Enthusiast 2.5" HDDs: Speed or Capacity?

Samsung Spinpoint M5S (HM250JI): 250 GB, 5,400 RPM

Samsung's HM250JI is the second 2.5" drive model with a standard height of 9.5 mm to reach a total capacity of 250 GB. Although Western Digital beat Samsung to market with the Scorpio WD2500BEVS, Samsung's new top model beats the WD drive in each and every test discipline: 3.1 W vs. 3.4 W maximum power draw; 0.9 W vs. 1.0 W idle power requirement; 17.3 ms vs. 17.8 ms average access time; 10% faster data transfer rates; and slightly better application benchmark results in PCMark 05. All of these figures make very clear that Samsung has created an excellent hard drive, and this becomes even more impressive as you compare its performance with 7,200 RPM drives, which it can compete with in several benchmarks.

One reason why this drive is more energy efficient may be the Serial ATA interface that Samsung chose, which does not support 300 MB/s speeds, but stays at 150 MB/s. As you can also see with the 3.5" desktop hard drive Raptor by Western Digital, the interface hardly has any impact on overall drive performance as long as the bandwidth is sufficient. Once again this unwritten law seems to apply, and it helps to conserve some energy: we haven't seen a single SATA/300 drive that could stay under 1 W idle power.

Tom's Hardware is the leading destination for hardcore computer enthusiasts. We cover everything from processors to 3D printers, single-board computers, SSDs and high-end gaming rigs, empowering readers to make the most of the tech they love, keep up on the latest developments and buy the right gear. Our staff has more than 100 years of combined experience covering news, solving tech problems and reviewing components and systems.