EA Not Banning Consumers Wanting Refunds for SimCity

On Thursday reports began to surface that EA threatened to ban any SimCity owner who requested a refund. That was a 180-degree about-face from the company's stance on launch day, as EA said it would provide customers with refunds if they were unhappy with the service. As of Friday, that stance continues to some degree, but somewhere between now and then, a rep said differently.

The rumor about a possible ban began with this forum post, as disgruntled gamer "CalebPeters" took to the EA forums and posted a message between himself and an EA representative. The SimCity customer was offered a 15-percent off coupon with his next purchase, and help with troubleshooting issues, but no money was going to be released by the company.

The possible ban likely stems from the customer's threat to dispute the charge at the bank. The argument between the two continued on until the rep reveals that according to company policy, refunds are at the company's discretion, and won't always be offered.

"The servers are having issues, with more servers opening up as other countries release then we will show these issues resolving themselves," the rep said. "I can understand this causing frustrations and I do apologize for this. I am sorry, but I am not able to process a refund. Is there anything else that I can assist you with?"

The sad aspect about this dispute is that once a gamer is banned from Origin, they lose every purchase that uses the platform. It's essentially like getting kicked out of Steam – all those game keys and all that hard earned money is lost.

EA followed up with a statement via Twitter. The company said that players won't be banned for requesting refunds, and pointed to the company's Returns & Cancellations policy. Based on the information, EA forum user CalebPEters may have downloaded the digital version which is not refundable.

"All physical products purchased through our Origin Store come with a 14-day unconditional guarantee," the policy reads. "If you don't like it, you can return it within 14 days of its delivery for a prompt refund -- no questions asked!"

Now here's the digital version. "As a general policy, EA does not offer refunds on any products downloaded through Origin," the policy states. EA backs this up on Twitter, reporting that "in general we do not offer refunds on digital download games."

What a mess. Suddenly the Nintendo 3DS is looking a lot more friendly.

Contact Us for News Tips, Corrections and Feedback           

  • audiophillia
    Read them terms and conditions people. you signed away your consumers rights the second you join Origin.
  • mazty
    Not according to the customer trade act in the UK - in fact saying you aren't allowed a refund is illegal if I read the law correctly.
  • flamethrower205
    I smell a lawsuit
  • just-saying
    Mazty, that law also only covers physical tangible goods. Digital Downloads are not physical goods.
  • unksol
    How sad is it that the news is EA is NOT banning people for asking for a refund? Like we should just expect abuse from them and it's shocking they are only screwing you over instead completely banning you...
  • irish_adam
    just-sayingMazty, that law also only covers physical tangible goods. Digital Downloads are not physical goods.
    Isnt it goods and services?
  • bllue
    Seems to depend how you treat the customer service rep (who have nothing to do with whether the servers work or not). Saw screenshots of people who badmouthed and they didn't get a refund while people who were nice about it got it, especially if they called instead of using chat. That was a few days ago so idk if it's the same now.
  • edogawa
    Oh EA, up to no good again I see....
  • QEFX
    And I remember when EA produced good games and tried to support the community.
    It's a shame that with Y2K EA became a company you want to avoid.

  • smeezekitty
    All these problems would be mitigated if you could play the bloody game in single player mode without logging on the servers.