Linus Torvalds slams supporters of delisted Russian driver maintainers as ‘trolls’

Linus Torvalds
(Image credit: TED)
Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware
Mark Tyson
News Editor

Mark Tyson is a news editor at Tom's Hardware. He enjoys covering the full breadth of PC tech; from business and semiconductor design to products approaching the edge of reason.

  • usertests
    Those darn trolls aaaaahhh!

    MD4AulkzdJE
    Reply
  • bit_user
    The article said:
    Linus Torvalds has dismissed those concerned about the recent dismissal of Russian kernel driver maintainers as trolls.
    You're being needlessly inflammatory. He didn't state or imply there were no legitimate concerns, but that's not to say all the objections are in good faith. Before you demonize Linus, you might want to look at some of the disinformation-laden comments he's talking about. I think he was reacting to people stirring up a big public backlash, which is utterly pointless if you understand why they got removed.

    The reason the maintainers got de-listed was in order to comply with sanctions, as advised by their (presumably the Linux Foundation's) lawyers. This wasn't a personal grudge on the part of Linus or any other core maintainers, as far as I can tell.
    https://www.phoronix.com/news/Linux-Compliance-Requirements
    Reply
  • Elusive Ruse
    I love this guy! :LOL:
    Reply
  • nrdwka
    bit_user said:
    You're being needlessly inflammatory. He didn't state or imply there were no legitimate concerns, but that's not to say all the objections are in good faith. Before you demonize Linus, you might want to look at some of the disinformation-laden comments he's talking about. I think he was reacting to people stirring up a big public backlash, which is utterly pointless if you understand why they got removed.

    The reason the maintainers got de-listed was in order to comply with sanctions, as advised by their (presumably the Linux Foundation's) lawyers. This wasn't a personal grudge on the part of Linus or any other core maintainers, as far as I can tell.
    https://www.phoronix.com/news/Linux-Compliance-Requirements
    The linked post describe well what linux doundation hope what that move will satisfy US and no pursuits will be charged against Linux foundation for not respecting US sanctio. And actually they are "separating" on good terms

    On other hand the message from Linus feels like personal grudge against Russian maintainers => sometime it is good to do not let tech peoples to make a statement on an inflammatory subject without agreement with other paries involved (aka colleague s from Linux foundation)
    Reply
  • AndrewJacksonZA
    So, uh, are their previous contributions removed along with their names? Even though people from "approved" countries will have to redo the work?

    You know, just to be safe.
    Reply
  • AndrewJacksonZA
    bit_user said:
    The reason the maintainers got de-listed was in order to comply with sanctions, as advised by their (presumably the Linux Foundation's) lawyers. This wasn't a personal grudge on the part of Linus or any other core maintainers, as far as I can tell.
    https://www.phoronix.com/news/Linux-Compliance-Requirements
    I understand your post and have read the article. I disagree with your last sentence though, Linus' wording made it sound very personal.
    Reply
  • NinoPino
    AndrewJacksonZA said:
    So, uh, are their previous contributions removed along with their names? Even though people from "approved" countries will have to redo the work?

    You know, just to be safe.
    To be removed are only the names from the MAINTEINERS file. At least for the moment patches will be accepted.
    Reply
  • NinoPino
    Linus could have simply exposed the kernel "compliance requirements", explaining the situation without doing such aggressive declarations.
    And two phrases sound very ugly. The "Did you think I'd be *supporting* Russian aggression?” that indirectly imply that Linus think that accepting Russians contribution to the Linux kernel means support Russia military operation, that is obviously a foolish thinking. I hope Linus do not think this for real.
    The other ugly affirmation was the "patriotic" Finnish origin that is absolutely of bad taste in this context. This personal and unhappy statement put a very bad light on Linus professionalism as "Kernel impartial coordinator".
    Reply
  • husker
    Reply
  • bit_user
    nrdwka said:
    On other hand the message from Linus feels like personal grudge against Russian maintainers
    I disagree. I think he was reacting to the backlash that occurred, after the maintainers were removed. The removed maintainers are a small group of people that he could deal with individually, if need be. There's no reason for him to make such public statements, if it mainly was being addressed to them.
    Reply