A Split-Design Gaming Keyboard: The Freestyle Edge (Update: Seeking Beta Testers)
Update, 4/5/17, 8am PT: Kinesis Gaming is seeking beta testers for the Freestyle Edge. To be considered, you have to sign up for the newsletter, which you can do here if you're interested. There appears to be no guarantee of selection, though. Also, the Freestyle Edge Kickstarter campaign continues to amass cash; it's currently up to $81,258. There are still 52 hours left in the campaign.
Update, 3/17/17, 8am PT: The Kickstarter campaign has now exceeded its $50,000 threshold, which means the project will go forward. There are still 21 days left in the campaign.
Original article, 3/9/17, 9:20am PT:
Although not exactly novel, split-design keyboards are relatively rare, which is why it's notable that there’s a new contender raising Kickstarter funds to produce one focused on gaming. Kinesis Gaming is looking to drum up $50,000 to finish funding production on a keyboard it’s calling the Freestyle Edge (which kind of sounds like a 1990s skater kid clothing line, but who are we to judge).
Reformatting The Layout
The company’s big idea is that most gamers don’t really use the entire keyboard; primarily, they’re making use of the WASD cluster, several of the keys around them (depending on the type of game), the spacebar, and dedicated left-side macro keys. For many, the numpad is just in the way and takes up valuable desk space--some keyboard makers, including Asus and Tesoro, developed removable numpad modules to address this very issue--and so as part of its design plan, Kinesis Gaming nixed it. Therefore, the Freestyle Edge is technically a TKL keyboard, but Kinesis Gaming saw fit to add ten additional keys on the left side. Eight of those are programmable, but the two on the bottom have dedicated functions (toggle layers on/off, toggle LEDs on/off).
This makes sense, although the company’s implementation results in a rather odd key layout. For instance, note that the Esc key is double wide and positioned above the macro keys instead of above the main key area, and the F keys are shifted to the left of where they would normally be. Further, on the right side, Kinesis Gaming added a vertical row of a few of the keys you’d normally find on the numpad, such as Scroll Lock, Print Screen, Home, End, Pg Up, and Pg Dn.
The arrow keys are there as well, but instead of being set off by themselves, they’re sort of crammed in there with a bunch of other keys. For example, the up arrow key is right underneath the Enter key. This cuts off the right Shift key, making it narrower than normal.
Stay On the Cutting Edge: Get the Tom's Hardware Newsletter
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.
It’s hard to disagree with the decision to include some of those keys, although because they’re in a non-traditional spot, some users will likely have trouble finding them intuitively.
Kinesis Gaming’s split design implementation keeps the two halves of the keyboard connected by a 20-inch cable that connects to the top/back of the two parts. This lets you squish the two halves together, position them at whatever angle(s) are most convenient for you, keep them wide enough that you can place a joystick between them, or move the right-side one out of the way and use just the left-side one for gaming.
They also each have a removable palm rest.
The Lift Kit
The Freestyle Edge also has a Lift Kit. Like ergonomic keyboards, part of the allure of the split design is that you can position the pieces in a way most comfortable for you, and propping them up in the middle gives you a nice ergonomic slant. Kinesis Gaming did not overlook this feature.
The Lift Kit consists of two risers that let you “tent” either or both of the keyboard halves at 5, 10, or 15 degrees. You’ll need to employ the palm wrests if you use the Freestyle Edge in this configuration.
The Lift Kit is not a standard feature of the Freestyle Edge, though; you’ll have to pay extra to get them. However, that’s not an unwise decision on Kinesis Gaming’s part; some users won’t be interested in the Lift Kits, so keeping them as an optional accessory reduces the cost of the keyboard itself.
Key Caps, Switches, And Lighting
Kinesis Gaming is in the tank for Cherry. Its Kickstarter reads in part, “Some keyboard manufacturers are moving away from Cherry to 'clone' switches to save money, but they aren't always passing those savings on to you, the customer. In gaming, every key stroke counts, which is why we insist on using only authentic Cherry switches.”
The Freestyle Edge features Cherry MX switches, mostly; the four keys in the “Programming Cluster” actually have Cherry ML switches. For now, you have the option of choosing Cherry MX Red, Brown, or Blue switches. The Kickstarter noted, “Down the road we hope to be able to offer the Edge in the full-array of Cherry switches, but for our first manufacturing run we had to make some tough choices.” Thus, for now, there will be no Cherry MX Blacks, Greens, Clears, Silent, Speed, etc.
One capitulation Kinesis Gaming made was on lighting. The Freestyle Edge has blue LEDs only, although there are nine brightness levels and a breathing effect you can switch on.
The key caps are ABS plastic, and the company boasted that its key cap legends will show up in the dark with the LEDs off better than other key caps thanks to its three-step “paint-and-laser” process:
“Here's how it works: 1) each keycap gets a base-layer of translucent white paint, then 2) a top-coat of black paint is applied, then 3) the keycaps are laser engraved to remove just the black layer of paint to create the bright white key legend (not gray plastic).”
Kinesis Gaming also noted that although the Freestyle Edge’s layout is unorthodox, (almost) all of the keys are standard sizes. A notable exception is the split spacebar, which has two separate 3.5x lengths. Although the right-side Ctrl and Shift keys are not standard sizes for normal Ctrl and Shift keys, they are 1.75x width. To replace them, you’ll have to find 1.75x with custom legends.
Configuration: On Keyboard Or “On Keyboard”
You can configure the Freestyle Edge via either onboard controls or a GUI. It’s worth noting that the GUI, which is called the SmartSet App, is not software that runs on your PC; instead, it’s a 1MB application that runs on the keyboard itself. Thus, you get thoroughly portable configuration software. The keyboard is plug-and-play, too, so ostensibly you should be able to bring the Freestyle Edge to any PC, plug it on, and pull up the GUI. No installation required.
You can see it in action here:
For on-keyboard programmability, Kinesis Gaming focused on four additional hardware buttons that are located at the top of the right half of the Freestyle Edge: Layout, Macro, Remap, and the “SmartSet” key.
Because the Freestyle Edge has 4MB of onboard memory, you can create and save up to 10 key layouts and “hundreds of additional layouts”, and you can remap any of the 95 keys. You can also record and bind macros on the fly, and the SmartSet key gives you control over the lighting brightness, and lets you toggle NKRO mode and Game mode, get the Status Report, and update the firmware.
Note that within layouts, there are actually two programmable layers. For example, the “top” layer in a given layout may be a WYSIWYG situation, but the second layer could map media controls onto the F keys. The bottom left key in the extra bank of keys toggles these layers on and off.
Specs And Pricing
The Freestyle Edge is not cheap. The basic model--sans Lift Kits but with the palm rests--will run you $219. If you add the Lift Kit, you’ll add $30 to the total, bringing the cost to $249. There are deals if you back the Kickstarter, though.
The “First Edition” round of the Freestyle Edge--a small initial run of 210 of the devices--will be in buyers’ hands in the July-August timeframe. The mass production run will start in September and be distributed to buyers thereafter.
However, the Kickstarter campaign has less than half of that $50,000 raised so far at press time, and if it's not fully funded, Kinesis Gaming won't move forward with the project. There are 29 days left in the campaign.
Product | Kinesis Gaming Freestyle Edge |
---|---|
Type | Ergonomic, split, TKL |
Switch | Cherry MX Red, Brown, or Blue |
Microcontroller | 32-bit Atmel microcontroller |
Onboard Storage | 4MB |
Lighting | Blue LEDs only |
Key Rollover | NKRO |
Interface | USB |
Cable | Braided |
Additional Ports | No |
Key Caps | ABS plastic, three-step “paint-and-laser” process for legends |
Weight | Approx. 2.5lbs |
Software | SmartSet App (runs on keyboard, not PC, compatible only with Windows) |
Misc. | -Plug-and-play-Windows, Mac, Linux, Chrome-Plate-mounted switch design-2-year warranty-Lift Kit (detachable, sold separately) and Palm Pads -Onboard macro, layout, remapping, and lighting controls-Halves connected by 20-inch cable |
Price | $219 for the basic model, $249 with Lift Kits |
-
DerekA_C i wish it was a bit more ergonomic for at least the left side for long hours of gaming.Reply -
scolaner 19403331 said:i wish it was a bit more ergonomic for at least the left side for long hours of gaming.
How would you change it? -
cryoburner
I'm pretty sure the keyboard would be getting made whether they put it on Kickstarter or not. Just look at some quotes from their writeup...19402406 said:However, the Kickstarter campaign has less than half of that $50,000 raised so far at press time, and if it's not fully funded, Kinesis Gaming won't move forward with the project. There are 29 days left in the campaign.
...Kinesis has been building ergonomic keyboards here in Seattle, WA for over 25 years.
This is a long-established company that has spent a year designing their latest keyboard, and they are already in the process of setting up manufacturing with the company that's been building their keyboards for the last 20 years. There is literally no need for them to raise $50,000 through crowdfunding, and even if they somehow didn't manage to make that small sum of money, the product is already well past the point where they would consider cancelling its development. This is little more than a way for them to get free advertising.
...And after 12 months of extensive research & testing with gamers, we're finally ready to build the all-new Freestyle Edge.
...Surprise, the manufacturing process is already underway!
I somehow doubt those "lift kits" cost them much more than a dollar to make, but they are selling them for $30 on top of the cost of a $220 keyboard. And of course, they try to make it sound like an essential feature that you won't want to miss out on in the product description...19402406 said:However, that’s not an unwise decision on Kinesis Gaming’s part; some users won’t be interested in the Lift Kits, so keeping them as an optional accessory reduces the cost of the keyboard itself.
A conventional flat keyboard puts strain on your hands and arms. Over time that strain adds up and can reduce your performance, or even knock you out of the game all together. With the optional Lift Kit, you can tent one or both key modules to provide a neutral wrist and forearm position for extended gaming sessions. This isn't some gimmick, it's just more comfortable.
If it's "just more comfortable", why not include it with the keyboard as a standard feature? Isn't the main point of this keyboard to be more ergonomic? Selling it separately just sounds like a way to upsell potential customers into paying an extra $30 for a couple pieces of plastic that could have probably been built into the bottom of the keyboard at almost no additional cost.
We like RGB lighting as much as the next guy, but does it boost your performance? Our blue LEDs illuminate the keyboard for gaming in low-light conditions, without any gimmicks. Choose from 9 brightness levels or activate Breathe mode to deliver soothing pulses of light.
So a pulsing "breath mode" is not considered a "gimmick"? What if someone finds a neutral white, or some other warmer color to be less distracting than a neon blue glow? Is that a "gimmick"? Keyboard backlighting seems like one place where RGB lighting can actually be useful to have.
Also, why eliminate the numpad when they're adding a set of programmable gaming keys on the left? I would have preferred to see them add a programmable numpad there instead. That way, the numpad could double as an expanded set of gaming keys. They likely eliminated it from the right side to keep both halves of the keyboard relatively equal in size so that they could be angled symmetrically, but with a numpad in place of the gaming keys on the left, they could have made both halves a bit longer. This would have opened up more space on the right side of the keyboard as well, so that they wouldn't have had to squash those keys together like a laptop keyboard.
I do like the idea of a split gaming keyboard though. It could certainly make it easier to use a gaming peripheral like a racing wheel or flight stick alongside a keyboard, or open up more space for using a mouse, in addition to the ergonomic benefits. I just kind of wish they did some things different with the design and that the "retail price" wasn't so inflated just because it's being marketed as "ergonomic". Perhaps another company will design something similar though. -
scolaner 19408271 said:
I'm pretty sure the keyboard would be getting made whether they put it on Kickstarter or not. Just look at some quotes from their writeup...19402406 said:However, the Kickstarter campaign has less than half of that $50,000 raised so far at press time, and if it's not fully funded, Kinesis Gaming won't move forward with the project. There are 29 days left in the campaign.
...Kinesis has been building ergonomic keyboards here in Seattle, WA for over 25 years.
This is a long-established company that has spent a year designing their latest keyboard, and they are already in the process of setting up manufacturing with the company that's been building their keyboards for the last 20 years. There is literally no need for them to raise $50,000 through crowdfunding, and even if they somehow didn't manage to make that small sum of money, the product is already well past the point where they would consider cancelling its development. This is little more than a way for them to get free advertising.
...And after 12 months of extensive research & testing with gamers, we're finally ready to build the all-new Freestyle Edge.
...Surprise, the manufacturing process is already underway!
I somehow doubt those "lift kits" cost them much more than a dollar to make, but they are selling them for $30 on top of the cost of a $220 keyboard. And of course, they try to make it sound like an essential feature that you won't want to miss out on in the product description...19402406 said:However, that’s not an unwise decision on Kinesis Gaming’s part; some users won’t be interested in the Lift Kits, so keeping them as an optional accessory reduces the cost of the keyboard itself.
A conventional flat keyboard puts strain on your hands and arms. Over time that strain adds up and can reduce your performance, or even knock you out of the game all together. With the optional Lift Kit, you can tent one or both key modules to provide a neutral wrist and forearm position for extended gaming sessions. This isn't some gimmick, it's just more comfortable.
If it's "just more comfortable", why not include it with the keyboard as a standard feature? Isn't the main point of this keyboard to be more ergonomic? Selling it separately just sounds like a way to upsell potential customers into paying an extra $30 for a couple pieces of plastic that could have probably been built into the bottom of the keyboard at almost no additional cost.
We like RGB lighting as much as the next guy, but does it boost your performance? Our blue LEDs illuminate the keyboard for gaming in low-light conditions, without any gimmicks. Choose from 9 brightness levels or activate Breathe mode to deliver soothing pulses of light.
So a pulsing "breath mode" is not considered a "gimmick"? What if someone finds a neutral white, or some other warmer color to be less distracting than a neon blue glow? Is that a "gimmick"? Keyboard backlighting seems like one place where RGB lighting can actually be useful to have.
Also, why eliminate the numpad when they're adding a set of programmable gaming keys on the left? I would have preferred to see them add a programmable numpad there instead. That way, the numpad could double as an expanded set of gaming keys. They likely eliminated it from the right side to keep both halves of the keyboard relatively equal in size so that they could be angled symmetrically, but with a numpad in place of the gaming keys on the left, they could have made both halves a bit longer. This would have opened up more space on the right side of the keyboard as well, so that they wouldn't have had to squash those keys together like a laptop keyboard.
I do like the idea of a split gaming keyboard though. It could certainly make it easier to use a gaming peripheral like a racing wheel or flight stick alongside a keyboard, or open up more space for using a mouse, in addition to the ergonomic benefits. I just kind of wish they did some things different with the design and that the "retail price" wasn't so inflated just because it's being marketed as "ergonomic". Perhaps another company will design something similar though.
Heh. This is why we do original content instead of just copy/pasting the market-speak.
Also, we get this in basically all PR materials. Half the products we cover are billed as "the world's widget". Sigh. -
Ramberjet Neat. But for $219, I would still stick with the route I took: the Ergodox. It's split, programmable, and has the columnar rather than staggered layout. I have a general gaming layer that puts WASD where ESDF normally are on QWERTY for added ergonomic comfort (I use Colemak though, so it's extra useful to be able to transition to WASD anyhow). Then the surrounding buttons (in addition to the immediately adjacent ZXCV, QERF) have been mapped to typical hotkeys: M (map), I (inventory), H, O, etc.Reply -
Dr Croubie I'm a big fan of Kinesis Freestyle, had one for over 2 years (bought to write thesis), then got one at work, now another on the way to use in the lab.Reply
But what's the advantage of this over the regular Kinesis Freestlye? Looks practically the same to me except for those 4 buttons on the top-left of the right section, and some fancy LEDs. The left buttons can already be macro-programmable. Even the VIP lifter looks the same.
And the current-model Freestyle works perfectly well for gaming, as I do play a bit with it already.
Still, everyone should get one of these (or at least the regular Freestyle, they got for <$50 on fleabay occasionally). Your wrists will thank you immensely.
Now all I need is a more accurate vertical lasermouse... -
Dr Croubie I'm a big fan of Kinesis Freestyle, had one for over 2 years (bought to write thesis), then got one at work, now another on the way to use in the lab.Reply
But what's the advantage of this over the regular Kinesis Freestlye? Looks practically the same to me except for those 4 buttons on the top-left of the right section, and some fancy LEDs. The left buttons can already be macro-programmable. Even the VIP lifter looks the same.
And the current-model Freestyle works perfectly well for gaming, as I do play a bit with it already.
Still, everyone should get one of these (or at least the regular Freestyle, they got for <$50 on fleabay occasionally). Your wrists will thank you immensely.
Now all I need is a more accurate vertical lasermouse...