Drivers Improve WindowsXP Service Pack 2 FireWire

Test Setup

Two Pentium 4 PCs were used for the test, each equipped with an IEEE 1394b card from the FireWire DV PCI Kit from Trust . The following table shows the setup of both systems in detail:

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Test PC 1
Mainboard/bareboneMSI MEGA-PC-645
ChipsetSIS 645
ProcessorIntel Pentium 4 2.53 GHz
Graphics cardSIS 645 (Savage 4)
Test PC 2
Mainboard/bareboneMSI 845PE-Neo 2
ChipsetIntel 845PE
ProcessorIntel Pentium 4 2.6 GHz
Graphics cardATI Radeon 9800
Shared hardware
Memory512 MByte DDR400 from Memory-Solutions
Mass storage120 GB Hitachi hard drive
Optical driveLG GSA-4082B DVD burner
Operating systemMS Windows XP with SP1
Input devicesLogitech MX-700 and Cordless Desktop Pro keyboard
LoudspeakerLogitech Z-680 THX certified sound system
Monitor2x LG Flatron L2010P, 20.1" TFT

To connect the two test PCs a 4.5 m long FireWire cable (6-pin on both sides) and an equally long IEEE 1394b cable from Hama were used for each. We measured throughput with SiSoft Sandra 2004 and NetIO. As these are synthetic benchmarks, we first of all carried out a manual test to determine a value close to reality. To do this we copied a 7.65 GB DVD image from one computer to the other and timed the operation. In order to obtain error-free measurements we deactivated the benchmarks and all other network connections and pulled the cables during the operation.

Windows XP And 1394 Networks

In general Windows has trouble with networks based on FireWire: because of the small number of users, the software giant appears to receive little in the way of feedback. In fact, a connection between the 1394 communication partners is often lacking entirely. This could be because of low-grade cables, incompatibility between the hardware used (seldom) or driver problems. Many IEEE1394 drivers do not support all functions of certain cards or chipsets - or at least not correctly.

During the test, the Texas Instruments driver that Windows had automatically allocated to the 1394 adapter had to be replaced by an OHCI driver from VIA to enable setup of a stable network connection via IEEE 1394a (!) at 400 MBit/s. It frequently pays off to disconnect other network connections - Ethernet, for example - as conflicts may otherwise arise in the allocation of IP addresses. In the test, it was enough to disconnect the computer from the local network.

During the test all other network connections were deactivated and unplugged

  • duxducis
    it's bad that i am forced to buy fire wire to get video from my camera, and fact that it cost 30$-%50$ to buy at sore and 5-15$ on web pisses me even more. So i say take you firewire and stick it where sun don't shine. you have failed so stop forcing people and let us use USB for free in peace