Barrier Eliminators: X1900GT and X1950XTX from Sapphire

Test Setup

System Hardware
Processor Intel Core 2 Duo E6700, 2.66 GHz, 1066 FSB, 4 MB Cache
Motherboard Abit AB9-Pro V1.00, BIOS 1.4
RAM Corsair CMX512-8000UL
2x 512 MB, CAS 4-4-4-8
Hard Drive Western Digital Raptor WD1500ADFD
150 GB, 10,000 RPM, 16 MB Cache, SATA 150
Networking Marvell Yukon Gigabit PHY, enabled, offline
Graphics Card 1 Sapphire X1950XTX 512M PCI-E D-DVI/VIVO
GPU : ATI Radeon X1950XTX (650 MHz)
RAM : 256 MB GDDR3 (1550 MHz)
Graphics Card 2 Sapphire X1900GT 256M PCI-E D-DVI/VIVO
GPU : ATI Radeon X1900GT (575 MHz)
RAM : 256 MB GDDR3 (1200 MHz)
Graphics Card 3 EVGA 7600GT CO Superclocked
GPU : Nvidia GeForce 7600GT (600 MHz)
RAM : 256 MB GDDR3 (1560 MHz)
Power Supply OCZ GameXStream OCZ700GXSSLI - 700W
System Software & Drivers
OS Windows XP Professional 5.1.2600, Service Pack 2
DirectX Version 9.0c (4.09.0000.0904)
Platform Driver Intel INF
Graphics Drivers ATI Catalyst 6.9
Nvidia Forceware 91.47
Benchmarks and Settings
Black & White 2 Version : Patch 1.1
Video Modes : 1024x768, 1280x1024, 1600x1200
Video Quality : Medium, High with 4xAA
Test : FRAPS 60-second - Intro Island Flyby
FEAR Version : 1.0 Retail
Video Modes : 1024x768, 1280x960, 1600x1200
Computer : Maximum
Graphics Card : Medium, Maximum (Softshadows, 4xAA, 16xAF)
Test Path : Options/Performance/Test settings
Oblivion Version : 1.0.228 Retail
Video Modes : 1024x768, 1280x1024, 1600x1200
Visual Settings : Bloom, HDR, 4x AA
Test : THG custom Indoor/Outdoor game saves
Quake 4 Version : 1.2 (Dual-Core Patch)
Video Modes : 1024x768, 1280x1024, 1600x1200
Video Quality : Medium, Ultra with 4xAA
Command Line : timedemo demo8.demo 1 (1 = load textures)
Video Quality
HQV DVD Catalyst : 3:2 Pulldown Detection + Auto Quality
Forceware 1 : Standard Settings
Forceware 2 : Edge Enhance. + Noise Red. + Inverse telecine

Note that both high quality and standard quality game settings are listed in the chart above, with Oblivion tested at three quality settings.

Video Quality : Movies

Enabling high-quality DVD viewing under ATI Catalyst Control Center is as easy as turning on automatic 3:2 pull-down detection, which makes us wonder why this option isn’t enabled by default. Nvidia Forceware requires manual selection to best suit the card’s purpose. Analog sliders allow settings between maximum and minimum enhancement, where the driver defaulted to the lowest setting.

Designed for testing high-end home theater displays, the HQV DVD from Silicon Optix assigns numeric values to qualitative observations. Because manual mode selection is required for Forceware drivers, the 7600GT was tested at both its base setting and with full enhancements/inverse telecine enabled.

Silicon Optix HQV DVD Performance Results
Test X1950XTX (Auto) X1900GT (Auto) 7600GT (Base) 7600GT (Optimized)
Color Bar (10) 10 10 10 10
Jaggies 1 (5) 5 5 3 3
Jaggies 2 (5) 3 3 3 3
Flag (10) 5 5 5 5
Picture Detail (10) 0 0 0 10
Noise Reduction (10) 10 10 5 5
Motion Adaptive NR (10) 5 5 5 5
3:2 Detection (10) 5 0 0 10
Film Cadence (8 tests x5) 40 40 0 40
H. Text Crawl (10) 10 10 10 0
V. Text Crawl (10) 10 10 10 0
Totals (130 max) 103 98 51 91

A simple explanation of scoring differences is more practical than 100 medium resolution screen shots :

Color Bar Test : All three cards showed the smallest bars well, without flickering.

Jaggies Pattern 1 : Scan lines first appears on the X1900GT and X1950XTX after the bar reached 10 degrees to horizontal, while the 7600GT exhibited scan lines as the bar first approached 10 degrees to horizontal. The actual difference is approximately two degrees, but this is the barrier at which the test defines three or five points.

Flag Test : The X1900GT and X1950XTX showed a softened background without noticeable interlacing. The 7600GT also exhibited the same behavior using base settings, while its optimized settings sharpened the background and introduced very slight scan lines.

Picture Detail Test : All three cards initially exhibited a softened background, but selecting optimum settings allowed the 7600GT to pass.

Noise Reduction Test : The X1900GT and X1950XTX eliminated analog noise from the analog-to-digital converted video segments. The 7600GT left some noise in background colors (sky) using both driver settings.

Motion Adaptive Noise Reduction Test : The X1900GT and X1950XTX showed minor blur around the moving object (a roller coaster). The 7600GT exhibited background noise (both settings).

3:2 Detection : The X1950XTX eliminated moiré in slightly less than half a second. Though based on the same core technology, the X1900GT failed to perform 3:2 detection promptly. The 7600GT showed constant moiré with inverse telecine disabled (base setting) and no moiré after enabling it.

Film Cadence Tests : The X1900GT and X1950XTX passed all eight tests with no moiré pattern or interlacing problems. The 7600GT exhibited a moiré pattern on the newspaper using base settings, but eliminated it after enabling inverse telecine.

Horizontal Text Crawl : The X1900GT and X1950XTX showed smoothly scrolling text with well defined edges and no interlacing in the background image. The 7600GT showed smoothly scrolling text without background interlacing at its base setting, but added noticeable background interlacing after optimizations were enabled.

Vertical Text Crawl : The X1900GT and X1950XTX displayed smoothly scrolling text on a clear background, as did the 7600GT at its base setting. Enabling advanced 7600GT driver features introduced a significant amount of minor background noise, with a loss in detail.

The 7600GT exhibited well-defined edges surrounding the text (no blurring) in both scrolling text tests, but showed significant noise in the text color. The HQV DVD scorecard does not account for such behavior, so no additional points were forfeited.

Create a new thread in the US Reviews comments forum about this subject
This thread is closed for comments
No comments yet
Comment from the forums
    Your comment