We tried to install Windows 11 on Raspberry Pi 5 — lack of internet connectivity left us stuck
Windows 11 — Airgap Edition
It hasn't taken too long for the Windows on Raspberry community to get Windows 11 running on the Raspberry Pi 5. Yes, the flagship Raspberry Pi with a quad-core 2.4 GHz CPU and up to 8GB of RAM can now run Windows 11, with some caveats. We watched a few videos from LeePSPVideo and followed the guidance, but our success was short lived.
The first big hurdle that we faced was using a UEFI BIOS firmware that was able to boot Windows 11. For that we followed the instructions in the Windows on Raspberry (Pi) GitHub repository to create a microSD card with the UEFI BIOS. We successfully booted the Raspberry Pi 5 using this BIOS and had a poke around inside to get a feel for how it works.
Our curiosity satisfied, we downloaded the WoR project's Raspberry Imager, a tool which automates the installation of Windows 10 and 11 for the Raspberry Pi and other single board computers.
Before we used the tool, we needed to obtain a legal Windows 11 image and once again WoR had a tool to streamline the process. Note that this download may be flagged as dangerous by your browser, so make every effort to confirm its legitimacy before continuing with the download.
Starting up the WoR Raspberry Imager, we went through the motions to create a Windows 11 installation on a spare NVMe drive — a drive that was known to work with the Raspberry Pi 5. Installation was a breeze, if a little slow, but we soon had Windows 11 ready for use on the Raspberry Pi 5.
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
We dropped the drive into the waiting Pimoroni NVMe Base and made sure that the microSD card was inserted. First, we booted it up and we saw "The Raspberry". The system then attempted to boot, but after a long wait (10-15 minutes), there was nothing. Was it the drive? No. This same drive worked fine with Raspberry Pi OS. We still tried another drive, but alas we were met with the same failure.
From the Raspberry Pi 4 onwards we have been able to boot from a USB 3 drive and the Raspberry Pi 5 is no different. We removed the NVMe Base and the drive. Put the drive in a USB to NVMe adapter, and met the same issue as before. Undeterred, we created a fresh install drive and retried the USB method, it worked! Soon we would have Windows 11 running on the Raspberry Pi 5!
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.
The Airgap widens!
The post-install Windows 11 setup procedure is pretty straightforward. Get the user's location, locale, keyboard and name. Then connect to the Internet, link to your Microsoft account and download the updates. We thought that we could just connect to the Internet. Surely, Ethernet would work. Long story short: nope. Ethernet and Wi-Fi were both failures.
Watching LeePSPVideo's YouTube video explained that Wi-Fi, Ethernet, Bluetooth and audio were not working with Windows 11 on the Raspberry Pi 5. This meant that USB dongles were needed. I tried over a dozen Wi-Fi dongles, but none worked. An old Linksys USB to 10/100 Ethernet also failed to work. We needed another means to finish the setup!
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Following our guide on how to install Windows 11 without a Microsoft account, we managed to bypass that part of the setup and finally reach the Windows 11 desktop. But, without internet access we are left with a rather lovely-looking brick.
This isn't the end of our adventure with Windows 11 on the Raspberry Pi 5. Once the WoR project has updated firmware / drivers for the Raspberry Pi 5 we shall go back and see if we can make the Raspberry Pi 5 into a low-cost, Arm-based desktop PC.
In the past we have installed Windows 10 on a Raspberry Pi 4 and have even managed to make Windows 11 work with a Raspberry Pi 4. So we know that it is possible to get a working install, and we know that the WoR community will be hard at work to make it possible.
Les Pounder is an associate editor at Tom's Hardware. He is a creative technologist and for seven years has created projects to educate and inspire minds both young and old. He has worked with the Raspberry Pi Foundation to write and deliver their teacher training program "Picademy".
-
Alvar "Miles" Udell Things that make you go "why". You can get a low end laptop like the Lenovo Slim 3 with 8GB RAM, 2+4 core CPU, and 256GB SSD for $300 on sale right now. Even assuming Windows 11 worked perfectly on the Raspberry Pi, would you really recommend it for any purpose over a cheap laptop?Reply
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1762582-REG/lenovo_82x70005us_15_6_ideapad_slim_3.html -
artk2219 Reply
They likely wouldn't, but its a fun experiment none the less, its more along the lines of "lets see if we can do this" as opposed to "you should totally do this".Alvar Miles Udell said:Things that make you go "why". You can get a low end laptop like the Lenovo Slim 3 with 8GB RAM, 2+4 core CPU, and 256GB SSD for $300 on sale right now. Even assuming Windows 11 worked perfectly on the Raspberry Pi, would you really recommend it for any purpose over a cheap laptop?
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1762582-REG/lenovo_82x70005us_15_6_ideapad_slim_3.html -
Alvar "Miles" Udell Replyartk2219 said:They likely wouldn't, but its a fun experiment none the less, its more along the lines of "lets see if we can do this" as opposed to "you should totally do this".
I don't think so, going by what he said at the end:
Once the WoR project has updated firmware / drivers for the Raspberry Pi 5 we shall go back and see if we can make the Raspberry Pi 5 into a low-cost, Arm-based desktop PC.
It looks as if he is attempting to go beyond "let's see if we can do this" and into the realm of "Let's do this for a specific reason", namely "a low cost ARM based desktop PC". -
SonoraTechnical Reply
Umm.... 'because we can'.... or at least 'we think we can'. holy cow if you don't get that, I'm not sure why you hang around hardware/software forums... LOL..Alvar Miles Udell said:Things that make you go "why". You can get a low end laptop like the Lenovo Slim 3 with 8GB RAM, 2+4 core CPU, and 256GB SSD for $300 on sale right now. Even assuming Windows 11 worked perfectly on the Raspberry Pi, would you really recommend it for any purpose over a cheap laptop?
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1762582-REG/lenovo_82x70005us_15_6_ideapad_slim_3.html -
bit_user Reply
I priced out an 8 GB Pi 5 + case + heatsink + power supply + 256 GB SDXC card and it comes to about $130. Your $300 laptop is about 2.3 times as expensive. For someone of reasonable means, $300 is not a lot to spend on a computer. However, the mission of the Pi foundation was to create a widely-accessible computing platform.Alvar Miles Udell said:Things that make you go "why". You can get a low end laptop like the Lenovo Slim 3 with 8GB RAM, 2+4 core CPU, and 256GB SSD for $300 on sale right now. Even assuming Windows 11 worked perfectly on the Raspberry Pi, would you really recommend it for any purpose over a cheap laptop?
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1762582-REG/lenovo_82x70005us_15_6_ideapad_slim_3.html
Schools buy these which might lack the budgets to buy full-fledged PCs for every student, particularly if they're in developing countries. So, don't be too dismissive of the price difference. Granted, they'd need monitor, keyboard, and mouse, but if you've already got those or can get cheap used ones, then the price savings is potentially a big deal.
Secondly, I'm wary of citing the "on sale" price of computers. Sure, you can often find last year's models at a discount, but not always and particularly if you need to buy large quantities of the same exact thing. The sort of bulk discounts that institution can get on new equipment isn't as big as the sort of inventory liquidation deals like you cited there. -
KraakBal As to "why", Microsoft needs to desperately get windows ready for Arm in general, ever since the Apple M1.Reply
Apple has proven that Arm laptops are viable and can be performant, while giving unprecedented battery life. Mainly that.
Qualcomm is due to release the Snapdragon X Elite soon, and afaik that is the first serious attempt to create a working windows arm laptop that does not suck (finally)
But to me it will all depend on if they can make something like Rosetta 2 that will enable most old x86 and x64 software to work out of the box and not perform too badly.
I am not confident that that will work well initially and there are other problems like Win11 being still too bulky for Arm, drivers are terrible and doesn't look like they can be converted easily to arm, etc.
But if the snapdragon is actually good and Linux works well on it, I cannot wait for a 18-24 hour laptop for videos and typing. -
bit_user Reply
IMO, it's not a "what would you do?" sort of question. I already agreed that, for someone of means, the laptop is the better option. My point was that many people or institutions would be in a situation of not being able to afford even the $300 price tag.Deleted member 2824971 said:On paper, I'd have to agree with Miles here. -
bit_user Reply
Where/how can you personally own one of those??Deleted member 2824971 said:But again, that would be mostly a curiosity thing, unless I fall for a Graviton system one of these days.
I once thought we would have such a thing, by now.Deleted member 2824971 said:I just hate paying twice for essentially the same capabilities, when I really just want to be able to dock my smartphone into the touchpad area of a laptop shell for desktop work. -
AlskiOnTheWeb I bought an 8GB RAM 256GB SSD Simodewa mini PC with an Intel N95 ... for $110!!!!! It came with Windows 11 ... runs perfectly. Why in the world would I ever pay for a RPi 5 to do that same thing? Price wise, the Pi won't stand up even ... nor performance wise ... so why oh why?Reply -
bit_user Reply
I'd be skeptical about that Windows license. ...and about that SSD, too.AlskiOnTheWeb said:I bought an 8GB RAM 256GB SSD Simodewa mini PC with an Intel N95 ... for $110!!!!! It came with Windows 11 ... runs perfectly.
I also doubt that such deals aren't mostly due to products made for the internal Chinese market being liquidated because the economy there is worse than expected. I think it reflects a market that's not "normal".
Well, for one thing, there should be a Pi 5-grade compute module, at some point. Those are considerably cheaper. Also, some people might need or want Windows/ARM for testing or development.AlskiOnTheWeb said:Why in the world would I ever pay for a RPi 5 to do that same thing? Price wise, the Pi won't stand up even ... nor performance wise ... so why oh why?