Time To Upgrade, Part 2: Picking The Parts To Replace
After looking at whether or not it makes sense to replace a PC built back in 2007 with a more modern machine, we decided to examine three component upgrade options—graphics, storage, and the motherboard/CPU/RAM platform—separately.
Conclusion
In this article, we took the components used to upgrade a three-year-old PC in the article Time to Upgrade: Should You Dump Your 2007 PC? and tested them individually. We replaced the P35 motherboard with a Core 2 quad-core and 4 GB of DDR2 RAM with a new MSI P55A Fuzion, Core i7-870, and 4 GB of DDR3 RAM. The older Zotac GeForce 8800 GTS made way for MSI's R5870 Lightning, and WD’s 150 GB Raptor hard drive downsized to G.Skill's Phoenix 100 GB SSD.
Scenario 1: Motherboard/CPU/RAM Replacement
Replacing platform components heavily impacts power consumption while significantly increasing performance. However, even a three-year-old quad-core CPU still has lots of firepower for most modern applications. Our conclusion for the full upgrade in the prior article remains valid here: save your money if you don’t use applications that necessitate a platform upgrade.
Scenario 2: Graphics Upgrade
Spending a few hundred dollars on a graphics card is a trickier proposition. True gamers will most likely not have waited three years for a graphics card replacement, as newer cards are faster, provide more advanced functionality, and in the case of AMD's Radeon HD 5000-series, deliver lower power consumption. Occasional gamers should consider purchasing a mainstream graphics card instead of the Radeon HD 5870 we chose, since even a mid-range card like Nvidia's GeForce GTX 460 will improve performance, features, and power savings.
Scenario 3: HDD/SSD Upgrade
This upgrade option is the real surprise. Although decent SSDs start at $200 ($300+ in the case of our 100 GB drive), the benefits are much more noticeable than in Scenarios 1 and 2. The SSD-enabled system boots up much quicker, shuts down a bit faster, and launches applications in only a fraction of the time required by even today's top hard drives. SSD benefits will be glaring to all user types.
Stay on the Cutting Edge
Join the experts who read Tom's Hardware for the inside track on enthusiast PC tech news — and have for over 25 years. We'll send breaking news and in-depth reviews of CPUs, GPUs, AI, maker hardware and more straight to your inbox.
We would prioritize these upgrade options in the following order:
Gamers
- Graphics Card
- SSD
- Motherboard/CPU/RAM
Power Users
- SSD
- Motherboard/CPU/RAM
- Graphics Card
Mainstream Users
- SSD
- Motherboard/CPU/RAM (if at all)
- Graphics Card (if at all, or select a mainstream card)