Oxide Games Says AMD Mantle is Disruptive Technology

Maximum PC recently conducted an interview with Oxide Games' Dan Baker to talk about the studio's use of Mantle in the upcoming game Star Swarm. One of the first things the interview points out is that Mantle isn't a low-level API that's close to the metal. But when compared to DirectX, Mantle is lower in the overall software stack.

"It's not low-level in the sense that we are exposed to individual architectural decisions," Baker said. "For example, Mantle still abstracts the details of the shader cores themselves, so that we don't even know if we are running on a vector machine or a scalar machine. What isn't abstracted is the basic way a GPU operates. The GPU is another processor, just like any other, that reads and writes memory. One thing that has happened is that GPUs are now pretty general in terms of functionality. They can read memory anywhere. They can write memory anywhere."

"A lot of the things an API has traditionally managed aren't really necessary any more," he added. "Mantle puts the responsibility onto the developer. Some feel that is too much, but this really isn't any different than managing multiple CPUs on a system, which we have gotten pretty good at. We don't program multiple CPUs with an API, we just handle it ourselves. Mantle gives us a similar capability for the GPU."

Later in the interview they talk about the claims of performance increases when using Mantle. When asked about the performance in Star Swarm, Baker indicated that the performance will depend on how exploitative you are, and the specifics of the engine. In the case of Star Swarm, the team was limited in what they could do by driver overhead problems. There have been decisions made where the team traded GPU performance for CPU. Eventually, his answer turned to DirectX where he said something very interesting about the performance of Mantle.

"We'd like to point out that our Direct3D performance is absolutely outstanding, relative to what is expected. We have spent a huge amount of time optimizing around D3D, and we feel we are actually pretty biased in D3D's favor. Mantle, on the other hand, we've spent far less time with and currently have only pretty basic optimizations. But Mantle is such an elegant API that it still dwarfs our D3D performance."

Later, he said that Mantle is somewhat of a disruptive technology in that it is getting everyone into rethinking things. To read the full interview, head here.

Create a new thread in the US News comments forum about this subject
This thread is closed for comments
71 comments
Comment from the forums
    Your comment
    Top Comments
  • heero yuy
    misleading title much?he says its the (disruptive) technology that would get everyone to rethink thingsthe way the title puts it is more to the effect that he said its a bad technology - the complete opposite as to what he actually said
  • gwwerner
    For all of you who are upset about the word disruptive, from wikipedia:A disruptive innovation is an innovation that helps create a new market and value network, and eventually disrupts an existing market and value network (over a few years or decades), displacing an earlier technology. The term is used in business and technology literature to describe innovations that improve a product or service in ways that the market does not expect.
  • MANOFKRYPTONAK
    Toms has changed people are moronic and not helpful. The title is well constructed, it is not the authors fault people don't know the correct meaning or usage of a word... And swearing indicates very low intelligence IMHO.
  • Other Comments
  • heero yuy
    misleading title much?he says its the (disruptive) technology that would get everyone to rethink thingsthe way the title puts it is more to the effect that he said its a bad technology - the complete opposite as to what he actually said
  • nickul
    ...and then, somewhere, at the very end, in the shortest statement ever: "Later, he said that Mantle is somewhat of a disruptive technology in that it is getting everyone into rethinking things."What a nice way of minimizing all the good things said about Mantle in that interview, and maximizing that one single aspect that is only somewhat negative => Nice chosen title...<= Niice... Nice AMD bashing... again.... I see you're keeping up the good work, Tom's Hardware! ;)U know what, I volunteer to help you start a rumor about how disruptive Mantle is!I will post on Facebook! I'll tweet! I will paint my cat and blame it on Mantle!! XD
  • chicofehr
    Mantle main problem is its going to take some time for developers to optimize their own software to utilize it to its full potential. Most developers have been using DX for very long and using a new api takes time to learn. I am sure the performance will be way better once they get a hang of it.