New Microsoft ads tout unavailable Recall feature, don't mention it was indefinitely delayed due to privacy concerns

Recall Ad from Microsoft
(Image credit: Tom's Hardware)

"Meet your new photographic memory," the ad, which has been running on Facebook and X, says. In the 12-second Facebook version, you see a man use Microsoft's Recall app to search for "where'd I see that cute pink creature thing" and then get a picture of an Axolotl. The commercial closes with the words "Recall what you've seen instantly" emblazoned on top of the man using a laptop and in front of a big picture of the creature.

This all sounds like a compelling reason to buy a Copilot+ PC. The only problem: Recall has been indefinitely delayed for weeks, with Microsoft even removing access to the tool from Windows Insiders after an overwhelming flood of negative press and user feedback. Because it takes screen shots of just about everything you do, Recall was plagued with privacy risks and fears from the moment it was announced, with even some governments rallying against it.

TOPICS
Sunny Grimm
Contributing Writer

Sunny Grimm is a contributing writer for Tom's Hardware. He has been building and breaking computers since 2017, serving as the resident youngster at Tom's. From APUs to RGB, Sunny has a handle on all the latest tech news.

  • kyzarvs
    Because no tech company runs on "It's better to ask forgiveness than permission" at all...
    Reply
  • Math Geek
    they have to get the propoganda machine rolling for a while so folks can used to the idea. some nice happy, pretty people living their BEST life due to this feature.

    couple months from now, the people will be screaming for it instead of refusing to use it!!
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    More like because no tech company does it better than Microsoft when it comes to spending a fortune on development of flawed and/or unpopular features, and then does everything they can to keep those features out there except actually fix them (or admit they were a waste and sunset them), all while ignoring things that people beg them to either implement or fix.

    In an age where there are fewer barriers to moving to Mac or Linux than ever, Microsoft seems to be doing everything they can to push them to alternative systems short of officially releasing Microsoft 365 for Linux...
    Reply
  • ThomasKinsley
    Setting privacy concerns aside, I don't see this as a useful feature that I would often access. Usually when I want to look up something from the past it's 6-18 months ago, which is far outside of Recall's boundaries.
    Reply
  • pixelpusher220
    ThomasKinsley said:
    Setting privacy concerns aside, I don't see this as a useful feature that I would often access. Usually when I want to look up something from the past it's 6-18 months ago, which is far outside of Recall's boundaries.
    My description is "This isn't tech, this is marketing thinking their on the Enterprise D". That said, having the ability to describe in plain words and find it 8 months later entirely is a logical extension of both search and backup concepts.

    M$ implementation here is on par for their customer-last stupidity though.
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    ThomasKinsley said:
    Setting privacy concerns aside, I don't see this as a useful feature that I would often access. Usually when I want to look up something from the past it's 6-18 months ago, which is far outside of Recall's boundaries.

    That's the biggest thing that makes Recall flawed. Even if you let it eat an enormous amount of space on your drive, 10-15% of its capacity depending on your setting, it's barely going to reach back that far. To quote Microsoft:

    The default allocation for Recall on a device with 256 GB will be 25 GB, which can store approximately 3 months of snapshots.

    So if it takes 25GB to store 3 months worth of Recall data, it will take 50GB to store 6 months (512GB+ drive required), and 100GB to store a year (1TB+ drive required). Of course they're probably basing that on something like 40 hours of use per week, like a business computer. That's a -huge- amount of space for a feature you will likely use once in a blue moon, not to mention it's going to inevitably have a marked effect on battery life since it takes screenshots every 5 seconds then has to scan, analyze, and import everything from them into a database which is then encrypted.

    Personally I think they'd get more use out of finding out a way to bypass Chromium's 90 day history limit and let Edge remember history until you clear it, like Firefox can, so you can easily find things from potentially years ago with very minimal resource usage.
    Reply
  • ThomasKinsley
    Alvar Miles Udell said:
    So if it takes 25GB to store 3 months worth of Recall data, it will take 50GB to store 6 months (512GB+ drive required), and 100GB to store a year (1TB+ drive required). Of course they're probably basing that on something like 40 hours of use per week, like a business computer. That's a -huge- amount of space for a feature you will likely use once in a blue moon, not to mention it's going to inevitably have a marked effect on battery life since it takes screenshots every 5 seconds then has to scan, analyze, and import everything from them into a database which is then encrypted.
    What makes this worse is that they planned to use this space at a time when companies are increasingly selling devices with soldered storage for a ridiculous premium simply because they know that you are not able to upgrade it yourself.
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    ThomasKinsley said:
    What makes this worse is that they planned to use this space at a time when companies are increasingly selling devices with soldered storage for a ridiculous premium simply because they know that you are not able to upgrade it yourself.

    Especially since Microsoft did not require a 512GB drive as minimum for a Copilot+ PC, so if you take a 256GB drive, subtract the 40GB+ of Windows, easily 10GB+ (more likely 20GB+) for just your office and productivity programs, then tack on 25GB on top of that for Recall, that's 30% of your space gone before you even do anything.

    For reference my Windows & Program Files folders (no games), total a bit over 80GB
    Reply
  • vijosef
    It can even remember memories you never had.
    Reply
  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    vijosef said:
    It can even remember memories you never had.

    So does Google, they call them "Sponsored Results".
    Reply