Amazon sold a fake RTX 4090 FrankenGPU cobbled together using a 4080 GPU and board — scam card was found in a returns pallet deal

Not an RTX 4090
(Image credit: North West Repair)
27

A prominent repair channel on YouTube is warning prospective graphics card buyers that a customer sent in an Amazon-purchased GeForce RTX 4090 which turned out to be a very bad fake. The video, shared by Tony from North West Repair (NWR), underlines the adage ‘buyer beware’ with a bright neon marker. What his customer thought was probably a quick repair job on a $2,000 card turned out to be a ‘no fix’ scam made from a cobbled-together and motley mix of components, including a "fried" RTX 4080 GPU and PCB. The graphics card also had a host of other issues that pointed to a badly cobbled-together FrankenGPU. 

We updated our story as Tony made a point of looking up the fake RTX 4090 card's GPU codename online and asserted it was from an RTX 4090 Laptop, but it is clearly marked as an AD103-300-A1 - which is what you would expect to find on an RTX 4080 desktop PCB.

Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware
Mark Tyson
News Editor

Mark Tyson is a news editor at Tom's Hardware. He enjoys covering the full breadth of PC tech; from business and semiconductor design to products approaching the edge of reason.

  • FoxtrotMichael-1
    I think the larger story here is that Amazon has become no better than AliExpress at peddling fake and counterfeit goods. It’s a shame, because it seems like Amazon has no real desire to crack down on it. The obvious conclusion is that they benefit from this type of behavior and give silence as tacit approval.
    Reply
  • COLGeek
    FoxtrotMichael-1 said:
    I think the larger story here is that Amazon has become no better than AliExpress at peddling fake and counterfeit goods. It’s a shame, because it seems like Amazon has no real desire to crack down on it. The obvious conclusion is that they benefit from this type of behavior and give silence as tacit approval.
    This is a larger issue than just with Amazon. It also happens in brick and mortar stores. This has become a widespread problem and is not likely to go away.

    It does make for interesting reading though.
    Reply
  • digitalgriffin
    COLGeek said:
    This is a larger issue than just with Amazon. It also happens in brick and mortar stores. This has become a widespread problem and is not likely to go away.

    It does make for interesting reading though.
    Pallet return Crates are pennies on the dollar. This guy rolled the dice it would be cheaper to fix than buy a new one, then flip it.

    It is interesting they don't have a better way of tracking fraud with big ticket electronic items.

    Serial number scan on box going out to customer, and scan back in when going in a pallet.
    Reply
  • CDGoin13
    Here is something to consider Russia or China buying the cards to swap the chips to get thier hands on 4090 chips and return or sell the cards with rejected chips.
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    It can happen to new purchases too. Remember the reports of people getting slabs of clay in iPad boxes from places like Walmart and BestBuy, and, of course, the fake Intel CPUs sold at Newegg. I myself got an empty Ryzen 1800X box that had obviously been bought, emptied, and returned (seals were broken), but was put back in new stock instead of used (or taken by an Amazon worker themselves).

    https://www.iphoneincanada.ca/2018/10/12/ontario-man-buys-ipad-walmart-clay/
    https://www.tomshardware.com/news/NewEgg-Fake-Corei7-D-H-Distributing,9814.html
    Reply
  • vanadiel007
    A melted power connector is not shipping damage. What we don't know is the original listing.
    It could have been listed as a damaged card for a large discount. We don't know if it was listed as new or used. Reputable seller or not?

    There's several things we don't know...
    Reply
  • parkerthon
    digitalgriffin said:
    Pallet return Crates are pennies on the dollar. This guy rolled the dice it would be cheaper to fix than buy a new one, then flip it.

    It is interesting they don't have a better way of tracking fraud with big ticket electronic items.

    Serial number scan on box going out to customer, and scan back in when going in a pallet.
    Except what if the product was resealed and resold as new previously? Who sourced the product, was it Amazon or a seller that uses FBA? Was it FBA commingled inventory? What if the buyer reporting the issue is lying to get a refund? Without a verifiable chain of custody from A to Z, they can’t prove anyone did anything. Now they could use analytics to suss out fraudsters that do this repeatedly but I’d bet this is a one off. Whoever threw this together went to way too much effort to make it look passable using various parts combined with time involved in slamming it all together… which means they really were worried about being caught. Amazon already flags unusual return frequency behavior and shuts down accounts based on that alone(sometimes for non-fraud instances).
    Reply
  • PEnns
    CDGoin13 said:
    Here is something to consider Russia or China buying the cards to swap the chips to get thier hands on 4090 chips and return or sell the cards with rejected chips.
    Or, they can get them by the 1000s via other countries that don't care for US sanctions.
    Reply
  • endocine
    COLGeek said:
    It also happens in brick and mortar stores.
    Indeed, bought a 4070ti at microcenter as new, but when taking it out of the box, the gpu had been used, but still worked as indeed a 4070ti. Always check the packaging when purchasing even from brick n mortar
    Reply
  • thisisaname
    Maybe the scam happen when the card was returned to Amazon by the original purchaser?
    Reply