User says access to ’30 years of photos and work’ in OneDrive denied by Microsoft, can't get a response after filing form 18 times — 'Microsoft suspended my account without warning, reason, or any legitimate recourse'

OneDrive install on phone
(Image credit: Shutterstock)

A Microsoft OneDrive user has taken to Reddit with a cautionary tale about their precious personal data in the cloud becoming inaccessible. Redditor deus03690 says that they have lost “30 years worth of irreplaceable photos” due to their misplaced trust in Microsoft’s cloud storage service.

In the discussion thread, the Redditor admits they may have made “a bad move” with their eggs-in-one-basket plan. However, to give the decision context they explain that they were moving house, faced space and relocation constraints, and were hemmed in by limited resources.

Mark Tyson
News Editor

Mark Tyson is a news editor at Tom's Hardware. He enjoys covering the full breadth of PC tech; from business and semiconductor design to products approaching the edge of reason.

  • BTM18
    Why not sue MS ?
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    BTM18 said:
    Why not sue MS ?
    A lawsuit is not the first thing you do.
    Reply
  • TerryLaze
    How did this guy not have a single person that he knew?!
    Give the drives to some family member or anybody to hold.
    Make a few gmail accounts, each one is 15gb free storage, make a second copy there.

    But the issue was probably that he moved so his IP changed and if they moved without their original PCs (logical conclusion of not taking you hard drives with you) then all of the hardware changed, and if somebody tries to connect to your onedrive from a different IP and with different hardware then you want onedrive to be cautious about it.
    He probably ignored warnings about IP having changed and tried to connect to it several times until he got locked out.
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    This guy had "30 years of irreplaceable photos" that he cannot work without yet in that 30 years he never had the funds to buy a single high capacity external hard drive in that time, or take the precaution of subscribing to multiple cloud services (2TB Google One $5 for 2 months promo right now) or use Gmail accounts for free as the person above mentioned, and he didn't have any family or friends to drop the drives off with or post to, and in the last few years he didn't have the resources to invest in a small, high capacity external hard drive that could fit into a pocket? Or heck, did he not have A BANK he could go to to and rent a safety deposit box for a couple of months for his drives?

    And since they were so critical, did he not over time think to buy SD cards over time to keep in a slim metal case for another backup method?
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    Alvar Miles Udell said:
    This guy had "30 years of irreplaceable photos" that he cannot work without yet in that 30 years he never had the funds to buy a single high capacity external hard drive in that time, or take the precaution of subscribing to multiple cloud services (2TB Google One $5 for 2 months promo right now) or use Gmail accounts for free as the person above mentioned, and he didn't have any family or friends to drop the drives off with or post to, and in the last few years he didn't have the resources to invest in a small, high capacity external hard drive that could fit into a pocket? Or heck, did he not have A BANK he could go to to and rent a safety deposit box for a couple of months for his drives?

    And since they were so critical, did he not over time think to buy SD cards over time to keep in a slim metal case for another backup method?
    As seen in the may threads about backups or file recovery, many many many people do not think of this.
    We see this here every day.

    And why my sig pic is relevant.
    Reply
  • bit_user
    Not comparable, but I have some old emails on Hotmail that have gotten corrupted. For the most part, it's nothing terribly important, but it just goes to show that these services generally don't care about your data as much as you do.

    BTW, I am a paying subscriber to MS' email service. I graduated above the "free" tier, long ago.
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    bit_user said:
    Not comparable, but I have some old emails on Hotmail that have gotten corrupted. For the most part, it's nothing terribly important, but it just goes to show that these services generally don't care about your data as much as you do.

    BTW, I am a paying subscriber to MS' email service. I graduated above the "free" tier, long ago.

    That is one reason I stuck with POP3 until just a few years ago, left them on the server and had a local copy, but that doesn't work well in this age of multiple devices.

    USAFRet said:
    As seen in the may threads about backups or file recovery, many many many people do not think of this.
    We see this here every day.

    And why my sig pic is relevant.

    But it is the first case I can remember of a guy going from multiple hard drives to a single cloud service then immediately tossing the drives without uploading the files as encrypted folders and not even waiting a few days to see if that single cloud service didn't flag the account.
    Reply
  • salgado18
    I think it's easy to say that the user should have made another backup, but this is a terrible error from Microsoft. No user should be locked out of a drive they pay for, not even for infringing content, without a warning or a way to delete said content. And any user should have a means to reach humans, even if by email. It doesn't mean the user didn't follow proper backup rules (he didn't, but that's not the point), but it means that Microsoft cannot be trusted with our data.
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    salgado18 said:
    I think it's easy to say that the user should have made another backup, but this is a terrible error from Microsoft. No user should be locked out of a drive they pay for, not even for infringing content, without a warning or a way to delete said content. And any user should have a means to reach humans, even if by email. It doesn't mean the user didn't follow proper backup rules (he didn't, but that's not the point), but it means that Microsoft cannot be trusted with our data.
    Agreed.
    But we do not know the details of how he came to be locked out of his OneDrive space.
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    salgado18 said:
    I think it's easy to say that the user should have made another backup, but this is a terrible error from Microsoft. No user should be locked out of a drive they pay for, not even for infringing content, without a warning or a way to delete said content. And any user should have a means to reach humans, even if by email. It doesn't mean the user didn't follow proper backup rules (he didn't, but that's not the point), but it means that Microsoft cannot be trusted with our data.
    True on Microsoft's part, they (and every service) should have a human over the appeals process and be required to tell them which part of the TOS they violated and have the violations confirmed by human eyes, especially when their TOS is written to be so vague on some fronts as to be able to classify many things as a violation and to no doubt have a very fallible "AI" classify such things.

    Their stance on nudity (none allowed in any form, real or artwork), for example, could be interpreted in a way so that a photograph of Michaelangelo's David or other classical works featuring nudity, a manga with some adult panels, a Hollywood movie featuring nudity, or even album artwork from a certain Nirvana album could be called against the TOS even though all of it is perfectly legal in most of the world.
    Reply