Best Hard Drives 2026 — The best HDDs for desktop PCs, NAS, and more, based on our extensive benchmarking

Best Hard Drives
(Image credit: Tom's Hardware)

Mechanical hard drives might seem like ancient technology, but there are still many places where they provide 'good enough' performance, and they easily offer the most amount of storage for the price. These devices still store the lion's share of data around the world, but recent demand spikes driven by AI data centers have put us firmly in the midst of shortages, and now prices are exponentially higher than normal. That makes finding a reasonably-priced hard drive all the more difficult, but we've compiled the list below to help you navigate the crisis and find the best deals possible. Our recommendations are based on in-depth benchmarking and our extensive library of reviews, ensuring you can make the best purchasing decision possible.

You do not always need the fast access that the best SSDs are designed to provide, and an HDD's sequential performance is plenty for streaming and other tasks. There are still a lot of hard drives to choose from, so we’ve tested multiple drives in our labs to help make sure you pick the right one for your needs.

TOPICS
Paul Alcorn
Editor-in-Chief

Paul Alcorn is the Editor-in-Chief for Tom's Hardware US. He also writes news and reviews on CPUs, storage, and enterprise hardware.

With contributions from
  • ajtatum
    Honestly, I can't believe you don't consider the Toshiba N300 HDD as the best for NAS devices. According to HDD reports, they have a much lower failure rate than WD Red drives and a bit lower than Seagate. Additionally, Toshiba N300 drives typically have more cache than either Seagate or WD Red. They have a higher TBW test and an awesome warranty. I've had WD Red drives fail me so much in the past that I don't even consider them, and the sentiment is the same with many NAS websites like NAS Compares. Seagate is just more widely known and have more marketing dollars to make people believe their drives are superior, whereas Toshiba doesn't need to do the marketing as anyone who's done their research would be able to see that Toshiba N300 drives are high quality, last long, and are less expensive than Seagate.
    Reply
  • Uberwolf
    My experience over 40 years has been, between the typical, WD and Seagate I have had about the same issues, with Seagate being a tad more reliable and expansions disks(USB) being the least reliable. Have had minimal experience with Toshiba.
    Reply
  • nerevah
    So when crypto was hot and everybody was farming, I gave it a shot at farming Chia (a crypto currency that needed HDDs to farm).
    Out of my 20 WD and 18 Seagate HDDs, 5 of the Seagate HDDs broke in less than a year, with no WD HDDs failing until now (3 years later).
    Seagate also refused to honor the warranty on their HDDs as they were shucked from external USB enclosures. They eventually gave in and replaced 3 of their HDDs after threatening them with legal actions.
    NEVER SEAGATE AGAIN!
    PS: I sold all the Seagate HDDs and the WD ones are still working without any problem in my NAS.
    Reply
  • breezeman
    This list makes little to no sense when looking at the pros and cons of allof the drives. You list WD Blacks 256mb cache as an advantqage but then list Seagates Exos line 256mb cache as a disadvantage. The Exos has a sustained write of 260mbs, so does the wd black but you havent mentioned that either. Also in the description section of the Exos drives you say that the drives dont reach 22TB when they definatly do. I have 4x 22TB 22x Exos drives running as we speak. In my experience the Exos line is far an away more reliable than the WD Black.

    This list is not helpful, misleading and shotty in its research of the available hardware. I hope that anyone reading the article scrolls down to the comments to see what others and I have mentioned. Do better, this is a garbage post.
    Reply
  • TheBeastFromOz
    ajtatum said:
    Honestly, I can't believe you don't consider the Toshiba N300 HDD as the best for NAS devices. According to HDD reports, they have a much lower failure rate than WD Red drives and a bit lower than Seagate. Additionally, Toshiba N300 drives typically have more cache than either Seagate or WD Red. They have a higher TBW test and an awesome warranty. I've had WD Red drives fail me so much in the past that I don't even consider them, and the sentiment is the same with many NAS websites like NAS Compares. Seagate is just more widely known and have more marketing dollars to make people believe their drives are superior, whereas Toshiba doesn't need to do the marketing as anyone who's done their research would be able to see that Toshiba N300 drives are high quality, last long, and are less expensive than Seagate.
    I've had a total of two HDD fail in the last 10 years, both WD Red drives. One of them, a 10TB, was only 3 years old and had just been used to store my movie collection. It started to fail, so I quickly replaced it with a Seagate, never had a failure of those, although I do tend to retire my drives at 10 years/50,000 hours, whichever happens first. The WD Reds are total crap, in my limited experience, and glad to see others have found the same. Never seen the Toshiba drives for sale here in Oz, the few suppliers that list them have them as out of stock, so assume they are no longer available here.
    Reply
  • SomeoneElse23
    TheBeastFromOz said:
    I've had a total of two HDD fail in the last 10 years, both WD Red drives. One of them, a 10TB, was only 3 years old and had just been used to store my movie collection. It started to fail, so I quickly replaced it with a Seagate, never had a failure of those, although I do tend to retire my drives at 10 years/50,000 hours, whichever happens first. The WD Reds are total crap, in my limited experience, and glad to see others have found the same. Never seen the Toshiba drives for sale here in Oz, the few suppliers that list them have them as out of stock, so assume they are no longer available here.
    Any drive with less than 5 year warranty isn't worth my time.
    Reply
  • Trevor Dennis
    My main worry with HDDs is reliability. I have had several fail over the years, but never an SSD, NVMe drive. 24TB is a lot of data to back up! So I'd be looking for data on how long a particular drive is going to last.
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    Trevor Dennis said:
    My main worry with HDDs is reliability. I have had several fail over the years, but never an SSD, NVMe drive. 24TB is a lot of data to back up! So I'd be looking for data on how long a particular drive is going to last.
    Drives die.
    Be it HDD, SSD, whatever....

    I've personally had both die.

    The only thing you should be doing is a good backup routine.
    Keeping data on a single device, no matter what type, is foolish.
    Reply