An IP Address Does Not Identify a Person, Rules Judge

Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware
TOPICS
Kevin Parrish
Contributor

Kevin Parrish has over a decade of experience as a writer, editor, and product tester. His work focused on computer hardware, networking equipment, smartphones, tablets, gaming consoles, and other internet-connected devices. His work has appeared in Tom's Hardware, Tom's Guide, Maximum PC, Digital Trends, Android Authority, How-To Geek, Lifewire, and others.

  • boiler1990
    Thank you, sir, for being intelligent amid the recent chaos of these broad lawsuits *tips hat*
    Reply
  • mman74
    I would say there is more than reasonable doubt in this area. Certainly it would be abhorrent to put someone away for murder on such tenuous evidence, but it seems like just because we are talking about big studios strong arming - what could clearly be innocent people into – into coughing up massive fines, then reasonable doubt no longer applies. Well I say, No!
    Reply
  • Delengowski
    Wow, someone with a brain; there is still hope.
    Reply
  • blazorthon
    If someone has an open/unsecured network, should they be held more accountable than someone who has a password protected network, even if it's not AES encrypted, or if it is? These questions should be asked too.
    Reply
  • Devoteicon
    Now only if there were more people working in politics that had the level of intelligence that this judge has... image the possibilities.
    Reply
  • CaedenV
    ... things that will change with ipv6
    Reply
  • s3anister
    Seems legit.
    Reply
  • finally somebody woke up. piracy will be there no matter what. Instead of forcing people to those costly fines, they should be given some option to buy the original content first. These massive fines have started a thug business. A daylight robbery. What if some of these people doing piracy r paid by the companies themselves so that they can lure and trap other people into these web.
    Reply
  • blazorthon
    blazorthonIf someone has an open/unsecured network, should they be held more accountable than someone who has a password protected network, even if it's not AES encrypted, or if it is? These questions should be asked too.
    To whoever it was who down-voted me, I ask you this: Do you really think that the RIAA or whoever won't try something along these lines?

    Their argument would be something like this: If someone leaves their WiFi network open to all because they don't secure it, then they are basically leaving the keys to a nuclear bomb with a map of where to find the bomb right on their front porch. The owners of a WiFi capable network should be held accountable for their heinous disregard for our property should some delinquent(s) use this insecure WiFi network that is basically just a silver platter.

    Do you really think that these @$$es won't try something like this? What if they do and we don't get lucky and have a reasonable judge at the head of the decision?
    Reply
  • computernerdforlife
    In the picture: Patchy the pirate totally ruined every part of Spongebob. IP address... Patchy? GTFO of here. That ruined the whole context of this article for me.

    As far as us long term Spongebob fans go, he SUCKS! If you don't believe me, believe Hasselhoff. :)
    Reply