Pixel Shader Quality, Continued
Click for uncompressed PNG image!
In this image, our character is looking straight down at two slanted ramps and with a pedestal in the middle. NVIDIA and ATi produce the same scene.
Click for uncompressed PNG image!
Again, the pipes displayed here show no sign of being rendered differently by either card.
Click for uncompressed PNG image!
Our the protagonist is standing in front of a metal wall. Again, both cards return identical results.
The shader-optimizations in NVIDIA's drivers don't seem to reduce the image quality in either Tomb Raider: Angel of Darkness or Halo - Combat Evolved. At least we were able to spot any detrimental influence.
Questionable Optimizations In ATi's Drivers?
Earlier this year, NVIDIA drew a lot of flak over a number of questionable optimizations in their drivers for 3DMark 2003 - optimizations which could definitely be called cheats. It was in response to this that NVIDIA came up with the guidelines pertaining to performance optimizations mentioned above. Laudably, we haven't been able to make out any "violations" of the new rules in the new driver v52.16 - at least so far.
ATi, on the other hand, repeatedly claimed that their drivers implemented no illegitimate optimizations. The accusations leveled against ATi at NVIDIA's Editors' Day two days ago thus become that much more serious. Epic's Mark Rein confirmed that in some cases, high-res detail textures were not displayed in some areas by ATi's drivers and that standard, lower-res textures are used instead. Randy Pitchford of the Halo development team also mentioned that there were optimizations present in ATi's drivers which are detrimental to Halo's image quality. However, Randy didn't want to go into more detail here. Finally, Massive's new DX9 benchmark, AquaMark 3, also displayed some irregularities of ATi drivers in the overdraw test.
Here is a list of accusations we were able to confirm: