EVGA power supply allegedly kills 22TB of customer storage — revised model from RMA had a different pin layout and killed all SATA-powered devices
The vendor changed the SATA pin layout on the EVGA GQ 1000W, which isn't compatible with previous power cables.
Reddit user u/sgircys on the DataHoarder subreddit reports that EVGA accidentally destroyed 22TB of storage in his work PC. After RMAing his EVGA power supply for coil whine issues, EVGA sent him a newly revised version of the same unit he bought featuring an upgraded pin layout. Unfortunately, EVGA forgot to send sgircys updated power supply cables to account for the changes. So when sgircys went to plug everything in, the power supply sent too much voltage to the wrong wires, frying all his storage devices.
The story starts with Sgircy contacting EVGA regarding a coil whine issue with his shiny new EVGA GQ 1000W Gold power supply. After contacting EVGA, he sent the unit (at his own expense) to EVGA to get the problem resolved. But in typical fashion, EVGA told the Reddit post to keep all his accessories and power supply cables as they wouldn't be returned if shipped. This is not an unusual practice for most power supply manufacturers.
After getting the unit back, he plugged the unit back into his machine, only to find that the PC was not working. Worse, he heard a click indicating an OCP mechanism was being triggered. After troubleshooting, he found he could power on the system, but only after he unplugged all his SATA-powered devices.
EGVA power supply pin layout change - featuring fried hard drives. Beware when warrantying a PSU. from r/DataHoarder
When he contacted EVGA again, an EVGA rep informed him that “at some point, the pin layout of these power supplies was changed,” confirming why the power supply wasn’t working. The EVGA rep sent him a new batch of cables compatible with the newly rewired version of his power supply for him to use.
However, this is where the story hits rock bottom. After plugging in the new cables, Sgircys discovered that all of his drives—22TB worth—were fried. The old cables he used previously fried all of his SATA-powered storage due to the improper voltages flowing through the incorrect wires.
Contacting EVGA again, the Reddit poster reported that EVGA did not want to replace his storage devices, saying the following: “I’ve never encountered a warranty that offers to cover loss of data or the costs related to the recovery of data and to the letter of our warranty terms, we technically don’t cover any loss or damages incurred by our products either.” EVGA also encouraged the Reddit poster to make a warranty claim from the drive manufacturer(s) themselves to get his storage drives replaced.
UPDATE - EGVA power supply pin layout change - featuring fried hard drives. from r/DataHoarder
Thankfully, this issue is scarce and only happened due to EVGA switching power supply pin layouts on its existing GQ lineup, which doesn't always happen. Regardless, it is somewhat surprising that EVGA has not replaced Sgircy's affected storage devices, especially since this is rare. If the Reddit poster can't get his drives replaced through his drive's warranty, he'll have to replace all of his storage devices out of pocket, which won't be cheap.
Stay On the Cutting Edge: Get the Tom's Hardware Newsletter
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.
Aaron Klotz is a contributing writer for Tom’s Hardware, covering news related to computer hardware such as CPUs, and graphics cards.
-
Rexer Wow. That's too bad. I wish I had words of advice or information on how to recover from such episodes of life but I have none. I know sometimes wrong hapens and the loses are absolutely hair pulling. Worse, is when you entrusted yourself with other people's personal effects or your own such as archive pictures, documents, court evidence and family adresses. Yeah, in bitterness, I've walked alone.Reply -
artk2219 I do hope he had backups, but it is kind of crummy that they sent him a unit without the proper cables, then fail to mention the pin out has changed and that he needs new cables. I wonder how many people have fried equipment related to changes like this. Things tend to not like like it when 12v goes to where 5v, 3.3v, or ground should be.Reply -
BillyBuerger The fact that PSU companies all came up with their own pinouts for modular PSUs and then didn't even follow their own pinouts on different models of their own products has always been stupid. It's way to easy for this to happen. I made a simialr mistake between my Seasonic and Corasir PSUs. But I was lucky that the OCP prevented the unit from turning on and it didn't damage anything.Reply
And while under a normal situation, they can put this on the user that they should have been aware of this, their warranty service should have known this before sending the replacement. That is on them, not on the drive manufacturers to cover. It's still stupid that this is even a thing that users have to be aware of and be careful not to make a stupid mistake and potentially fry very expensive components. -
Co BIY I was unaware the pinouts were not on some standard since the size and configurations of the plugs are all standard.Reply
Shocking. -
Alvar "Miles" Udell EVGA, like all non OEMs, contracts out manufacturing. The last time TomsHardware investigated PSUs, 11 years ago, EVGA was just a rebadger without any input in the designs, and used some questionable sources. If this happened the way the Reddit poster said it happened, and EVGA is still just rebading products, I would guess they changed to a different OEM for that product line, and if they didn't have any technical involvement the new models were constructed differently with different pinouts.Reply
https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/power-supply-oem-manufacturer,2913-6.html -
Alvar "Miles" Udell Amdlova said:Why don't buy a seasonic instead :)
Some people need to suffer a catastrophe before they do something sensible like choose a proper source for the most important component of a computer system. I was one of those, thankfully it was early in my self building career and ever since have only used SeaSonic PSUs. -
suryasans I believe if those are hard disk drives, the data in the fried drives could still be saved if He asks a data recovery expert who usually has some spare hard drives PCBs from various models.Reply -
USAFRet
That is absolutely not a guaranteed outcome.suryasans said:I believe if those are hard disk drives, the data in the fried drives could still be saved if He asks a data recovery expert who usually has some spare hard drives PCBs from various models.
And could have easily been prevented with any rational backup routine.
And, from the article, we have no idea of the status of the "data". Only the demise of the physical drives.