us
We've already given you a first-look at Intel's Calpella platform in the Mobile Core i7-920XM. Now the company is filling out its next-gen mobile lineup with its Arrandale-based CPUs sporting 32nm dual-core processors and 45nm graphics controllers. Read More

  • Asus' G51J: Affordable Core i7 Mobile Gaming?
    Mobility and gaming have been at odds for a long time, but Asus thinks its G51J could be the solution. With Intel Core i7 Mobile CPU technology and Nvidia’s recent GeForce GTX-260M, is this mid-sized, mid-priced notebook too good to be true at ~$1,500? Read More
All Notebooks articles
 Notebooks performance charts
All performance charts
 Latest Notebooks news
All Notebooks news

Newsletters


  • Ask your question about IT issues
  • Post

Partners

Ads

Sponsored links