ATi brings out some big guns for this comparative test. The X2-256t houses the best graphics chip that the manufacturer has to offer. To permit the high clock rates, ATi equips its graphics card with a sophisticated cooling system.
Conversely, NVIDIA makes a modest first impression with its Quadro FX 1100, which is a mid-range processor, has half as much memory as on the X2-256(t) and offers no cooling for the memory modules.
However, appearances can be deceptive. The benchmarks confirm that Quadro FX 1100 achieves the best benchmark values within the mid-range category. In addition, NVIDIA has no qualms about offering this product at a low price. Due to the excellent price/performance ratio, the Quadro FX 1100 justifiably earns itself the Editor's Choice.
The Fire GL X2-256t lags slightly behind. It only keeps up by using massive computing power whereas NVIDIA easily scores with a product that is equipped with a technically inferior chip. In theory, the X2-256t should however compete in the high-end category alongside the FX 2000 and FX 3000. Consequently, we suspect that ATi has assigned too few resources for its OpenGL driver team. In contrast to the mainstream graphics focusing on Direct3D, with OpenGL, a great deal more input is required. Nevertheless, ATi seems to be aware of this problem and attempts to offset the untapped performance potential by offering an acceptable price - to the detriment of its own margins.
|Product||Video Outputs||Digital TMDS Displays||Stereo Connector||Framelock / Genlock||Space req.||Aux. Power Connector||Memory|
|ATi FireGL X2-256||DVI-I + DVI-I||2 single link||no||no||1 slot||yes||256 MB|
|ATi FireGL X2-256t||DVI-I + DVI-I||2 single link||no||no||1 slot||yes||256 MB|
|NVIDIA Quadro FX 1000||DVI-I + DVI-I||2 single link||yes||no||1 slot||yes||128 MB|
|NVIDIA Quadro FX 1100||DVI-I + DVI-I||2 single link||yes||no||1 slot||yes||128 MB|
- No Major Innovations
- Test Candidates In Detail
- Ati Driver
- NVIDIA/PNY Quadro FX 1100: Light Flexing Of The Muscles
- NVIDIA Driver
- The Key Data At A Glance
- Casing Design - A Clear Emphasis On Serviceability
- Test Configuration
- Viewperf 7.1.1 (Synthetic)
- 3D Studio Max 4.2.6 (Application)
- Special 3DSM Plug-in Driver Increase Performance
- Solidworks 2003 SP5.5 (Application)
- Price Comparison And Rating
- Cooling: Gentle Breeze To Cool A Hot Head