Testing QNAP's TS-470 NAS
QNAP sent us a review sample with four 4 TB Seagate ST4000VN000 hard drives already installed and configured in RAID 5, yielding 12 TB of accessible capacity. The internal file system is ext4, and our TS-470 came with QTS version 4.0.5 installed, dated 10-23-13.
|Test Client Specifications|
|Motherboard||Gigabyte Z77X-UP5 TH, Rev. 1.0, Intel Z77 Express PCH, BIOS: F11|
|CPU||Intel Core i3-3220 (Ivy Bridge) 3.30 GHz, 3 MB Shared L3 Cache|
|RAM||Corsair Dominator Platinum DDR3 2 x 4 GB (8 GB) (reduced to 2 GB to minimize the risk of caching)|
|eSATA Controller||Intel 7 Series/C216 Chipset Family SATA AHCI Controller|
|Hard Disk||Corsair Force Series 3 120 GB, Firmware 1.2|
|DVD ROM||Samsung SH-D163A, SATA 1.5Gb/s|
|Graphics Card||HD Graphics|
|Network Card||Intel Gigabit CT Desktop Adapter|
|Power Supply||Seasonic X Series 760 W|
|System Software & Drivers|
|Operating System||Windows 7 Professional 64 Bit SP1|
|Intel Network Driver||Version 188.8.131.52|
|Intel Chipset Driver||Version 184.108.40.2066|
|Intel NAS Performance Toolkit||Version 1.7.1 (Test Backup with a trace from Version 1.6)|
We determined the transfer rates with version 1.7.1 of the Intel NAS Performance Toolkit. If you are interested in details of this test methodology, you can read up about it in Benchmarking With Intel's NAS Toolkit.
The HD Station tests, which include media playback, are recorded with the Elgato Game Capture device, plugged in between the NAS and display. It gets power from a USB connection that's also used to retrieve the audio and video streams.
Sound Level and Temperatures
QNAP's TS-470 is not completely silent, but it's quiet enough. Unsurprisingly for a network-attached device, its fan is the number-one source of noise. Fortunately, QNAP uses a fairly conservative fan that emits a barely-audible 30.3 db(A).
The system’s temperature stays quite constant. Its CPU operates at 43 degrees Celsius (109 degrees Fahrenheit), and its motherboard sensor reads 33 degrees Celsius (91 degrees Fahrenheit). The hard disks remains quite cool at 31 degrees Celsius (88 degrees Fahrenheit).
When it comes to power consumption, the TS-470 is a mixed bag. On one hand, it's EuP-certified, which means it satisfies an EU requirement mandating the low power draw of inactive electronic devices. However, it neither supports wake-on-LAN nor automatic power-up after an outage in that mode. Makes you wonder how much value there is in EuP if it requires shedding functionality.
Even the power numbers for standby and wake-on-LAN mode are conservative, though, registering 1.2 and 1.6 W, respectively. If we were going to criticize any reading, it'd be the 26 W draw in disk-off mode, which is too high.
In the chart below, we also have readings for consumption while the TS-470 plays back high-def video.
|Off (Standby)||1.2 W|
|Off (EuP)||0.4 W|
|Off (Wake On LAN)||1.6 W|
|Disk Power Off||26.3 W|
|Work (Copying Data)||48.3 W|
|Peak (Booting)||102.1 W|
|Media Player (HD Video Playback):||54.4 W|
Because the TS-470 sports relatively potent hardware and commands a premium price, we have high expectations of where its performance should end up, and QNAP's solution doesn't disappoint. Using a single gigabit Ethernet port, we often approached the interface's theoretical limit.
The device demonstrates its processing performance during tests with an encrypted volume, where it maintains approximately 90 MB/s.
For the sake of an easier comparison, we tabulated the test results for the plain text volume and the encrypted volume in a single graph.
The previous generation had a USB3.0 port on the front, wonder why they went back to two?
Also, if my TS-559 Pro II is anything to go by, these things really can't handle dust.
Although TS-470 has a good potential to be upped with an i7 processor and 16 GB ram if you're willing to void the warranty. There's an article showing how to do it...
TD430 running x8 WD 4TB Reds in raid 5 with 2 LANs in Team yielded 700MB/s with 20TB raid array allocation.
This NAS is junk with crap transfer
So ehm… yeah, other than the custom case I'm not really convinced this is great value for money at all.