Topics:

ASUS Creates Upgradeable Graphics Cards

5:50 PM - May 8, 2008 by Theo Valich
Source: Tom's Hardware US – Keywords: asus, graphics, card
Categories: AMD/ATI, Build Your Own, NVIDIA

Syndication: Add to your Google homepage Add to My Yahoo!

 

Taipei (Taiwan) - The vision of upgradeable graphic cards goes back to the late 1990s, when Micron Technology was experimenting with removable sockets. In 2006, both MSI and Gigabyte showcased upgradeable graphic cards, but their concepts, which were based on GeForce Go MXM boards, never took off. Earlier this year, Asus introduced a single board with three MXM slots for ATI Mobility Radeon 3850 or 3870 cards (upgradeable with future parts), and has now unveiled its single-MXM product.

Called Splendid HD 3850M, this card doesn’t look like anything special, until you remove the dual-slot cooler. What you can see then is a MXM card with a RV670 chip and 512 MB of memory attached to the PCB that contains the Splendid HD video processor: The video processor features 12-bit gamma correction, 7-region color enhancement and dynamic contrast engine.

The Graphics chip is clocked at 668 MHz while the 512 MB GDDR3 memory operates at 828 MHz DDR (1.65 GT/s). According to Asus, this MXM card will score around 600 3DMarks (3DMark06) more than ATI’s own reference design. But what makes the different, is the fact that this product is significantly shorter than the Radeon 3850 or 3870 ATI reference design.


The Asus Trinity card has three MXM slots. The company is currently selling the card with three modules based on the Radeon HD 3850.

Thanks to a modular design, you will be able to upgrade to upcoming MXM modules, including ATI’s RV770 and RV870 chips (Radeon HD 4800, 5800 series). Interestingly, there should be no issue to put a Nvidia-GPU based MXM module onto this card, since there is no limiting logic.

Using this design, you can imagine a future where users will upgrade their graphics experience simply by buying a small module. If you would have to buy just the GPU and memory, this approach would actually lead to less money being spent, since you don’t need to buy the complete card over and over again.

This new line of products appears to be much more than an engineering exercise. We hope to see future designs incorporating HDMI-in on graphics cards too, just like on the much anticipated professional sound card, Xonar AV1 .

Asus is now on track of doing something new, something that can put them clearly ahead of the competition.


Talkback

Zerk 09/05/2008 01:34
Hide
Zerk
Sweet Card,that will be Cool, i Guess?
RADIO_ACTIVE 09/05/2008 01:45
Hide
RADIO_ACTIVE
Interesting...
Anything that would make Graphics Cards cheaper gets an A+ in my book.
We will have to wait and see if this product takes off or not.
I like that is is small, I have 2x 8800GTX cards and they take up so much room. My wife has a 8800GTS 512 and it takes up even more room.
N19h7M4r3 09/05/2008 02:08
Hide
N19h7M4r3
I think this should have already existed in a commercial basis for a very long time... a graphic card is almost a small computer... so why havent we been able to buy just a new GPU or memory, i know getting everything to work will be hard, but we can just imagine how it was to make the first motherboard with removable slots for everything...
inglburt 09/05/2008 02:09
Hide
inglburt
If it actually works out like they want, I'm all for it. It sucks spending 3-500 on new video cards every couple years or so.
Turas 09/05/2008 02:18
Hide
Turas
OK I see "The Asus Trinity card has three MXM slots. The company is currently selling the card with three modules based on the Radeon HD 3850. " in the article. Please tell me where one could buy such a card.
miahallen 09/05/2008 02:31
Hide
miahallen
Quote :Using this design, you can imagine a future where users will upgrade their graphics experience simply by buying a small module. If you would have to buy just the GPU and memory, this approach would actually lead to less money being spent, since you don’t need to buy the complete card over and over again.


That's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. An MXM module IS a complete card! THIS WILL NOT SAVE THE END USER MONEY!
athauglas 09/05/2008 04:06
Hide
athauglas
This isn't practical. Graphics cards depreciate and their specifications improve much to quickly for a modular design to make sense. A new GPU module would certainly have new video memory packaged with it, and could have radically different power requirements, thus requiring most of the power circuity to be packaged with it, too. The cooling solution may also have to be packaged with the GPU module, if the original design can't dissipate heat quickly enough. What's left on the base board that actually, you know, costs a significant amount of money? Nothing. Nothing except an expensive, proprietary socket design that serves little no purpose than to create yet *another* mechanical junction that's prone to failure.

No thanks.
lopopo 09/05/2008 06:02
Hide
lopopo
I read a review on this on techreport turns out it sucks because drivers. What the hell is up with people now days they advertise and want you to buy 3 way sli and three of this and four of that and the drivers aren't ready yet or no software can take advantage...if I pay $ I want scalability
virtualban 09/05/2008 10:10
Hide
virtualban
I agree that it might and probably will have some point of view where less money is spent on an upgrade (that's just the idea behind this, isn't it?), but sure it will prevent better products in the long run, as the already limited budget of ATI for example (but even if it was Intel) would be diverted to compatibility with sockets and previous designs and buss and stuff and more money for the same performance for the rest of us.
KyleSTL 09/05/2008 03:32
Hide
KyleSTL
Turas :
The Asus Trinity ... Please tell me where one could buy such a card.


You won't be able to. According to news reports ATI will make ~10 units. It's like asking when you can buy a Ferrari Enzo FXX, never going to happen, unless you have 'connections', or are on a very short hand-picked list.
mf_fm 09/05/2008 05:43
Hide
mf_fm
ASUS FTW, you just can't go wrong with ASUS's board.

15+ years of usage, my first ASUS board is still in working condition.

ever since then, every mobo and graphic cards that i bought is from ASUS, almost 0 problem. almost.

still, ASUS is an A+ brand. strong brand which i will recommend without embarrassment to myself.
maxinexus 09/05/2008 07:00
Hide
maxinexus
This idea is not new!!! But why not make a socket and upgrade just a GPU exactly like we do CPU on MB.
kittle 09/05/2008 09:40
Hide
kittle
And ditto for the GPU memory.
The gamer wants mass processing power. The artist wants lots of memory. The game developer wants both. so we dont need 3 cards, we need 1 card with options.
Id love to see this take off, although the initial outlay for the upgradable card will probably run quite a bit.
hcforde 10/05/2008 03:55
Hide
hcforde
Back in the middle of Feb I made this post
http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/ [...] fire-build

It basicaly addressed what ASUS is doing now, and was wondering why it wasn't being done
groo 11/05/2008 05:39
Hide
groo
MXM is just PCIe x16 for laptops

laptop graphics are usualy several months behind and more expensive

Note You are going to post a comment as anonymous.



Shop for Computer Video Cards
GeForce 8800 GTS Video Card GeForce 8800 GTS Video Card

Compare the top 5 lowest prices by hovering your mouse over the product names on the left

$299.99
GeForce 9800 GX2 Video Card GeForce 9800 GX2 Video Card $664.99
GeForce 9800 GTX Video Card GeForce 9800 GTX Video Card $329.99
GeForce 8800 GTX Video Card GeForce 8800 GTX Video Card $449.99
GeForce 8800 GTS Video Card GeForce 8800 GTS Video Card $309.99

See More Products...